REPORT ABUSIVE REPLY
|
Message Subject
|
For all you secessiontards, sorry, but there is no legal mechanism that allows a state to secede
|
Poster Handle
|
Anonymous Coward |
Post Content
|
The states voted to enter. They can just vote to leave.
The problem with the Confederate states is that the people weren't allowed to vote to leave.
Quoting: samanthasunflower Yes, we did. Delegates were elected to secession conventions. We wanted out, and it was, and is, legal. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 27484739 This is a total misunderstanding of the Union. First of all, the consitutional convention and the states subsequent ratification post-date the formation of the union. The Union began with the articles of association in 1774. When you create a corporation, which is a seperate legal person, the inception of it is filed with your secretary of states office under articles of association. At this point, the corporation comes into being. It is a single entity. This entity (the Union) later declared independence...entered into a form of government called the articles of confederation...then dissolved that and replaced it with a new constitutional form of government...but it is and always has been one entity. A state can no more secede from the union than a hand or a foot can decide to secede from the body. Their are many parts, but they are all one body. One nation. Indivisible. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 14093935 The Articles of Association did not form the Union, read them. This is an agreement to boycott British goods, not a contract for perpetual union. How you can get that from this document is a mystery. And how you can really believe that the colonies were not legally subject to the British Crown is also a mystery. You logic is flawed and your argument is weak.
|
|
Please verify you're human:
|
|
Reason for reporting:
|