|
REPORT ABUSIVE REPLY
|
|
Message Subject
|
BREAKING: Scientist claims comet ISON has companions!
|
|
Poster Handle
|
Dr. Astro |
|
Post Content
|
...
Well this phd washout has now proven he is not an expert at astronomy. He's proven he can't even be trusted to tell the truth.
Quoting: Dr. Astro He is Mathematician, Physicist, Master in Solid States and Nuclear Fusion. What is astronomy other than physicist, math and observations applied to the stars?? Don't forget that physicists have a lot of more physics than astronomers! He failed to attain a PhD. A master's degree in physics is a consolation prize for someone who couldn't cut it in a PhD program. You are making a false appeal to authority, and amazingly you still fail to see that he's flat out lying now. He started this because of Pete's images, now that those images have been debunked he's now lying by claiming Pete's images are a NASA hoax because NASA showed his images "without the companions" (hot pixels). That is a flat-out lie. When NASA showed Pete's images, they still contained the hot pixels. He's just making shit up. 1-) He never ever stated his thoughts regarding companions on C/2012 S1 with these Pete's images, he have his own source of informations. He has provided no images and no data. This started immediately after Pete's images were seized upon on this forum and others. He's just taking what conspiracy forums have put out and using it for his own site. Yes, there are other images of ISON that were used to claim "companions" as well, but Pete's images were first. He now retreats from Pete's images because they were thoroughly debunked and the astrophotographer himself contacted. Now that astrophotographer must be dismissed by him and regarded as part of the conspiracy. 2-) Generally people first take a MS or Doc degree before going to PhD, this is the path he followed. If you knew McCanney's history, you would know that he was about to take his PhD course on Cornell, but he decided to first get hired as a substitute teacher to use good space data. He had problems with Astronomic department at Cornell, who don't likes people around talking about Electric Universe, so he get fired and decided to not get a PhD status.
Quoting: glaucoHe's a washout. An MS in physics is a consolation prize for someone who couldn't make it through a PhD program. At least he admits he got fired. Oh, but of course he has excuses for everything. Funny how you blindly believe this liar yet ignore the people who actually take pictures like this. 3-) You push authority and uses too much scold.
Quoting: glaucoNo I do not. I do not appeal to my own authority. I do not claim to be right because I have a PhD or because I'm an astrophotographer with 17 years experience in amateur astronomy and 13 years experience in astrophotography. I'm right because that's what the evidence shows. My experience and knowledge have nothing to do with it, they're just the tools I use to find the answers. I just find it ironic that you appeal to a false authority when someone who actually has the higher degree is telling you otherwise. It's just beautiful irony. It's clear that you will just believe whatever BS spills out of McCanney's mouth because you think he's some kind of authority on the subject. Well pal, this incident has proven he is no authority at all. In fact it proves he has no idea what the hell he's talking about. Where is his astrometric data? Where are his images? They don't exist. But don't worry, I think I can help with that...
|
|
|
Please verify you're human:
|
|
|
Reason for reporting:
|
