Godlike Productions - Discussion Forum
Users Online Now: 1,047 (Who's On?)Visitors Today: 148,337
Pageviews Today: 253,469Threads Today: 85Posts Today: 1,671
03:22 AM


Rate this Thread

Absolute BS Crap Reasonable Nice Amazing
 

THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS

 
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 42130120
South Africa
12/09/2013 10:39 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
[link to science.nasa.gov]


I like to look for articles ,that are written a few months back. ...You know the kind that are denied being told later, after the fact.hiding2
 Quoting: Deliverer


Ahem..... so let me get this straight...
BLUE dust that lights up the night?!
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 39988244


pretty freaky! abduct
 Quoting: Deliverer


It is mentioned several times , in Isaiah , Ezekiel , Hosea? and Revelation. I know it is written in one of the gospels but I can not remeber where .
 Quoting: Azadok 48171460



Where's the cut and paste religitards when we need 'em? pope
 Quoting: The Lost~Soul


6 "And it shall come to pass in that day, that the light shall not be clear, nor dark:

7 But it shall be one day which shall be known to the Lord, not day, nor night: but it shall come to pass, that at evening time it shall be light."

Zechariah 14:6-7
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 51062385
United States
12/09/2013 10:40 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
From the sky huge hailstones, each weighing about a hundred pounds, fell on people. And they cursed God on account of the plague of hail ...
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 50886412
United States
12/09/2013 10:44 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
Sooo an eliptic plane is blank wide and earth is blank wide and ison debris field before perih..was ESTIMATED at.....wide, insert numbers and presto,,,,, question is what are the numbers,,, were are those numbers,,,, gottaa be around heere somewhere. ?.
 Quoting: CRTR1968


I would like just the flat out honest to God TRUTH, no more of this hiding from the public! I think even if it was a bad case scenario that they would not say a word,and the big wigs would be some what prepared..... That`s just me.....I guess.
 Quoting: Deliverer




If you look at ISON's orbit as it approaches the sun, the earth is projected to pass through where the tail was on it's approach. Read that again. Again, BEFORE it even approached perihelion and before it was blown up, either by NASA or because of solar radiation. So none of this is new information. In fact, it was easily understood for the last 8 months and confirmed as ISON made its trip into th einner solar system more than month ago.

It really makes me wonder if anyone on this site talking about ISON really has even a basic understanding of what is happening, because it certainly doesn't seem that way
The Lost~Soul

User ID: 51048623
Australia
12/09/2013 10:48 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
[link to science.nasa.gov]


I like to look for articles ,that are written a few months back. ...You know the kind that are denied being told later, after the fact.hiding2
 Quoting: Deliverer


Ahem..... so let me get this straight...
BLUE dust that lights up the night?!
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 39988244


pretty freaky! abduct
 Quoting: Deliverer


It is mentioned several times , in Isaiah , Ezekiel , Hosea? and Revelation. I know it is written in one of the gospels but I can not remeber where .
 Quoting: Azadok 48171460



Where's the cut and paste religitards when we need 'em? pope
 Quoting: The Lost~Soul


6 "And it shall come to pass in that day, that the light shall not be clear, nor dark:

7 But it shall be one day which shall be known to the Lord, not day, nor night: but it shall come to pass, that at evening time it shall be light."

Zechariah 14:6-7
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 42130120



Many thanks! rockon
Time to depart this earthly vehicle...
:Comet Lovejoy:
Deliverer  (OP)

User ID: 43098787
United States
12/09/2013 10:48 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
bsflag
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 17665216


Well they wrote it, but i agree NASA is bullshit. Anything they release to the public that contains any truth would definitely be understated or under-exaggerated. in this case, the fine dust would probably be the size of cars.
 Quoting: The Lost~Soul

Here comes a flying mountain!!!!!hiding
Appointed Deliverer
Engonoceras

User ID: 20067985
United States
12/09/2013 10:53 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
I wonder what they define as "fine-grained"?

Now Jan 2014 would be AFTER Comet ISON (no it's not dead) has passed the Earth at a very high angle from the Sun at like 10s of millions of million miles ABOVE us.

If particles are low enough to hit us that's quite a difference in trajectory given the comet and all it's particles should all travel in the exact same trajectory (gravity pulls on particles the same regardless of size) after it whipped around the Sun on Nov 28th.

Also ANY change in the trajectory caused by the outward pushing of the Solar Winds and CMEs could only push particles FURTHER away from us at an even higher trajectory NOT lower.

WTF NASA?

Last Edited by TexasPaleo on 12/09/2013 10:53 AM
Krystle|Ann

User ID: 49621846
United States
12/09/2013 10:54 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
The more comet dust you breath in the greater heights you will soar to.wtf
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 51062385


Yeah, cause you'll go to heaven?

ptabook
:cpl3:
:rose:Power, Corruption and Lies..
Much more than just the title of an album.
The year was 2081, and everyone was finally equal.KV :rose:
Deliverer  (OP)

User ID: 43098787
United States
12/09/2013 10:55 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS

OP, this is quite a find and of major importance...major.

Also, to me this is real doom.

We do not even know what the hell will be hitting us.

five stars
[/quot
When I read it I was like crud,another made up article, but when I seen it was NASA I was like i'm posting it before they remember they did and remove it!
Appointed Deliverer
Deliverer  (OP)

User ID: 43098787
United States
12/09/2013 10:55 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
The more comet dust you breath in the greater heights you will soar to.wtf
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 51062385


Yeah, cause you'll go to heaven?

ptabook
 Quoting: Krystle|Ann

Amen
Appointed Deliverer
Dr. AstroModerator
Senior Forum Moderator

User ID: 4211721
United States
12/09/2013 11:07 AM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
I wonder what they define as "fine-grained"?
 Quoting: Engonoceras

Micron sized.
Now Jan 2014 would be AFTER Comet ISON (no it's not dead)
 Quoting: engo

[link to spaceweathergallery.com]
[link to spaceweathergallery.com]
astrobanner2
Engonoceras

User ID: 20067985
United States
12/09/2013 11:15 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS


Comets have brightness from their comas.

De-iced rocks or rock clouds would be almost invisible.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 48510957
Germany
12/09/2013 11:21 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
I wonder what they define as "fine-grained"?
 Quoting: Engonoceras

Micron sized.
Now Jan 2014 would be AFTER Comet ISON (no it's not dead)
 Quoting: engo

[link to spaceweathergallery.com]
[link to spaceweathergallery.com]
 Quoting: Dr. Astro


Astro can you imagine, if they were worried about a tiny amount of this stuff being released on approach, what they must be thinking now that it's broke up into a million pieces?

The things entire mass of gas and rocks and whatever else makes it up is now dispersing in one concentration in space that we will be flying through.

This is much more serious doom now that it has broken up!

And before you say it, no one knows for sure the exact trajectory of all these millions of pieces and gasses. It's very likely we will pass through it, or at least some of it, and anyone that says we won't 100% is a liar.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 48510957
Germany
12/09/2013 11:23 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS


Comets have brightness from their comas.

De-iced rocks or rock clouds would be almost invisible.
 Quoting: Engonoceras


I have banged my head on the wall trying to get this across to astro for days, but it seems to land of deaf ears.
Engonoceras

User ID: 20067985
United States
12/09/2013 11:23 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
Where are the SOHO pictures of ISON whipping around the Sun??

The "Comet of the Century" and no SOHO pictures, just one non-comet picture frozen through the whole perehelion event??!!

WTF NASA?!

And even though NASA prefectly predicted the exact perehelion path it still said back in April that particles could diverge so much from the expected trajectory we could get dusted. How is even such a divergance possible?

Lemme quote myself:
"If particles are low enough to hit us [via a lower trajectory coming back from the Sun] that's quite a difference in trajectory given the comet and all it's particles should all travel in the exact same trajectory (gravity pulls on particles the same regardless of size) after it whipped around the Sun on Nov 28th. Also ANY change in the trajectory caused by the outward pushing of the Solar Winds and CMEs could only push particles FURTHER away from us at an even higher trajectory NOT lower."

WTF NASA?!

Nasa can't be 100% right about the perehelion path and then a month later be so wrong in the trajectory of some of the debris.

Last Edited by TexasPaleo on 12/09/2013 11:29 AM
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 49889043
United States
12/09/2013 11:27 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
It is mentioned several times , in Isaiah , Ezekiel , Hosea? and Revelation. I know it is written in one of the gospels but I can not remeber where .
 Quoting: Azadok 48171460



Where's the cut and paste religitards when we need 'em? pope
 Quoting: The Lost~Soul


actually what you need is William Bramley's "Gods of Eden." great read, interesting data...

he documents all the cases where before the "Black Death" there were major ufo sightings and even critters on the ground, appearing to be spraying...

this book plus studying shamanism and Graham Hancock's "Supernatural" compelled me to consider that there was a supernatural influence on world events... once you recognize this possibility, you begin to see it cropping up everywhere with every historic figure...

then you find things like Joseph Jordan and hundreds of cases of people ending the abuse of ufo/abduction by calling on Jesus, plus all the former occultists who say Jesus is the only true path... then you find research from people like Lee Strobel and discover that you can illustrate the legitimacy of the New Testament... then you debunk evolution (easy to do if you are honest and know where to look) and then "aliens" become "biblical powers and principalities" and with a little more digging the whole things becomes a luciferian spirit-worshipping globalist plan and best of all: the Bible becomes truth...

William Bramley. Gods of Eden. Red Ice Creations
[link to www.youtube.com]
Deliverer  (OP)

User ID: 43098787
United States
12/09/2013 11:32 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS

ANYONE Want to. build an underground city for Crazy, smart,People like us???ahhh
Appointed Deliverer
Reinvigorated Being

User ID: 2782120
United States
12/09/2013 11:36 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
...


They're talking about dust that left the comet before it even reached the sun, dust that remains in the meteoroid trail and is blown by solar wind from the point of closest intersection between our orbit and the comet's orbit. That happens in January, weeks after the remains of the comet have passed their point of closest approach to earth in late December.
 Quoting: Dr. Astro


Nay, you're wrong.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 50023508

"For several days around January 12, 2014, Earth will pass through a stream of fine-grained debris from Comet ISON"
[link to science.nasa.gov]

Now, when is the comet's perigee supposed to be? January? Or December?
The article specifically mentioned mid January and the specific timeframe of the 2nd trail of dust which will have been produced by the comet after perihelion, leaving the sun and passing by the earth.
 Quoting: AC

The article mentions two populations of dust, but it does not say anything about either one being produced after perihelion. It says one will be following the comet towards the sun, the other will be moving in the other direction, not because it's following the comet on its way out of the solar system, but because it's been pushed back by solar radiation pressure. Additionally, the video animation showing the two populations shows that both originate from the same stream, not from the comet's outbound path.
 Quoting: Dr. Astro

Ah, so Ison is still coming not of it's own "dead" volition. It's being forced by solar radiation pressure. Good eye!

These word games can be entertaining like watching a juggler.. I like how you stick to debunking the specific arguments rather than concepts. It's just more entertaining.

..Funny, I've seen other scientific articles explaining how we would be "dusted from both sides," about a month apart coinciding with each pass of the comet.

Sometimes the best way to dig out of a hole is to stop digging. It's ok to admit when you have made a mistake.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 50023508


One of my favorite "Bush-isms" came to mind, regarding the quoted poster admitting to having made a mistake. "That's unpossible" chuckle
I'm a proud Texan & American, posting from Central Texas & have no clue why my flag shows friggin Canada(no offense to my Canadian friends).

"Men will never be free until the last king is strangled with the entrails of the last priest."

Diderot

"Immigration without assimilation is invasion!" - Anonymous Coward

Gird your lions, shave your Family & panic sex the 'maters!

"When your so-called religion is purely a political theory of conquest, and deception is one of it's core principles then it strikes me as perfectly sane and reasonable to assume literally everyone who is of such a "religion" to be exactly the same POS who deserves to be treated as the enemy non-stop." Darkwolf007
YupIBelieveYou

User ID: 45045766
United States
12/09/2013 11:44 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
Nice find. Now we just need to see if the debris consists of 'fine particles' or larger pieces.

Small particles sounds pretty worrying as well, the article says we won't be able to see them....but it doesn't mention that we will be able to inhale them.
 Quoting: ThreeDog

And do we really know what the heck we'll be breathing in??!!uhoh
scared
 Quoting: Deliverer


per article:
"...When NASA's Swift spacecraft observed the comet in January 2013, it was still near the orbit of Jupiter, but already very active. More than 112,000 pounds of dust were spewing from the comet's nucleus every minute."

so for every day we spend in this tail... that is a potential of 80,640 TONS of debris....

sheds 112,000 Lbs of debris per minute

that is 56 tons per minute

that is 3,360 tons per hour

that is 80,640 tons per day

that is 29,030,400 tons per year

...and, this thing has been shedding for how long????

FFS! It musta been huge when it was born...
Cum dignitatis infixae omnibus humanae familiae partibus et eorum jurum aequalium , quae abalienari non possunt , agnitio constituat et in orbe terrarum libertatis et justitiae et pacis fundamentum
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 50886412
United States
12/09/2013 11:52 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
I wonder what they define as "fine-grained"?
 Quoting: Engonoceras

Micron sized.
Now Jan 2014 would be AFTER Comet ISON (no it's not dead)
 Quoting: engo

[link to spaceweathergallery.com]
[link to spaceweathergallery.com]
 Quoting: Dr. Astro


Astro can you imagine, if they were worried about a tiny amount of this stuff being released on approach, what they must be thinking now that it's broke up into a million pieces?

The things entire mass of gas and rocks and whatever else makes it up is now dispersing in one concentration in space that we will be flying through.

This is much more serious doom now that it has broken up!

And before you say it, no one knows for sure the exact trajectory of all these millions of pieces and gasses. It's very likely we will pass through it, or at least some of it, and anyone that says we won't 100% is a liar.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 48510957


Well the problem with what you are saying is 40 million miles of difference. Earth is passing through dust from the comets approach to the sun, before perihelion, BEFORE it blew up into a million pieces. Even having fanned out in a debris field, ISON is going to be 40 million miles above the earth on it's way out of the solar system.

You're simply talking about two different scenarios and I don't think most of the people on this forum even understand something this basic
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 42426863
United States
12/09/2013 11:57 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
We are already feeling the comet dust in our atmosphere with all the rain and snow and hail we are getting globally, it is only going to increase as the debris passes us on its way into far space. Let's just hope we don't enter another ice age. Could happen.
Grinny

User ID: 39702721
Netherlands
12/09/2013 11:58 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS


Last Edited by Grinny on 12/09/2013 12:19 PM
right?

User ID: 49825113
United States
12/09/2013 12:03 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
Nice find. Now we just need to see if the debris consists of 'fine particles' or larger pieces.

Small particles sounds pretty worrying as well, the article says we won't be able to see them....but it doesn't mention that we will be able to inhale them.
 Quoting: ThreeDog

And do we really know what the heck we'll be breathing in??!!uhoh
scared
 Quoting: Deliverer


make sure you have colloidal silver ...saved the rich in the old days when comets past with the space dust that brought the black death ! ... [link to www.discoverynews.us]
 Quoting: Apocalypse Girl


Yeap, colloidal silver is the shit. Best brand sovereign colloidal silver given its parts of silver diluted per volume of water, the finer the particles the better for absorption. Also check 5htp for mood swings and a tesla plate to assist with neg frequencies.


Factoid: if you take too much of it youre blood becomes blue-ish looking. Tell me what do you think elite drink by the liter?.

If memory does not fail 1666, what a fucking number to relate to the black plague, almost like Iron Maden the number of the beast LOL.

This time im sure its not only dust, earth needs a pole shift to recharge the magnetosphere, without it we are letting in the full spectrum of visible light and that is why sun light has gone from yellow to almost white.

Plus ever wonder why timelines for different civilizations, constructions, new found pyramids in the Antartica, evidence of huge asteroid impacts like Arizonan, Tunguska y the gulf of México never match?

Nothing is meant to be permanent around here, its only used for soul training purposes and petri dish Creator level ;).

Be safe and loose as much of the attachment to the human form and human shit LOL, the Boss is coming and we are going to be presenting some partial grades to IT individually whether we like it or not.

Whos the Boss?: God, the divine energy of the universe, the Creator, Source, ITS design, ITS will :).

The divine energy of the Cosmos is behind this so better accept it as faith accompli and deal with what is.

Smoke them if you got them stoner
 Quoting: A friend of wolves from afar 51289730



Colloidal or ionic? I found this article that supports ionic:

[link to www.hydrosolinfo.com]
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 48510957
Germany
12/09/2013 12:08 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
I wonder what they define as "fine-grained"?
 Quoting: Engonoceras

Micron sized.
Now Jan 2014 would be AFTER Comet ISON (no it's not dead)
 Quoting: engo

[link to spaceweathergallery.com]
[link to spaceweathergallery.com]
 Quoting: Dr. Astro


Astro can you imagine, if they were worried about a tiny amount of this stuff being released on approach, what they must be thinking now that it's broke up into a million pieces?

The things entire mass of gas and rocks and whatever else makes it up is now dispersing in one concentration in space that we will be flying through.

This is much more serious doom now that it has broken up!

