Godlike Productions - Conspiracy Forum
Users Online Now: 1,266 (Who's On?)Visitors Today: 304,258
Pageviews Today: 393,876Threads Today: 62Posts Today: 1,477
03:08 AM


Rate this Thread

Absolute BS Crap Reasonable Nice Amazing
 

ISRAEL AND 'MORAL EQUIVALENCE': THE QANA MASSACRE REVEALS THE TRUE FACE OF ISRAEL'S AGGRESSION by Justin Raimondo

 
BUSH MUST GO
Offer Upgrade

User ID: 105879
United States
08/02/2006 05:34 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
ISRAEL AND 'MORAL EQUIVALENCE': THE QANA MASSACRE REVEALS THE TRUE FACE OF ISRAEL'S AGGRESSION by Justin Raimondo
""According to Jewish law, during a time of battle and war, there is no such term as 'innocents' of the enemy...""


www.antiwar.com/justin/?articleid=9459
[link to www.antiwar.com]
(NUMEROUS SUPPORTING LINKS EMBEDDED AT SOURCE URL ABOVE)


August 2, 2006


Israel and 'Moral Equivalence'

The Qana massacre reveals the true face of Israel's aggression


by Justin Raimondo


The Qana massacre was the occasion for a full-court propaganda campaign by Israel’s amen corner, and one has to say they rose to the occasion like real pros. First, of course, they expressed remorse – then, naturally enough, they blamed it all on… Hezbollah.

How so? Well, you see, the Israelis bombed a building filled with children and old people because rockets fired at Israel "originated immediately next to it." Yet the Red Cross denied there were any Hezbollah in Qana. The Israelis keep up a constant refrain claiming Lebanon uses its own civilian population as "human shields," but the reality is quite different: Lebanese civilians flee when Hezbollah fires a fusillade, because they know the Israelis will soon be bombing the place to perdition. Aside from which, Nasrallah’s folks are a tightly knit group and security is taken seriously: a friend of mine who went into Hezbollah headquarters in southern Beirut was subjected to such a thorough search that by the time they were through with him he was bereft of his dignity as well as any desire to proceed further. Hezbollah doesn’t trust noncombatants, and for that reason keeps well away from them no matter what their religious, ethnic, or political affiliations.

Read this Ha’aretz piece and see if you can figure out how the IDF is trying to slither and slide out of this one: the building didn’t collapse immediately, there is an 8-hour gap – or maybe not – and "maybe we’ll never know what happened." Blah blah blah – in short, the Israelis are blowing a lot of smoke.

One has to wonder, however, what it is they’re smoking if they really think anyone believes their overly elaborate obfuscations. Like a squid ejecting a cloud of ink, the Israeli propaganda machine is emitting all sorts of alternate scenarios, replete with maps, aerial photos, and video, and they dispatched their Internet army to spread the rationalizations far and wide. All to cover up a simple, irrefutable fact: it was Israeli warplanes, and not Hezbollah, that slaughtered 54 people, more than half of them young children, and the rest women and old folks.

IDF commanders and the politicians who supposedly control them don’t even have the courage of their own viciousness. After all, they have an easy out in this pronouncement of the Yesha Rabbinical Council:


"According to Jewish law, during a time of battle and war, there is no such term as 'innocents' of the enemy. All of the discussions on Christian morality are weakening the spirit of the army and the nation and are costing us in the blood of our soldiers and civilians."


These aren’t fringe characters, but fairly representative of Israeli religious opinion. Pat Buchanan complains:


"If Israel is not in violation of the principle of proportionality, by which Christians are to judge the conduct of a just war, what can that term mean? There are 600 civilian dead in Lebanon, 19 in Israel, a ratio of 30-1, though Hezbollah is firing unguided rockets, while Israel is using precision-guided munitions."


