Godlike Productions - Conspiracy Forum
Users Online Now: 2,209 (Who's On?)Visitors Today: 2,597,244
Pageviews Today: 3,334,915Threads Today: 750Posts Today: 12,679
09:57 PM

Back to Forum
Back to Forum
Back to Thread
Back to Thread
Message Subject Guantanamo Inmates Could Be Moved To US Jails
Poster Handle Anonymous Coward
Post Content

Just because they move locations, doesn't mean their status as an enemy combatant changes. We already have hundreds of "terrorists", conspirators, and suspected terrorists already held in federal prisons.

An extra 166 inmates won't change anything, nor cause any problems.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 3095752


OK, regime apologist.
 Quoting: Carshy McCarsh


Thanks for contributing.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 3095752

[link to illinoiscarry.com]

But the money isnít the worst of it. Moving the detainees into the United States would greatly increase the likelihood that federal judges will order some of them released here.

Though the nationís attention has been focused on the administrationís absurd decision to grant the 9/11 plotters a trial in the civilian justice system, the fact is that many, if not most, of the remaining Gitmo detainees will not face a trial of any kind. They are being held under the laws of war, which permit the detention of enemy operatives until the conclusion of hostilities. The threat they pose is terrible, but it is known to us mostly through foreign intelligence that may not be used in trial proceedings.

This was not a problem in Americaís prior wars. Handling enemy prisoners was properly considered a military matter. In this war, activist judges urged on by left-wing lawyers have taken on an oversight role: the power, codified by Congress in the 2005 Detainee Treatment Act, to review the legitimacy of military detention. Many civilian judges are fundamentally hostile to the concept of indefinite detention under wartime protocols that do not require proof of a crime. With no political accountability to the voters whose lives are at stake, and no guidance from Congress regarding the rules for these detention proceedings, judges have made abominable rulings, vacating the combatant designations of detainees who were trained in terror camps and clearly connected to the jihadist network.

So far, these rulings have not resulted in detaineesí being released in the United States. But that is only because, at present, the detainees are physically kept outside of the country. In the 2005 Real ID Act, Congress barred aliens who either have been members of terrorist organizations or have received paramilitary training in terrorist camps from entering our nation. Though one judge has tried to order detainees released here regardless, his order was reversed on appeal. Other judges have been hesitant to hold that their power to review detention rulings implies a power to order detainees released, much less released in the United States, in defiance of statutory proscription.
 Quoting: Carshy McCarsh

Sorry, but the scare-mongering isn't going to work with me.

We house hundreds of terrorists currently in federal prisons. No one has become radicalized by them.

Those held in Gitmo already have the statutory right to file a petition for a writ of habeas corpus, to challenge their detention. Also, if at a CSRT hearing, it is determined that they are not enemy combatants, they are to be released to their country of citizenship or dealt with in accordance to foreign policy.

So, the scare-mongering belief that the courts are going to release them to run amok in the US is laughable.

Those that get released, are released because they were deemed not to be enemy combatants.
Please verify you're human:

Reason for reporting: