Users Online Now: 2,062 (Who's On?) Visitors Today: 2,771,528 Pageviews Today: 3,350,929 Threads Today: 560 Posts Today: 8,860 06:03 PM

Absolute BS Crap Reasonable Nice Amazing

# Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?

green_girl

User ID: 49871189
11/17/2013 07:12 PM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
...

For now.
Quoting: • 18770744

Perhaps you missed the part where I integrated the orbit for 1 million years and it's STILL hyperbolic.
Quoting: Dr. Astro

Simple questions:

How much energy is needed to change hyperbolic to parabolic in this case (do we know the ISON mass to calculate this)?

Let's say in 1920s ISON traveled 4km/s so something as small as the Earth can change ISON direction 180degrees ( U-turn ) 113 AU from the Sun, do we know what is there.

Do we know all energies possible (not only gravity) during close miss ISON-Sun to be sure what will happen.

Quoting: • 18770744
OK, I see, I highlighted with blue color REAL data FROM JPL, just to make you easier to imagine what can happen to "small" rock in 100 years, so 1 million years perspective is unknown as much as what happened 100 years ago 100 AU from the Sun.

Be cool, use discernment, be Yourself.

Quoting:

so are you asking if ison will ever decide to turn around and come back? I would say the answer is no. It is going to leave the solar system, that is determined to be the only thing it can do based on the speed and trajectory. As it moves out it will begin to lose momentum. When it loses enough momentum it can begin to be effected by bodies that exert enough force, but there are not a lot of bodies outside of our solar system for a long long while. And even if it does meet something out there, there is not much chance that it will be turned back towards us. it would get a brand new path leading it somewhere else. But astro's models would include other bodies too, so if he says it is not coming back, i am doubly certain of my response.
:malefav:
I love this place!!
Dr. Astro (OP)
Senior Forum Moderator

User ID: 48376296
United States
11/17/2013 07:13 PM

Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
the great comet of 1680, was 333 years ago.

the orbit of Ison and this comet are so similar, but they say it's broke into two.

2 comets, with a 333 year orbit. do the math.
Quoting: Anonymous Coward 49479441

Neither one has a 333 year orbit. ISON is hyperbolic and C/1680 V1's orbit lasts about 10,000 years, not 333.
Dr. Astro (OP)
Senior Forum Moderator

User ID: 48376296
United States
11/17/2013 07:16 PM

Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
...

For now.
Quoting: • 18770744

Perhaps you missed the part where I integrated the orbit for 1 million years and it's STILL hyperbolic.
Quoting: Dr. Astro

Simple questions:

How much energy is needed to change hyperbolic to parabolic in this case (do we know the ISON mass to calculate this)?

Let's say in 1920s ISON traveled 4km/s so something as small as the Earth can change ISON direction 180degrees ( U-turn ) 113 AU from the Sun, do we know what is there.

Do we know all energies possible (not only gravity) during close miss ISON-Sun to be sure what will happen.

Quoting: • 18770744
OK, I see, I highlighted with blue color REAL data FROM JPL, just to make you easier to imagine what can happen to "small" rock in 100 years, so 1 million years perspective is unknown as much as what happened 100 years ago 100 AU from the Sun.

Be cool, use discernment, be Yourself.

Quoting:

So you're suggesting that it's going to free return around an impossibly large undiscovered planet at too close a distance to the sun ( [link to arxiv.org] ) and magically return to the sun on the same path every 333 years? No that is not how things work in real life.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 19247914
United States
11/17/2013 07:47 PM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?

An analysis of comet ISON's orbit in comparison to historical comets.
Quoting: Dr. Astro

Nobody cares.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 16934843
Australia
11/17/2013 07:57 PM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?

An analysis of comet ISON's orbit in comparison to historical comets.
Quoting: Dr. Astro

Nobody cares.
Quoting: Anonymous Coward 19247914

no he doesn't
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 50148567
United Kingdom
11/17/2013 08:08 PM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
Why would it disintegrate this time as some suggest, if its made this trip every 333 years just curious?
Quoting: Anonymous Coward 45198861

It doesn't make this trip every 333 years, as I reveal in the video. It's a hyperbolic comet.
Quoting: Dr. Astro

correct, it is a 313 year orbit

:killshot313:

Dr. Astro (OP)
Senior Forum Moderator

User ID: 48376296
United States
11/17/2013 08:12 PM

Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
So you're suggesting that (...)
Quoting: Dr. Astro

166.5 years from now (333 / 2)
ISON a.d.1846 171AU from the Sun, 3.2 km/s
Detectability 150 - 200 au (m_Mars),
Mars escape speed 5km/s
Quoting:

You said earth, now you're saying Mars. While either one could perturb the comet, it would have to be deliberately placed at just the right spot to produce a return trajectory.
My claim is not "same comet every 333 years",
my claim is "impossible because never happen before" is not true.
Quoting: dot

Now you're just trolling.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1488672
Poland
11/17/2013 08:27 PM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
density of this path is interesting

Anonymous Coward
User ID: 36005354
United States
11/18/2013 12:56 AM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
Seems well orchestrated to me - as every year we have some "confirmed" disaster about to happen that will end life as we know it, then on the day before this end of times, some genius pops us and calls us a bunch of nutty conspiracy theorists. I have a theory - this is part of the distraction - part of the "overwhelm with information."
Quoting: BunnySwanson

WElcome to the
DVCMCM

User ID: 50168301
Italy
11/18/2013 06:32 AM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
Wonder how OP did calculate 333 year orbit

DVCMCM

User ID: 50168301
Italy
11/18/2013 07:01 AM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
Another clue is that the more one comet big is, the more large orbit it got (..official Earth's science oO).

Now, how big is ISON ...'comet'?

Last Edited by IWASTHERE on 11/18/2013 07:05 AM
DVCMCM

User ID: 50168301
Italy
11/18/2013 08:44 AM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
Dr. Astro (OP)
Senior Forum Moderator

User ID: 48376296
United States
11/18/2013 08:55 AM

Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
Wonder how OP did calculate 333 year orbit

Quoting: DVCMCM

Did you even watch the video?
Hydra

User ID: 50152036
Germany
11/18/2013 08:59 AM

Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
Wonder how OP did calculate 333 year orbit

Quoting: DVCMCM

Did you even watch the video?
Quoting: Dr. Astro

Of course Ducky didn't - would destroy his agenda:

.
If the Moon is off, if Earth wobbles or if there is a pole shift
how can things like this, predicted decades ago, happen?

Annular Solar Eclipse - January 15, 2010 - Rameshwaram, India
DVCMCM

User ID: 50168301
Italy
11/18/2013 09:00 AM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
Wonder how OP did calculate 333 year orbit

Quoting: DVCMCM

Did you even watch the video?
Quoting: Dr. Astro

Math formula please here. Anything else is needed.

green_girl

User ID: 49871189
11/18/2013 09:02 AM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
Wonder how OP did calculate 333 year orbit

Quoting: DVCMCM

Did you even watch the video?
Quoting: Dr. Astro

Of course Ducky didn't - would destroy his agenda:

.
Quoting: Hydra

now that is a brilliant duckie smilie.
:malefav:
I love this place!!
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 49830588
New Zealand
11/18/2013 12:22 PM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
Question Dr. Astro if you please.

An unprecedented event with 1000's of incoming comets?
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 50072074
United Kingdom
11/18/2013 12:26 PM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
Question Dr. Astro if you please.

An unprecedented event with 1000's of incoming comets?
Quoting: Anonymous Coward 49830588

green_girl

User ID: 49871189
11/18/2013 12:33 PM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
Question Dr. Astro if you please.

An unprecedented event with 1000's of incoming comets?
Quoting: Anonymous Coward 49830588

Quoting: Anonymous Coward 50072074

No there is nothing in it to imply the claims are true. no thousand comets incoming. aside from the ones we always knew were coming.
:malefav:
I love this place!!

User ID: 18770744
Poland
11/24/2013 07:07 PM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
No, it's hyperbolic.
Quoting: Dr. Astro

For now.

Quoting: • 18770744

Perhaps you missed the part where I integrated the orbit for 1 million years and it's STILL hyperbolic.
Quoting: Dr. Astro

You can put this on the list not failed predictions.
User ID: 18770744
11/17/2013 01:53 PM

This prediction was named "trolling"
by Astro
performing 1 000 000 years calculations.

Last Edited by on 11/24/2013 07:20 PM
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 50197089
United Kingdom
11/24/2013 07:08 PM
Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
Truth
Dr. Astro (OP)
Senior Forum Moderator

User ID: 48376296
United States
11/24/2013 08:22 PM

Report Abusive Post
Re: Does comet ISON have a 333 year orbit?
No, it's hyperbolic.
Quoting: Dr. Astro

For now.

Quoting: • 18770744

Perhaps you missed the part where I integrated the orbit for 1 million years and it's STILL hyperbolic.
Quoting: Dr. Astro

You can put this on the list not failed predictions.
User ID: 18770744
11/17/2013 01:53 PM

This prediction was named "trolling"
by Astro
performing 1 000 000 years calculations.

Quoting:

Hey troll: