REPORT ABUSIVE REPLY
|
Message Subject
|
*****GUNSHOTS HEARD AT POLISH PLANE CRASH SITE!******
|
Poster Handle
|
Anonymous Coward |
Post Content
|
thats the sound of stepping on a dry branch.
its not.
yes it is. I analyzed the formants. It's exactly the sound of wood snapping in a crappy camera microphone.
you sir are an idiot.
nope im a sound engineer and the frequencies simply do not match that of a shotgun going off in a wooded environment, the fact that no reverb is heard backs up this fact
You're a sound engineer just like you're Canadian one minute and British the next.
where/when have i said i was canadian?
THAT sound in the youtube video IS NOT a shotgun. I know enough about this topic to be certain of that.
The guy saying he analyzed the formats and it's the sound of wood snapping posted from a Canadian server. Someone replied "you sir are an idiot" then you answered "nope I'm a sound engineer". And you posted from a British server. You're sloppy, there goes 10% of your shill wage.
I wrote teh first part. there are two independent sound engineers that have experience saying this is not a gunshot but only one saying it's a branch snapping. Listen to the hollow sound it makes. A gunshot would have a much different frequency profile (and as the other engineer says - noticeable reverberation signature)
I own 6 pistols and my friend owns at least that many. I have a .32acp that sounds very much like the sound. Most likely 9x18 or another small caliber.
I also grew up running around in the woods. If that was a branch, the person that stepped on it must have been 400-500 pounds because that's what it would take for a branch to make that much noise and sound like a gun going off.
It sounds very close to the Makarov the German person posted.
You can tell me it's a stick all day long but it's not. it's a gunshot.
I never said it was a stick or a twig or a branch for that matter. I did however say what it was not and that wasa shotgun (silenced [single] or not).
Now you say a Makarov because I have a morning off tomorrow I will analyse some makarov files in various environments and see what my professional opinion is.
My gut tells me it's not a handgun either and for the person above who says its def a gun, what a joker he is. I'm thinking fuselage the more I keep playing it.
Quoting: Anonymous Coward 849944Nobody said it was a shotgun! You are trying to confuse matters. It doesn't even make an ounce of sense for it to be a shotgun, shotguns are very limited use and you don't often see police/military carrying them. Also, you mention silenced shotgun, which is a very rare and ineffective thing. You now say that you are off for the day, I can see why as you have accomplished your goal of confusing matters and causing problems.
|
|
Please verify you're human:
|
|
Reason for reporting:
|