Godlike Productions - Discussion Forum
Users Online Now: 2,255 (Who's On?)Visitors Today: 1,079,972
Pageviews Today: 1,802,489Threads Today: 727Posts Today: 12,990
05:42 PM


Rate this Thread

Absolute BS Crap Reasonable Nice Amazing
 

Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.

 
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 8929091
United States
10/13/2012 03:04 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
bump
TeamReaper

User ID: 22030141
United States
10/13/2012 03:24 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Think here is the reference to rice and also the reason they stated about going to the library (implying an old book)
Look at the table of contents and then go to page 92 -
Geological Survey water-supply paper, Volume 1364:
[link to books.google.com]

The above link references work by Fisk, specifically his fracture pattern. you will want to see this - Louisiana Chenier Plain Geological Investigation by Harold N. Fisk (This is a scan of an almost impossible to obtain 1948 US Army Corps of Engineers report by Harold N. Fisk on the geology of the Louisiana Chenier Plain):
[link to www.scribd.com]


Fisk fracture pattern (notice were they are in relation to the sinkhole):
[link to ars.els-cdn.com]

[link to ars.els-cdn.com]


Geology of Fort Polk Region, Louisiana:
[link to www.scribd.com]

Last Edited by TeamReaper on 10/13/2012 03:25 AM
In every operation, whether planning it or executing it, you can never count on luck; but you have to accept it, and recognize it when it’s there.
-Major ******, U-2 Pilot/Instructor/Flight Commander
TeamReaper

User ID: 22030141
United States
10/13/2012 03:37 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
not sure if posted (image is interesting for those unclear of the fracturing:

U.S. Government Confirms Link Between Earthquakes and Hydraulic Fracturing
[link to www.informantnews.com]
In every operation, whether planning it or executing it, you can never count on luck; but you have to accept it, and recognize it when it’s there.
-Major ******, U-2 Pilot/Instructor/Flight Commander
remjr1
User ID: 1964511
United States
10/13/2012 09:35 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Awesome find there TeamReaper!
alexisj9

User ID: 1376880
United Kingdom
10/13/2012 10:02 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Those are some good posts teamreaper.
Vision Thing

User ID: 23462738
United States
10/13/2012 10:12 AM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Thanks Team Reaper!
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 24892162
United States
10/13/2012 10:20 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Good morning Everyone, hope all is well and safe in your world. (:
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 23137596
United States
10/13/2012 10:44 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Think here is the reference to rice and also the reason they stated about going to the library (implying an old book)
Look at the table of contents and then go to page 92 -
Geological Survey water-supply paper, Volume 1364:
[link to books.google.com]

The above link references work by Fisk, specifically his fracture pattern. you will want to see this - Louisiana Chenier Plain Geological Investigation by Harold N. Fisk (This is a scan of an almost impossible to obtain 1948 US Army Corps of Engineers report by Harold N. Fisk on the geology of the Louisiana Chenier Plain):
[link to www.scribd.com]


Fisk fracture pattern (notice were they are in relation to the sinkhole):
[link to ars.els-cdn.com]

[link to ars.els-cdn.com]


Geology of Fort Polk Region, Louisiana:
[link to www.scribd.com]
 Quoting: TeamReaper


clappa
Earth Cries

User ID: 1023471
United States
10/13/2012 11:36 AM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Weren't they supposed to start the flaring of the three vent wells yesterday? Anyone know if they did?
Mark 13:20 And except that the Lord had shortened those days, no flesh should be saved: but for the elect's sake, whom he hath chosen, he hath shortened the days.

