Godlike Productions - Discussion Forum
Users Online Now: 2,200 (Who's On?)Visitors Today: 435,523
Pageviews Today: 700,079Threads Today: 238Posts Today: 3,625
08:37 AM


Back to Forum
Back to Forum
Back to Thread
Back to Thread
REPORT ABUSIVE REPLY
Message Subject Another fail of Poleshit-Nancy - Planet X Moons Visible in Light from Venus!
Poster Handle Astromut
Post Content
...


Pluto is never a naked eye object, nor do you need the Hubble to see it. I have no idea what you're talking about at this point.
 Quoting: Astromut


In 50-60 years you'll know. ;)
 Quoting: Antares~"*"

No, I already know; there's no massive object anywhere near here. The planets are all right where they should be, and in fact at this point I've even directly ruled out the old planet X theory which "only" called for a 4 earth mass object at the outer solar system.
Thread: Robert Harrington's Planet X Does Not Exist
Cute little cryptic games don't fly with me.
 Quoting: Astromut


A hypothetical 4 earth mass planet, but since pluto is the next best thing, hypothetically, it is PlanetX.
 Quoting: Antares~"*"

No, that is not how it works. The whole purpose of the planet X theory was to explain the perceived perturbations of the outer planets, specifically uranus and neptune. Once it was realized that pluto wasn't nearly massive enough, it could not fit the theory and cannot be planet X. Planet X is not just whatever you want it to be, it was a specific theory that turned out to be wrong.
Face it, i'll never waiver my opinion on pluto(aka planetx).
 Quoting: antares

That's fine, but your opinion has nothing to do with reality nor does it have anything to do with what "planet X" actually means.
You can say no all day long and it still won't change the fact that you're basing your assertions on a flawed and deliberately overlooked calculation.
 Quoting: antares

I am basing my assertions on neither. Show me where my calculations are flawed. Pluto is not 4 times earth's mass, nor is it the cause of the previously believed perturbations of Neptune and Uranus, which don't even exist in the first place. I showed all this already, THAT is what planet X was supposed to be. Pluto is not it. End of story.
 
Please verify you're human:




Reason for reporting:







GLP