But these guys aren’t Christians – and Israel isn’t the West, as much as they’d like us to believe they are. The principle of proportionality doesn’t apply in the Middle East or North Africa – where history and culture have conspired to produce a socio-political milieu in which a disproportionately violent response to the least provocation is required. The Israelis are deliberately targeting Lebanese civilians in order, as per the Yesha Rabbinical Council, to "exterminate the enemy" – just as Hezbollah is deliberately (albeit relatively ineptly) targeting Israeli civilians in the north.

These people not only inhabit the same lands and look the same, they also think alike: if you steal their cow, they’ll blow up your barn – with your family in it. A similarly harsh justification for inflicting death and terror on a civilian population was offered by none other than Osama bin Laden in his fatwa explaining the "Islamic" rationale behind the 9/11 attack on the World Trade Center:


"It is allowed for Muslims to kill protected ones among unbelievers in the event of an attack against them in which it is not possible to differentiate the protected ones from the combatants or from the strongholds. It is permissible to kill them incidentally and unintentionally according to the saying of the Prophet. When he was asked, as in al-Bukhari, about the offspring and women of unbelievers who stayed with the unbelievers and were killed, he said, 'They are from among them.’ This indicates the permission to kill women and children because of their fathers if they can not be distinguished. In the account of Muslim he said, 'They are from their fathers.'"


Perhaps Osama graduated from the same school of moral philosophy as Alan Dershowitz, who, in defense of the Qana slaughter, wrote at the Huffington Post:


"By hiding behind their own civilians, the Islamic radicals issue a challenge to democracies: either violate your own morality by coming after us and inevitably killing some innocent civilians, or maintain your morality and leave us with a free hand to target your innocent civilians. This challenge presents democracies such as Israel with a lose-lose option and the terrorists with a win-win option."


Dershowitz, a well-known advocate of torture, issues a "challenge" to readers to come up with a better solution than launching a military campaign certain to involve heavy civilian casualties. The clear implication being that the IDF has no choice but to kill civilians, because Hezbollah uses its own supporters as "hostages."

This argument does not apply to Qana, however, since, as Ha’aretz reports:


"As the Israel Air Force continues to investigate the Sunday air strike, questions have been raised over military accounts of the incident. It now appears that the military had no information on rockets launched from the site of the building, or the presence there of Hezbollah men at the time.

"The Israeli Defense Forces had said after the deadly air-strike that many rockets had been launched from Qana. However, it changed its version on Monday.The site was included in an IAF plan to strike at several buildings in proximity to a previous launching site. Similar strikes were practiced in the past. But there were no rocket launches from Qana on the day of the strike."


Let’s assume, for the moment, that Ha’aretz is wrong, and Hezbollah did launch rockets in the vicinity of Qana. Dershowitz’s argument still makes no moral sense – at least, to the Western mindset – because the Israeli response is so grotesquely disproportionate. Remember, all this death and devastation is occurring in response to a minor border incident involving a few Israeli soldiers and some trigger-happy Hezbollah fighters: similar dust-ups have occurred on our border with Mexico, and I don’t see Washington ordering air strikes on Mexico City.

The Middle Eastern "morality" that allows the Israelis to target the Beirut airport, where tourists ducked and covered, and permits Hezbollah to lob Katyusha rockets into Haifa, is given its dark voice by bin Laden:


"It is allowed for Muslims to kill protected ones among unbelievers on the condition that the protected ones have assisted in combat, whether in deed, word, mind, or any other form of assistance, according to the prophetic command. This is what happened at the time of Abu Dawud and others who were involved in the murder of Duraid Ibn al-Samma. When he was 120 years old he went out with the Hawazin tribe to advise them. They consulted him on battle procedure and he went from being a protected one to being a target because of his advice regarding the war against Islam.

"It is allowed for Muslims to kill protected ones among unbelievers in the event of a need to burn the strongholds or fields of the enemy so as to weaken its strength in order to conquer the stronghold or topple the state. It is permissible even if protected ones are among the victims, as the Prophet did among the Bani Nadir."