“Things fall apart; the center cannot hold.” Yeats
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 25192789
United States
10/13/2012 11:59 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Weren't they supposed to start the flaring of the three vent wells yesterday? Anyone know if they did?
 Quoting: Earth Cries


they don't work weekends. they're putting another crawdad on the barbee right now.
remjr1
User ID: 1392221
United States
10/13/2012 12:30 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
".....they're putting another crawdad on the barby"(sorry if I didn't get the quote exact, working off my cell right now) Sounds like they're grubbin with the Aussie's drilling next door ;-)
TeamReaper

User ID: 22030141
United States
10/13/2012 12:44 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Appreciate the thx. Hope you all had time to read the first link, especially the part about salt caverns and change in elevation by 300 feet.
In every operation, whether planning it or executing it, you can never count on luck; but you have to accept it, and recognize it when it’s there.
-Major ******, U-2 Pilot/Instructor/Flight Commander
TeamReaper

User ID: 22030141
United States
10/13/2012 12:48 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
The fisk fracture map looks like there are some just north and south of the sinkhole. Did you catch the part where he discusses that these fractures happen at right angles to the fault?
In every operation, whether planning it or executing it, you can never count on luck; but you have to accept it, and recognize it when it’s there.
-Major ******, U-2 Pilot/Instructor/Flight Commander
Anaiah

User ID: 25470439
United States
10/13/2012 12:49 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
May or may not be connected to the new madrid aspect of all this: Noticing earthquakes in Georgia and North Carolina in the past 12 hours. WTF? With the multiple ones in Missouri, TN, and such the past week, looks a lot out of place. Like foreshadowing or something, I'm not used to hearing about EQ's there so it's odd to me (here in lower Alabama).

Edit to add:

[link to quakes.globalincidentmap.com]

ought to show them a bit longer, at least. Weird.

Last Edited by Anaiah on 10/13/2012 12:49 PM
As above, So below.
miabelieves

User ID: 1468143
United States
10/13/2012 01:08 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
was this posted... [link to leanweb.org]
Analysis of air samples in the Bayou Corne/Grand Bayou area by the Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality demonstrated that the concentrations of toxic chemicals in the air, including Volatile Organic Compounds such as Benzene, Toluene, Ethyl Benzene and Xylene, were below the Louisiana Ambient Air Standards. However, though the concentrations of toxic chemicals were below acceptable standards, health symptoms continue to be experienced and reported by community members.

Locations where odors and health symptoms were reported by community members:

Highway 70 between Bayou Corne and Gator Corner/Stop
Highway 70 and Gumbo Street
Highway 70 between Gumbo Street and Gator Corner/Stop
Gator Corner/Stop
Gumbo Street
Sauce Piquante
Crawfish Stew Street

Time Odors were observed
6:30 AM and 9 PM

Description of Odors
Diesel
Tar
Gas
Burning Trees

[link to www.examiner.com]

if the butane in the sinkhole vicinity exploded, it would meet, according to the National Terror Alert, the definition of a dirty bomb.

"I sought an analysis of the recent DEQ test results from Waligora, who since a stint as a nuclear weapons officer in the U.S. military has been teaching, consulting and testifying as an expert witness in radiation litigation for more than 45 years," asserted Smith Friday.

He expressed concern that the state reported its findings of radium-226 and radium-228 as "below acceptable levels," when in fact, the results were 15 times higher than the state’s own standard for soil contamination.

“Well, once again the Louisiana DEQ is in denial because they don’t know what to do about the radioactive contamination in the Bayou Corne subsidence,” Waligora wrote, adding the following findings:

There are immediate radiation dose concerns, not only cumulative toxin concerns.

[link to theadvocate.com]
Hold on to your undies, it's gonna be a hell of a ride
alexisj9

User ID: 1376880
United Kingdom
10/13/2012 01:32 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Appreciate the thx. Hope you all had time to read the first link, especially the part about salt caverns and change in elevation by 300 feet.
 Quoting: TeamReaper


I've had a quick scan so far, but intend to read it all when the kids are in bed later.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 21268876
United States
10/13/2012 01:57 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
was this posted... [link to leanweb.org]
Analysis of air samples in the Bayou Corne/Grand Bayou area by the Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality demonstrated that the concentrations of toxic chemicals in the air, including Volatile Organic Compounds such as Benzene, Toluene, Ethyl Benzene and Xylene, were below the Louisiana Ambient Air Standards. However, though the concentrations of toxic chemicals were below acceptable standards, health symptoms continue to be experienced and reported by community members.

