|
REPORT COPYRIGHT VIOLATION IN REPLY
|
|
Message Subject
|
Rogue Planets Could Drive By And Scoop Up Life
|
|
Poster Handle
|
Astromut |
|
Post Content
|
don't argue sitchin with me, honey.
Quoting: Mordier L'eft Don't call me "honey." And I'm not arguing "sitchin," I'm simply telling you that what he claimed is not a rogue planet by definition. A planet that orbits a star is not a rogue planet. it goes back to the birth of our system. that's when Nibiru was captured by our system as a rogue planet.
Quoting: l'eftThen it's no longer a rogue planet, it's a captured planet. Regardless of how the claim says it came to be here, it's not a rogue planet. you're the astronomer, you explain uranus on its side, and the chevron scar on miranda.
Quoting: l'eftSimple. The early solar system was a violent place with protoplanets colliding with each other. It does not require the presence of a "rogue planet" nor even a captured planet. Sedna may be an example of a captured planet, though it's only a dwarf planet. Mike Browns take on Sedna: Variations on a theme called Tyche. Has nothing to do with "Nibiru." These are not the same things. Words have meaning, Nibiru suggests a massive planet with an orbital period of 3600 years and therefore a semi-major axis of about 235 AUs and an eccentricity that brings it into the inner solar system, Tyche suggests a massive planet with a semi-major axis measured in the 10's of thousands of AUs, and an eccentricity that does not bring it into the inner solar system.
|
|
|
Please verify you're human:
|
|
|
Reason for copyright violation:
|