Substitute "Jews" for "Muslims," and you have something the Yesha Rabbinical Council can get behind. This thinking is exemplified by Israeli "Justice" Minister Haim Ramon, who recently opined:



[link to zope.gush-shalom.org]
Goofy Thum


---


For the most recent articles shared search by 'user name' BUSH MUST GO in the Advanced GLP Search at www.godlikeproductions.com/searchhandle.php [link to www.godlikeproductions.com]

Last Edited by Phennommennonn on 09/24/2011 06:13 PM
'Link, Copy, Paste, & Disseminate!'
bmg fan
User ID: 125518
Canada
08/02/2006 05:58 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: ISRAEL AND 'MORAL EQUIVALENCE': THE QANA MASSACRE REVEALS THE TRUE FACE OF ISRAEL'S AGGRESSION by Justin Raimondo
Bump
BRIDAS

User ID: 113430
Japan
08/02/2006 06:00 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: ISRAEL AND 'MORAL EQUIVALENCE': THE QANA MASSACRE REVEALS THE TRUE FACE OF ISRAEL'S AGGRESSION by Justin Raimondo
Bump
 Quoting: bmg fan 125518

KIATT

Keep it at the top.
The Reptilian Elite are planning economic collapse, martial law and micro-chipping next year (2007).
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 121080
United States
08/02/2006 06:39 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: ISRAEL AND 'MORAL EQUIVALENCE': THE QANA MASSACRE REVEALS THE TRUE FACE OF ISRAEL'S AGGRESSION by Justin Raimondo
bump
BUSH MUST GO (OP)

User ID: 105879
United States
08/02/2006 11:49 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: ISRAEL AND 'MORAL EQUIVALENCE': THE QANA MASSACRE REVEALS THE TRUE FACE OF ISRAEL'S AGGRESSION by Justin Raimondo
Bump
Quoting: bmg fan 125518

KIATT

Keep it at the top.
 Quoting: BRIDAS



KIATT = Keep it at the top.

I don't think I've ever encountered that acronym, BRIDAS.

An original? Customized for GLP? I like it. headbang

When I first encountered 'KIATT', I thought you were calling for a mass planting of the slow-growing, Pterocarpus angolensis; a.k.a. the Kiaat. [link to www.thefreedictionary.com]

tounge

BMG
'Link, Copy, Paste, & Disseminate!'
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 125494
Netherlands
08/02/2006 11:55 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: ISRAEL AND 'MORAL EQUIVALENCE': THE QANA MASSACRE REVEALS THE TRUE FACE OF ISRAEL'S AGGRESSION by Justin Raimondo
loads of rockets on israel !
you never mention that bmg ?
i think you have a weak hand !
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 125494
Netherlands
08/02/2006 11:57 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: ISRAEL AND 'MORAL EQUIVALENCE': THE QANA MASSACRE REVEALS THE TRUE FACE OF ISRAEL'S AGGRESSION by Justin Raimondo
i forgot brain banana
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 125494
Netherlands
08/02/2006 12:09 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: ISRAEL AND 'MORAL EQUIVALENCE': THE QANA MASSACRE REVEALS THE TRUE FACE OF ISRAEL'S AGGRESSION by Justin Raimondo
bmg is losing his touch .
but he didnt had much of it annyway .
he didnt post much today and i wonder why ?
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 91701
United States
08/02/2006 12:12 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: ISRAEL AND 'MORAL EQUIVALENCE': THE QANA MASSACRE REVEALS THE TRUE FACE OF ISRAEL'S AGGRESSION by Justin Raimondo
lol what a jerk he should write comedy or fiction better yet lmao
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 125494
Netherlands
08/02/2006 12:30 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: ISRAEL AND 'MORAL EQUIVALENCE': THE QANA MASSACRE REVEALS THE TRUE FACE OF ISRAEL'S AGGRESSION by Justin Raimondo
bmg is comedy because he is a jewish person .
am i the only person who figured it out ?

News