Locations where odors and health symptoms were reported by community members:

Highway 70 between Bayou Corne and Gator Corner/Stop
Highway 70 and Gumbo Street
Highway 70 between Gumbo Street and Gator Corner/Stop
Gator Corner/Stop
Gumbo Street
Sauce Piquante
Crawfish Stew Street

Time Odors were observed
6:30 AM and 9 PM

Description of Odors
Diesel
Tar
Gas
Burning Trees

[link to www.examiner.com]

if the butane in the sinkhole vicinity exploded, it would meet, according to the National Terror Alert, the definition of a dirty bomb.

"I sought an analysis of the recent DEQ test results from Waligora, who since a stint as a nuclear weapons officer in the U.S. military has been teaching, consulting and testifying as an expert witness in radiation litigation for more than 45 years," asserted Smith Friday.

He expressed concern that the state reported its findings of radium-226 and radium-228 as "below acceptable levels," when in fact, the results were 15 times higher than the state’s own standard for soil contamination.

“Well, once again the Louisiana DEQ is in denial because they don’t know what to do about the radioactive contamination in the Bayou Corne subsidence,” Waligora wrote, adding the following findings:

There are immediate radiation dose concerns, not only cumulative toxin concerns.

[link to theadvocate.com]
 Quoting: miabelieves


Oh my, what a good time to post this.

Hydrogen Sulfide- broad-spectrum poison, nervous system most affected, blocks oxygen from binding and stops cellular respiration.

Benzene- confirmed human carcinogen, leukemia, cancer of the lymph system, lung cancer and bladder cancer

Methylene Chloride- affects central nervous system, liver, cardiovascular system, blood, irritation to skin, eyes, respiratory tract, also cancer hazard.

OKAY, potential cause for nervous system related diseases?? Such as meningitis, chicken pox, and HFMD. Is this why it's slowly getting picked up by msm? Blaming meningitis on some steroid shots that have been used for years as back pain treatment, why now? But could the real reason be from the gasses being released from the ground all along New Madrid fault line?

I was watching a movie on FX last night with mark wahlberg in an m night shamylon (spelling?) about an unknown airborne chemical in the NE that the main characters are perplexed by. In part of the movie they were watching the MSM on tv, two guys sitting down were talking about the cause of the airborne invisible illness. The guest on the show considered it the beginning of the end, but the opposing opinion from the other guy said it was planned by our own government. Both are logical in some sense according to the time we are in.
I just thought how much of a coincidence it was that movie of all movies was playing and that same night I found out the information about these chemical definitions I posted.
RadChick

User ID: 24892162
United States
10/13/2012 02:01 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Cavern wall collapse confirmed:
Published today, 10/13 at 10:13 am (?)

By CAIN BURDEAU / Associated Press / WWLTV

NEW ORLEANS (AP) -- A collapsed wall of an abandoned underground salt cavern where a Texas company had operated is being blamed with causing a sinkhole and contaminating an aquifer in a sparsely populated area of swampland west of New Orleans.

The Louisiana Office of Conservation said new data shows that a series of problems -- natural gas bubbling up in local bayous and a growing sinkhole that's swallowed about 4 acres of swamp forest -- are linked to the collapse of a side wall of an underground salt cavern that Houston-based Texas Brine Co. LLC operated. The company extracted brine and piped it to nearby petrochemical facilities.

Late Thursday, Conservation Commissioner James H. Welsh ordered Texas Brine to make sure the collapsed cavern does not worsen and to do more testing, monitoring and analysis to understand what is happening underground.


