Godlike Productions - Conspiracy Forum
Users Online Now: 2,146 (Who's On?)Visitors Today: 2,958,234
Pageviews Today: 3,594,185Threads Today: 609Posts Today: 9,678
07:35 PM

Back to Forum
Back to Forum
Back to Thread
Back to Thread
Message Subject How can I go beyond "fallen away Catholic" to "not Catholic"?
Poster Handle Anonymous Coward
Post Content
If you received the sacrament of confirmation, you are always Catholic in God's eyes, thus the phrase "fallen away Catholic" or "back slidden". This goes for anyone who was confirmed in the Catholic faith.
 Quoting: Generation Doom

So let me get this straight...when God says he casts sin away and never will remember it...He can do that...but, He can't forget that somebody was Roman Catholic? That is your argument? So, according to you, sin is less important that Roman Catholic Church membership? God can forget sin, but He cannot forget Roman Catholic Church membership...which according to others here...when I left would be part of my judgment (that I left the RCC). Do you see any difference between the Catholic church and the mafia? The mafia says that once a member always a member too!
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 24011342

Whoa buddy..I didn't make the rules. I'm just reporting what I've heard. I came across this discussion, maybe it will help clarify why you are always considered Catholic.

[link to forum.catholic.org]
 Quoting: Generation Doom

I read some of the posts on that forum.

Here is my answer to that...
You can read it from a Roman Catholic Bible some place as well...
[link to bible.cc]
God forgives and forgets sins.

According to your link to a Catholic Online Forum...God does not forget baptism and confession, because they make an indelible mark on the soul.

Let me see if I am understanding your position (or at least the position of some in that forum)...God can not forget the baptism of a child (who may be only a few days old) and He can not forget the confirmation of a person approximately 13 years old....BUT, according to the Bible...he can forget the sins of a murderer (the guy on the cross next to Jesus...even the apostle Paul) could count as people that God forgave and forgot their sins.

Amazing! The Roman Church can force God to remember actions taken on an infant (baptism)...all the while...God can forget the sins of murder or whatever sins somebody may commit. Do you see the Roman Church as more powerful than God Himself?
Please verify you're human:

Reason for reporting: