|Users Online Now: 1,655 (Who's On?)||Visitors Today: 288,759|
|Pageviews Today: 413,803||Threads Today: 100||Posts Today: 2,147|
THE JEWISH EXILE THAT NEVER WAS!
User ID: 1279026
11/19/2012 08:12 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
USB 4 PAL GAA Article 01.29.10 The Jewish Exile that Never Was!
THE JEWISH EXILE THAT NEVER WAS!
By: Gulamhusein Abba
Note: Recently I submitted a piece by Mazin Qumsiyeh, PhD to various editors and moderators for
posting on their sites. In it Mazin stated, among other things,” The victimhood pathology started
rather early with the myth of the exodus from Egypt (archeologists and historians have long
shown that this notion of enslavement in Egypt and redemption is simply not consistent with the
facts or the historical record)”.
While some of the editors/moderators published the piece, several rejected it, claiming that Mazin’s
statement about “the myth of the exodus from Egypt” was unsubstantiated and unacceptable. That made
me evaluate the claim and the following article is the outcome of that research.
Even more than the oft averred promise by God to the Jewish people, exile is central to the
Jewish claim on Palestine. Because they were exiled, they have a right to return. (Incidentally,
this is precisely why the Zionists keep denying, in the face of overwhelming evidence to the
contrary, that the Palestinians were forced out of their homes and villages by the Zionists during
the formation of an Israeli state. If they admit that they were forced out, they would have to
admit Palestinians’ right to return. But if the Palestinians, as the Zionists insist, left of their own
accord, they have no such right!)
The Jewish “exile” claim raises two questions. First: Even if they were exiled, and had a right to
return, does that mean they have a right to claim Palestine, or a part of it, as a Jewish state?
Second, the more important one: Were they in fact exiled from Palestine?
Research scholars, several of them Jewish and some of them ardent Zionists, have been asserting
for quite some time that the claim of exile is a myth propagated by the Zionists.
Dr.Mazin Qunsiyeh, PhD, recently wrote : “….archeologists and historians have long shown that
this notion of enslavement in Egypt and redemption is simply not consistent with the facts or the
This is by no means a new or far fetched claim.
Dissertations by Dr. Shlomo Sand and Jeremiah Haber
Dr. Shlomo Sand the author of “Invention of the Jewish People” and an expert on European
history at Tel Aviv University, has claimed in his book that "The Jews were never exiled from
the Holy Land…. most of today’s Jews have no historical connection to the land called Israel”.
His earlier book, “When and How Was The Jewish people Invented”, has been on Israel's
bestseller list for 19 weeks.
Sand annotates what prompted him to write the book: "I started looking in research
studies about the exile from the land - a constitutive event in Jewish history, almost like
the Holocaust. But to my astonishment I discovered that it has no literature. The reason is
that no one exiled the people of the country. The Romans did not exile peoples and
they could not have done so even if they had wanted to. They did not have trains and
trucks to deport entire populations. That kind of logistics did not exist until the 20th
century. From this, in effect, the whole book was born: in the realization that Judaic
society was not dispersed and was not exiled."
The original Jews living in Israel, contrary to the propounded history, were not exiled. Sand
argues that most of the Jews were not exiled by the Romans. They were permitted to remain in
Sand suggests that the story of the exile was a myth promoted by early Christians to recruit Jews
to the new faith. They portrayed that event as a divine punishment imposed on the Jews for
having rejected the Christian gospel. Sand writes that "Christians wanted later generations of
Jews to believe that their ancestors had been exiled as a punishment from God."
Elaborating further, Sand continues: "The supreme paradigm of exile was needed in order to
construct a long-range memory in which an imagined and exiled nation-race was posited as the
direct continuation of 'the people of the Bible' that preceded it."
Jeremiah Haber, an orthodox Zionist and a professor Jewish studies, writing under the nom de
plume Jeremiah (Jerry) Haber, was critical of columnists like Charles Krauthammer and Leonard
Fein. In the July 29, 2007 issue of the Magnes Zionist, Jeremiah admonished the two columnists
for accepting “the myth that the Jews were forcibly expelled from the Land of Israel, and taken
into captivity by the Romans.”
Jeremiah went on to emphasize: “To this day, most lay people, Jews and non-Jews, accept the
myth of the exile, whereas no historian, Jew or non-Jew, takes it seriously.” And to further detox
the seemingly blind addiction to this myth, he presented two assertions: : “The first point to
make is that well before the revolt against Rome in 66-70 c.e., there were Jewish communities
outside Palestine, most notably in Babylonia and in Egypt, but elsewhere as well. References to
the dispersal of the Jewish people throughout the civilized world are found in the book of Esther,
Josephus, and Philo. There is no indication that these communities were small, satellite
“Second, there is no contemporary evidence – i.e., 1st and 2nd centuries c.e. – that anything like
an exile took place. The Romans put down two Jewish revolts in 66-70 c.e. and in 132-135 c.e.