[link to www.wwltv.com]
Founder of Nuked Radio

Thread: MAYDAY: The Wigner Effect

”To argue with a person who has renounced the use of reason is like administering medicine to the dead.”
~Thomas Paine
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1443074
United States
10/13/2012 02:14 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
I watched it too, nice timing huh?
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 21268876
United States
10/13/2012 02:19 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
I watched it too, nice timing huh?
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1443074


Yeah all I could think about were current events while watching.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 25192789
United States
10/13/2012 02:30 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
".....they're putting another crawdad on the barby"(sorry if I didn't get the quote exact, working off my cell right now) Sounds like they're grubbin with the Aussie's drilling next door ;-)
 Quoting: remjr1 1392221


oh, and let's not be forgetting all the frog giggers down that ways too...
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 25192789
United States
10/13/2012 02:33 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
it's it ironic that BP and Transocean are the only
outfit on the planet with the technology to fix this problem.
RadChick

User ID: 24892162
United States
10/13/2012 02:45 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
After Sinkhole Flyover: Strongest odor I have ever experienced in all my time in Louisiana — Intense petroleum fumes hovering directly over community

There is no doubt that the fumes from the sinkhole and bubbling natural gas in the surrounding area have been impacting the community. Local residents have documented this along with their potentially related health symptoms through the Odor and Symptom Log available online here.

[link to enenews.com]
Founder of Nuked Radio

Thread: MAYDAY: The Wigner Effect

”To argue with a person who has renounced the use of reason is like administering medicine to the dead.”
~Thomas Paine
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 25192789
United States
10/13/2012 02:56 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Folks. don't lose sight of the fact that the
sinkhole-and-cavern problem is only a small part
of this whole thing.

the fundamental problem with the "cavern" is that
Texas Brine did not conform to established engineering standards
when they were harvesting the brine from the cavern: they
washed away too much of the salt structure from the sides
of the cavern and thereby weakened the cavern structure
to the point of causing collapse (which in turn puts
the entire Napoleanville Salt Dome complex in jeopardy)

the MOST HUGE part of the problem is that coincidentally with this
salt dome fiasco, a deep reservoir of natural gas has decided
to seep its way to the surface -- and it is this natural
gas which coincidentally filled the Texas Brine "cavern".

But! more importantly, all of this natural gas, which
is leaking up from a reservoir deep in the earth's crust,
is ALSO saturating all of the ground in southern louisiana --
and it is this "natural gas problem" that is the catastrophic component of the whole situation.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 21268876
United States
10/13/2012 03:04 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Folks. don't lose sight of the fact that the
sinkhole-and-cavern problem is only a small part
of this whole thing.

the fundamental problem with the "cavern" is that
Texas Brine did not conform to established engineering standards
when they were harvesting the brine from the cavern: they
washed away too much of the salt structure from the sides
of the cavern and thereby weakened the cavern structure
to the point of causing collapse (which in turn puts
the entire Napoleanville Salt Dome complex in jeopardy)

the MOST HUGE part of the problem is that coincidentally with this
salt dome fiasco, a deep reservoir of natural gas has decided
to seep its way to the surface -- and it is this natural
gas which coincidentally filled the Texas Brine "cavern".

But! more importantly, all of this natural gas, which
is leaking up from a reservoir deep in the earth's crust,
is ALSO saturating all of the ground in southern louisiana --
and it is this "natural gas problem" that is the catastrophic component of the whole situation.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 25192789


Yes look at how many dying trees there are around the sinkhole area. The ground is indeed saturated.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 25192789
United States
10/13/2012 03:06 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Folks. don't lose sight of the fact that the
sinkhole-and-cavern problem is only a small part
of this whole thing.

the fundamental problem with the "cavern" is that
Texas Brine did not conform to established engineering standards
when they were harvesting the brine from the cavern: they
washed away too much of the salt structure from the sides
of the cavern and thereby weakened the cavern structure
to the point of causing collapse (which in turn puts
the entire Napoleanville Salt Dome complex in jeopardy)

the MOST HUGE part of the problem is that coincidentally with this
salt dome fiasco, a deep reservoir of natural gas has decided
to seep its way to the surface -- and it is this natural
gas which coincidentally filled the Texas Brine "cavern".

