|
REPORT ABUSIVE REPLY
|
|
Message Subject
|
When can we expect to see NIBIRU/PLANET X with the naked eye
|
|
Poster Handle
|
Anonymous Coward |
|
Post Content
|
...
no, there is no gravitational evidence to support a brown dwarf dipping into the mapped solar system. If it were visible and as bright as the religious texts report, there would have been some MAJOR gravitational disturbances that would have had effects on our orbit, along with damn near every other body in the inner solar system.
Brown dwarves are MASSIVE objects. Jupiter has a hell of a pull, and we are talking objects that START at 13 times the mass of jupiter.
Quoting: Anonymous Coward 10231506 "Mapped" or inner solar system is the key phrase here.And also not only, Which I want to clarify does reduce the Nibiru theory (As far as brown dwarfs are concerned) to an absurdity . But as Brown dwarfs as small as 3 to 4 Jupiter masses have been found, which was once thought not possible, there is the possibility and some circumstantial evidence of our Suns binary when one examines periodic comets and Sednas orbit.However Nibirutards hijacking Brown and Whitemore without fully understanding it is just silly . The comet thing isnt as regular as I think you are thinking. Are you talking about the hypothesis that also links the great extinctions on earth with the same cycle? Just one of the many binary theories floating around in more mainstream science, I was speaking more about the Tyche paper, I believe you are referring to Nemesis, However am in no way trying to tie this to Nibiru as a 3600 year orbit. The conversation kinda evolved for me , because so many saying a Binary is not possible for our sun period, and that just is not true. What I was saying is a hypothetical Sedna type object that exists somewhere in between our Suns hypothetical binary and our Sun would be a more reasonable try for Nibiruheads, at least in a "mechanics" sense of the word. However it would have to be a lot longer than 3600 years in its orbit , and of course much much much smaller than a brown dwarf . Stretching my mind as open as I can basically to give some form of benefit of doubt . Tyche was the super jupiter at ~500 AU, yeah? And an object such as the one you are describing in the attempt to give them the benefit of the doubt would have to have an orbital period on the order of tens of thousands of years, as Sedna's orbit is close to 12,000 on its own. The companion would have to be at LEAST that. and, again, I think we agree that this is not something that would be dipping into the inner solar system. Also, while its POSSIBLE for there to be a binary companion, unless it is a brown dwarf, we would be able to see it, even if it were a red dwarf.
|
|
|
Please verify you're human:
|
|
|
Reason for reporting:
|