According to Josephus, the rebels were killed, and many of the Jews died of hunger. Some
prisoners were sent to Rome, and others were sold in Libya. But nowhere does Josephus speak of
Jews being taken into exile. As we shall see below, there is much evidence to the contrary. There
was always Jewish emigration from the Land of Israel…..”.
Similarly, in a post dated March 25, 2008 of the Jews Sans Frontieres, it was claimed that there
are “a couple of pervasive racial myths upon which Zionism is founded. One is that of exile and
the other is that of the common origin of the Jewish people…”
Yet another learned critic of the Jewish Exile is Israel Jacob Yuval, director of the
Interdisciplinary Research Center in Jewish Studies, Backenroth Senior Lecturer in Medieval
Jewish Studies. In his book, The Myth of the Jewish Exile from the Land of Israel: A
Demonstration of Irenic Scholarship, Jacob Yuval extended his sincere empathy to the
Palestinians. “On the one hand, I am a Zionist loyal to awareness of the need for the existence of
the State of Israel. On the other hand, I am deeply troubled by the price paid by the Palestinians
for the fulfillment of this dream. Like many others, I desperately seek a fair solution that will
minimize the pain and suffering for both sides”
All this leads one to ask by whom was this myth of exile concocted and why?
As already stated, the suggestion made by Sand is that the story of the exile was a myth
promoted by early Christians to recruit Jews to the new faith.
This myth suited the Zionists exceedingly well.
Jerry Haber, in his post dated July 29, 2007, suggests that though the myth was not
invented by the Zionists, they dropped the “punishment” part and used it and nurtured
it, “in part, to justify the return of the Jews to their ancestral homeland. For the tacit
assumption of the Zionists was that if the Jews had left the land willingly, if they had
merely ‘emigrated’ because they found opportunities beckoning in the Diaspora, then
they would have betrayed their allegiance to the land, and their return would have
been less justified….. it (the myth)dovetailed nicely with the historical view of the
wandering Jew that finds no rest outside of his native place from which he was
In Sand's view, at a certain stage in the 19th century, intellectuals of Jewish origin in
Germany, influenced by the folk character of German nationalism, took upon
themselves the task of inventing a people "retrospectively," out of a thirst to create a
modern Jewish people. From historian Heinrich Graetz on, Jewish historians began to
draw the history of Judaism as the history of a nation that had been a kingdom,
became a wandering people and ultimately turned around and went back to its
The third chapter of Sand’s book “The Invention of the Diaspora” starts with the
quotation from the preamble to the Israeli Declaration of Independence: "After being
forcibly exiled from their land, the people remained faithful to it throughout their
Dispersion and never ceased to pray and hope for their return to it and for the
restoration in it of their political freedom" As we have seen, Sand argues that the
Jewish people's exile from its land never happened.
Sand goes on to state that the description of the Jews as a wandering and self-isolating
nation of exiles, "who wandered across seas and continents, reached the ends of the
earth and finally, with the advent of Zionism, made a U-turn and returned en masse to
their orphaned homeland," is nothing but
"national mythology." Like other national movements in Europe, which sought out a
splendid Golden Age, through which they invented a heroic past - for example,
classical Greece or the Teutonic tribes - to prove they have existed since the beginnings
of history, "so, too, the first buds of Jewish nationalism blossomed in the direction of the
strong light that has its source in the mythical Kingdom of David."
Sand asserts: “Zionism changed the idea of Jerusalem. Before, the holy places were
seen as places to long for, not to be lived in. For 2,000 years Jews stayed away from
Jerusalem not because they could not return but because their religion forbade them
from returning until the messiah came.”
These revelations about the oft asserted exile of the Jews being a myth are indeed
revealing and shocking. They completely demolish the Jewish claim of their right to
return to the Holy Land. But this is not all. Modern researchers and historians go further.
They claim that the Jews never existed as a nation and that the vast majority of the present
day Jews have no connection to the Biblical Jews or the Biblical Holy Land.
But that is another story. (Please watch for: “Was there a Jewish nation?”)
|1||How the last moment of humanity's exile, and how the first moment of the Messianic age and Redemption are going to look like||12/29/16|
|2||Enlil is Obama.. My Brother Exiled Me for 8 years while laughing about it||01/11/17|
|3||Cuban exiles pour onto Miami streets to celebrate Fidel Castro’s death||11/26/16|
|4||Is Obama in exile?||03/21/11|
|5||Are Americans Living in Exile? An Analysis.||07/22/11|
|6||Zionist nationalist myth of enforced exile: Israel deliberately forgets its history||01/28/09|
|7||Zionist nationalist myth of enforced exile: Israel deliberately forgets its history||01/03/09|
|8||Zionist nationalist myth of enforced exile: Israel deliberately forgets its history||10/27/08|
|9||BREAKING!! W.H. Petition Calls for Stripping Citizenship and Exile for Anyone Who Signs Petition to Secede!!||11/14/12|
|10||Proof Israel will not face destruction or be exiled again !||07/19/10|