But! more importantly, all of this natural gas, which
is leaking up from a reservoir deep in the earth's crust,
is ALSO saturating all of the ground in southern louisiana --
and it is this "natural gas problem" that is the catastrophic component of the whole situation.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 25192789


Yes look at how many dying trees there are around the sinkhole area. The ground is indeed saturated.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 21268876


maybe. but we're talking all of southern louisiana (including New Orleans) here bunkie.

can you say: "totally uninhabitable"?
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 21268876
United States
10/13/2012 03:29 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Folks. don't lose sight of the fact that the
sinkhole-and-cavern problem is only a small part
of this whole thing.

the fundamental problem with the "cavern" is that
Texas Brine did not conform to established engineering standards
when they were harvesting the brine from the cavern: they
washed away too much of the salt structure from the sides
of the cavern and thereby weakened the cavern structure
to the point of causing collapse (which in turn puts
the entire Napoleanville Salt Dome complex in jeopardy)

the MOST HUGE part of the problem is that coincidentally with this
salt dome fiasco, a deep reservoir of natural gas has decided
to seep its way to the surface -- and it is this natural
gas which coincidentally filled the Texas Brine "cavern".

But! more importantly, all of this natural gas, which
is leaking up from a reservoir deep in the earth's crust,
is ALSO saturating all of the ground in southern louisiana --
and it is this "natural gas problem" that is the catastrophic component of the whole situation.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 25192789


Yes look at how many dying trees there are around the sinkhole area. The ground is indeed saturated.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 21268876


maybe. but we're talking all of southern louisiana (including New Orleans) here bunkie.

can you say: "totally uninhabitable"?
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 25192789


I can say totally uninhabitable. Well, you said yourself that it is saturated and I am agreeing with you.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 21268876
United States
10/13/2012 03:33 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
was this posted... [link to leanweb.org]
Analysis of air samples in the Bayou Corne/Grand Bayou area by the Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality demonstrated that the concentrations of toxic chemicals in the air, including Volatile Organic Compounds such as Benzene, Toluene, Ethyl Benzene and Xylene, were below the Louisiana Ambient Air Standards. However, though the concentrations of toxic chemicals were below acceptable standards, health symptoms continue to be experienced and reported by community members.

Locations where odors and health symptoms were reported by community members:

Highway 70 between Bayou Corne and Gator Corner/Stop
Highway 70 and Gumbo Street
Highway 70 between Gumbo Street and Gator Corner/Stop
Gator Corner/Stop
Gumbo Street
Sauce Piquante
Crawfish Stew Street

Time Odors were observed
6:30 AM and 9 PM

Description of Odors
Diesel
Tar
Gas
Burning Trees

[link to www.examiner.com]

if the butane in the sinkhole vicinity exploded, it would meet, according to the National Terror Alert, the definition of a dirty bomb.

"I sought an analysis of the recent DEQ test results from Waligora, who since a stint as a nuclear weapons officer in the U.S. military has been teaching, consulting and testifying as an expert witness in radiation litigation for more than 45 years," asserted Smith Friday.

He expressed concern that the state reported its findings of radium-226 and radium-228 as "below acceptable levels," when in fact, the results were 15 times higher than the state’s own standard for soil contamination.

“Well, once again the Louisiana DEQ is in denial because they don’t know what to do about the radioactive contamination in the Bayou Corne subsidence,” Waligora wrote, adding the following findings:

There are immediate radiation dose concerns, not only cumulative toxin concerns.

[link to theadvocate.com]
 Quoting: miabelieves


Oh my, what a good time to post this.

Hydrogen Sulfide- broad-spectrum poison, nervous system most affected, blocks oxygen from binding and stops cellular respiration.