And before you say it, no one knows for sure the exact trajectory of all these millions of pieces and gasses. It's very likely we will pass through it, or at least some of it, and anyone that says we won't 100% is a liar.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 48510957


Well the problem with what you are saying is 40 million miles of difference. Earth is passing through dust from the comets approach to the sun, before perihelion, BEFORE it blew up into a million pieces. Even having fanned out in a debris field, ISON is going to be 40 million miles above the earth on it's way out of the solar system.

You're simply talking about two different scenarios and I don't think most of the people on this forum even understand something this basic
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 50886412


No you're wrong and you missed my point. I know the article is about before perihelion, I'm now talking about after.

Everyone was lead to believe ison would pass 40 million miles above us, but that's absolute bullshit, that's why they faked the perihelion event. The trajectory is different.

And now especially because it's broken up and EXPLODED out, the debris field could easily be 40 million miles xyz.
Dr. AstroModerator
Senior Forum Moderator

User ID: 4211721
United States
12/09/2013 12:16 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
Everyone was lead to believe ison would pass 40 million miles above us, but that's absolute bullshit, that's why they faked the perihelion event. The trajectory is different.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 48510957

Nope.
Thread: Comet ISON's debris is following the original orbit of the comet.
Here's the real math on how much of the comet's mass it would take to propel the remaining mass to earth. Let's be super generous, let us assume that the volatiles of the comet will jet out in exactly the right direction to send the maximum possible remaining mass to earth, thus the comet's entire mass of volatile ices can be used as "fuel" to provide the thrust needed to send it to earth. That is the ultimate in generous assumptions. The question is then how much would remain to reach earth if that were the case. It would take over 57000 m/s delta-V, 57 km/s, to send any fragment of ISON to earth at perihelion. Furthermore, the delta-V would have have to push the comet in a sunward direction.
[link to imageshack.us]
That is the delta-V that must be achieved the volatile ices in the comet. Given an "exhaust velocity" of around 900 m/s for a comet (Combi et al 1997 [link to link.springer.com] ) we can calculate how much of the comet would have to act as "volatile fuel" and how much of it would remain to reach earth. Let's be extremely generous, ridiculously so. Let's say ISON is on the "friggen huge" range of comet nucleus sizes and has a diameter of 50 km, similar to Hale-Bopp. It's not that big, but for the sake of being generous to this example, let's just pretend it is. Let's also assume it is at the top end of the range of comet density, 1.2g/cm^3. It would therefore have a mass of about 7.854 x 10^16 kilograms. In order to deliver 57 km/sec of delta-V, all but about 0.0000000000245 kg of the comet would have to be "fuel" and would never reach earth. That is because delta V = Exhaust velocity * ln(total mass/final[payload] mass) The "payload fraction" that reaches earth would have a whopping mass of 0.0000000000245 kg.

In terms of more realistic numbers, comet separation velocities of major fragments are in the tens of m/s, orders of magnitude too small to send any to earth:
[link to www.lpi.usra.edu]
 Quoting: Dr. Astro

astrobanner2
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 48510957
Germany
12/09/2013 12:20 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
Everyone was lead to believe ison would pass 40 million miles above us, but that's absolute bullshit, that's why they faked the perihelion event. The trajectory is different.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 48510957

Nope.
Thread: Comet ISON's debris is following the original orbit of the comet.
Here's the real math on how much of the comet's mass it would take to propel the remaining mass to earth. Let's be super generous, let us assume that the volatiles of the comet will jet out in exactly the right direction to send the maximum possible remaining mass to earth, thus the comet's entire mass of volatile ices can be used as "fuel" to provide the thrust needed to send it to earth. That is the ultimate in generous assumptions. The question is then how much would remain to reach earth if that were the case. It would take over 57000 m/s delta-V, 57 km/s, to send any fragment of ISON to earth at perihelion. Furthermore, the delta-V would have have to push the comet in a sunward direction.
[link to imageshack.us]
That is the delta-V that must be achieved the volatile ices in the comet. Given an "exhaust velocity" of around 900 m/s for a comet (Combi et al 1997 [link to link.springer.com] ) we can calculate how much of the comet would have to act as "volatile fuel" and how much of it would remain to reach earth. Let's be extremely generous, ridiculously so. Let's say ISON is on the "friggen huge" range of comet nucleus sizes and has a diameter of 50 km, similar to Hale-Bopp. It's not that big, but for the sake of being generous to this example, let's just pretend it is. Let's also assume it is at the top end of the range of comet density, 1.2g/cm^3. It would therefore have a mass of about 7.854 x 10^16 kilograms. In order to deliver 57 km/sec of delta-V, all but about 0.0000000000245 kg of the comet would have to be "fuel" and would never reach earth. That is because delta V = Exhaust velocity * ln(total mass/final[payload] mass) The "payload fraction" that reaches earth would have a whopping mass of 0.0000000000245 kg.

