Dear god, thank you to the OP.. I have 3 dogs and I have fed them Beneful all their lives. One 10yrs.,7yrs and 9 months. Both the older dogs have terrible skin problems and itching all the time. I cried reading these peoples stories and felt horrible for what I have been putting my dogs through. I am changing their food immediately and I can only pray I am not too late. I feel sick inside thinking I've been tormenting my poor animals all this time..