Benzene- confirmed human carcinogen, leukemia, cancer of the lymph system, lung cancer and bladder cancer

Methylene Chloride- affects central nervous system, liver, cardiovascular system, blood, irritation to skin, eyes, respiratory tract, also cancer hazard.

OKAY, potential cause for nervous system related diseases?? Such as meningitis, chicken pox, and HFMD. Is this why it's slowly getting picked up by msm? Blaming meningitis on some steroid shots that have been used for years as back pain treatment, why now? But could the real reason be from the gasses being released from the ground all along New Madrid fault line?

I was watching a movie on FX last night with mark wahlberg in an m night shamylon (spelling?) about an unknown airborne chemical in the NE that the main characters are perplexed by. In part of the movie they were watching the MSM on tv, two guys sitting down were talking about the cause of the airborne invisible illness. The guest on the show considered it the beginning of the end, but the opposing opinion from the other guy said it was planned by our own government. Both are logical in some sense according to the time we are in.
I just thought how much of a coincidence it was that movie of all movies was playing and that same night I found out the information about these chemical definitions I posted.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 21268876


Bump
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 25192789
United States
10/13/2012 03:44 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Folks. don't lose sight of the fact that the
sinkhole-and-cavern problem is only a small part
of this whole thing.

the fundamental problem with the "cavern" is that
Texas Brine did not conform to established engineering standards
when they were harvesting the brine from the cavern: they
washed away too much of the salt structure from the sides
of the cavern and thereby weakened the cavern structure
to the point of causing collapse (which in turn puts
the entire Napoleanville Salt Dome complex in jeopardy)

the MOST HUGE part of the problem is that coincidentally with this
salt dome fiasco, a deep reservoir of natural gas has decided
to seep its way to the surface -- and it is this natural
gas which coincidentally filled the Texas Brine "cavern".

But! more importantly, all of this natural gas, which
is leaking up from a reservoir deep in the earth's crust,
is ALSO saturating all of the ground in southern louisiana --
and it is this "natural gas problem" that is the catastrophic component of the whole situation.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 25192789


Yes look at how many dying trees there are around the sinkhole area. The ground is indeed saturated.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 21268876


maybe. but we're talking all of southern louisiana (including New Orleans) here bunkie.

can you say: "totally uninhabitable"?
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 25192789


I can say totally uninhabitable. Well, you said yourself that it is saturated and I am agreeing with you.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 21268876

i know. i was just trying to emphasize that the PROBLEM
is a hell of a lot more than just some silly cavern and
its daughter sinkhole. (or even the whole damn Napoleanville Salt Dome complex, for that matter)
alexisj9

User ID: 1376880
United Kingdom
10/13/2012 05:16 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Don't make ASSUMPTIONS; try to Understand.
Folks. don't lose sight of the fact that the
sinkhole-and-cavern problem is only a small part
of this whole thing.

the fundamental problem with the "cavern" is that
Texas Brine did not conform to established engineering standards
when they were harvesting the brine from the cavern: they
washed away too much of the salt structure from the sides
of the cavern and thereby weakened the cavern structure
to the point of causing collapse (which in turn puts
the entire Napoleanville Salt Dome complex in jeopardy)

the MOST HUGE part of the problem is that coincidentally with this
salt dome fiasco, a deep reservoir of natural gas has decided
to seep its way to the surface -- and it is this natural
gas which coincidentally filled the Texas Brine "cavern".

But! more importantly, all of this natural gas, which
is leaking up from a reservoir deep in the earth's crust,
is ALSO saturating all of the ground in southern louisiana --
and it is this "natural gas problem" that is the catastrophic component of the whole situation.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 25192789


I agree with you for the most part except for the Texas brine stuff, I think the bottom side of the cavern was melted by external water, either sea water or, the water left over by hydrolic fracturing. I think the second option due to shale coming in with it.

The industry has a good scape goat to pay for everything for the moment, I wonder how many other companies will have expensive bills before this is over.





GLP