Godlike Productions - Discussion Forum
Users Online Now: 1,892 (Who's On?)Visitors Today: 801,358
Pageviews Today: 1,373,414Threads Today: 532Posts Today: 9,820
03:19 PM


Back to Forum
Back to Forum
Back to Thread
Back to Thread
REPORT ABUSIVE REPLY
Message Subject BREAKING: Scientist claims comet ISON has companions!
Poster Handle Dr. Astro
Post Content
Your opinion is worth what, exactly? That is to say, what do you have to back that opinion up with? Good job genius, you debunked your own dear leader, McCanney.
 Quoting: Dr. Astro


Take care, I guess this content is protected.

With my opinion and more 5 dollars you win a beer in any bar. As well as yours.
 Quoting: glauco

I backed up my opinion with all kinds of sources and information. Your own information debunked McCanney's claims. You thought you could get away with confirmation bias by only paying attention to the part you liked while ignoring the rest which debunked McCanney's notions of Hale-Bopp's size and the distance of its "companions." It doesn't work like that, you dismantled your own claim without even realizing it. I'd say I handed your ass to you, but in truth you hoisted yourself with your own petard.
So, if he said Hale-Bopp or ISON is big, so it is.
 Quoting: glauco

LMFAO! Nice logical fallacy, you're making a false appeal to authority. Blatantly. You just showed that McCanney is wrong without even realizing it. Good job.
Little dirty snow balls would never have enough gravitational force to do that.
 Quoting: Glauco

Nope, doesn't work like that. As I previously showed, they don't have enough gravity to hold a companion at 1 LD or greater, but they certainly can at 180 km or so. That is a very close orbit, and even then at 2~3 days long it indicates that the comet's mass is only about 0.000001 times the moon's mass. So good job dumbass, you disproved your own claim.
 
Please verify you're human:




Reason for reporting:







GLP