In terms of more realistic numbers, comet separation velocities of major fragments are in the tens of m/s, orders of magnitude too small to send any to earth:
[link to www.lpi.usra.edu]
 Quoting: Dr. Astro

 Quoting: Dr. Astro


Nicolateslaghost already showed its on a different trajectory but even if it isn't the following that you didn't answer above still applies...

Astro can you imagine, if they were worried about a tiny amount of this stuff being released on approach, what they must be thinking now that it's broke up into a million pieces?

The things entire mass of gas and rocks and whatever else makes it up is now dispersing in one concentration in space that we will be flying through.

This is much more serious doom now that it has broken up!

And before you say it, no one knows for sure the exact trajectory of all these millions of pieces and gasses. It's very likely we will pass through it, or at least some of it, and anyone that says we won't 100% is a liar.
Dr. AstroModerator
Senior Forum Moderator

User ID: 4211721
United States
12/09/2013 12:29 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
Astro can you imagine, if they were worried about a tiny amount of this stuff being released on approach, what they must be thinking now that it's broke up into a million pieces?
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 48510957

They're not "worried." The trajectory it takes after perihelion brings the debris nowhere near us.
astrobanner2
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 44534891
United States
12/09/2013 12:30 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
[link to science.nasa.gov]


I like to look for articles ,that are written a few months back. ...You know the kind that are denied being told later, after the fact.hiding2
 Quoting: Deliverer


More disinformation by NASA. Should we go through this debris field, these little particles will pollute our atmosphere and block out the sun causing the next ice age...
Shustah

User ID: 51129720
United States
12/09/2013 12:30 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
Very informative video...posted this on another thread.

[link to www.youtube.com]
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 50886412
United States
12/09/2013 12:35 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
 Quoting: Dr. Astro


Astro can you imagine, if they were worried about a tiny amount of this stuff being released on approach, what they must be thinking now that it's broke up into a million pieces?

The things entire mass of gas and rocks and whatever else makes it up is now dispersing in one concentration in space that we will be flying through.

This is much more serious doom now that it has broken up!

And before you say it, no one knows for sure the exact trajectory of all these millions of pieces and gasses. It's very likely we will pass through it, or at least some of it, and anyone that says we won't 100% is a liar.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 48510957


Well the problem with what you are saying is 40 million miles of difference. Earth is passing through dust from the comets approach to the sun, before perihelion, BEFORE it blew up into a million pieces. Even having fanned out in a debris field, ISON is going to be 40 million miles above the earth on it's way out of the solar system.

You're simply talking about two different scenarios and I don't think most of the people on this forum even understand something this basic
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 50886412


No you're wrong and you missed my point. I know the article is about before perihelion, I'm now talking about after.

Everyone was lead to believe ison would pass 40 million miles above us, but that's absolute bullshit, that's why they faked the perihelion event. The trajectory is different.

And now especially because it's broken up and EXPLODED out, the debris field could easily be 40 million miles xyz.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 48510957




You have absolutely no data whatsoever to support that claim. NONE

So you're just another idiot on GLP that has a feeling.
Who gives a shit>

More fucking meaningless BLATHER
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 51174326
France
12/09/2013 12:36 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: THIS WAS WRITTEN LAST APRIL BY NASA SCIENCE, ABOUT COMET ISON DEBRIS TRAILS
It is mentioned several times , in Isaiah , Ezekiel , Hosea? and Revelation. I know it is written in one of the gospels but I can not remeber where .
 Quoting: Azadok 48171460



Where's the cut and paste religitards when we need 'em? pope
 Quoting: The Lost~Soul


BREAKING---ATHEISTS MENTALLY ILL (OFFICIAL)
Psalm 14:1-7

King James Version (KJV)

14 The fool hath said in his heart, There is no God. They are corrupt, they have done abominable works, there is none that doeth good.

Mentally Ill Legal Definition:

Related Terms: Mental Disorder , Fool , Lunatic , Mentally Retarded , Imbecile , Idiot , Natural Fool , Incapacitated , Incompetency , Dementia , Non Compos Mentis
clappa
hesright





GLP