|
Space Heaters Reviews
|
Anonymous Coward User ID: 344850 12/27/2007 12:13 AM Report abusive post | Space Heaters Reviews
| Quote |
[link to www.consumersearch.com]
Space Heaters Reviews
Consumer Reports magazine has the best review of electric space heaters. Editors test 16 different models from eleven different manufacturers. The magazine also keeps readers updated on space heater recalls. Alongside Consumer Reports, owner-written reviews at Amazon.com and other sites are valuable for gauging long-term reliability and durability. We also relied on space heater reviews and information at Good Housekeeping magazine and Popular Mechanics, and a much longer buyer's guide from James Dulley, a syndicated columnist and environmental engineer. Dulley's website is one of the best sources of information on home heating and cooling, including portable electric heaters, but side-by-side comparison testing isn't included.
We found a large number of evaluations for the EdenPURE Quartz Infrared Heater (*est. $400), which is heavily advertised in newspaper circulars and on television. The manufacturer behind the EdenPURE, Bio-Tech Research, claims that his space heater can "cut your heating bill up to 50% while keeping you toasty warm." However, we read dozens of reviews at Amazon.com and InformercialRatings.com from owners who say the EdenPURE did not live up to its end of the bargain. Professional comparison tests also place this electric heater near the bottom. Many owners say their unit failed within a few weeks or simply did not heat a very large area. While some reported a small dip in their utility bills, it would still take several years of use to recoup the high purchase price for the EdenPURE space heater. We found better reviews for units costing far less.
We found some conflicting reviews for Vornado Vortex portable heaters. The Vornado VH2 (*est. $95) and Vornado EH1-0028-06 (also known as the DVH or DVTH) (*est. $115) are very similar. The main difference is that the DVH space heater has push-button controls and temperature readout, while the cheaper VH2 has knob controls. Both have a fan that circulates heated air (this type of heater is called forced convection). The Vornado DVH is a favorite at Good Housekeeping magazine, where editors say it heats a room quickly. However, owners posting comments to Amazon.com say the Vornado space heaters can be fragile. Some report breaking handles and knobs; others indicate that the fan stopped working. Reviews for the more expensive Vornado space heater are better overall.
Convection heaters represent most of the electric heaters available right now. This type of space heater uses either natural air circulation (natural convection) or a fan (forced convection) to raise the air temperature in a room. We found good reviews overall for oil-filled space heaters. Many of these heaters look like an old-fashioned radiator, using oil in a sealed compartment to produce heat. The oil never needs to be refilled. We found excellent reviews for DeLonghi oil-filled space heaters. The Soleus NDY-15 oil-filled radiator (*est. $60) is moderately priced, but gets some mixed reviews from owners, who say it doesn't last very long or simply doesn't put out enough heat.
Be aware that each year there are several electric-heater recalls. This year has so far seen at least seven recalls, including an April recall for Holmes oil-filled space heaters, models HOH2505 and HOH2520 (*est. $50) . There doesn't appear to be any pattern to the recalls -- different brands and types of portable heaters are affected each time. However, the high number of recalls doesn't help improve these appliances' reputations as fire hazards. In fact, the Consumer Products Safety Commission reports that each year about 28,000 house fires are attributed to space heaters, resulting in 300 related deaths. That doesn't mean that space heaters are inherently dangerous, but they should be used wisely. The U.S. Department of Energy, among other sources, outlines some good common-sense safety practices for using space heaters.
Reviews say electric heaters are a great way to help you reduce heating costs, letting you turn the thermostat down so you are not heating rooms no one is using. Space heaters are also very efficient, converting every ounce of electricity into heat.
Most electric heaters provide up to 1500 watts or 5120 BTUs (British Thermal Units) of heat. This is the maximum amount of wattage that can be used safely in a standard household electrical outlet. Many space heaters offer two settings. The low setting of 500 to 750 watts will warm a typical room. For larger rooms of up to 1000 square feet, the higher heat setting of 1500 watts is necessary.
For the best results, you should place an electric heater on a flat surface under a window so the unit can warm the cold air as it enters the room, whether this air is from drafts or the cold glass. If this is not possible, place the space heater in a safe location at least three feet away from all objects. The Consumer Products Safety Commission (CPSC) says space heaters should be plugged directly into a wall outlet. If you must use an extension cord, use a heavy duty cord or a good surge protector.
Experts say a bathroom is the wrong place for an electric space heater, because water and electrical devices are usually a bad combination. However, a few models have special shock-resistant features that make them suitable for use in a bathroom.
Only electric heaters should be used inside your home. Unvented heaters -- such as those that use kerosene or propane fuel -- shouldn't be used in interior spaces. That's because these units use a flame to produce heat. The flame consumes oxygen in the room, reducing air quality and introducing flammable elements into the air. They can also be a carbon monoxide risk. Kerosene and propane heaters do produce more heat than electric space heaters, and they are a good choice for heating large areas like a garage or outdoor patio. Kerosene and propane heaters are covered in our Alternative Considerations section below. ... Continued
>> Full story continued... |
|
Anonymous Coward User ID: 325080 12/27/2007 12:21 AM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote | My favorite is Comfort Zone. I paid $8.95 for it. Two settings: 500/1000 watts. I find little need for a 1500 Watt space heater. |
|
Anonymous Coward User ID: 344850 (OP) 12/27/2007 12:23 AM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote |
My favorite is Comfort Zone. I paid $8.95 for it. Two settings: 500/1000 watts. I find little need for a 1500 Watt space heater. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 325080
more Americans should buy these portable electric heaters
to save money on their heating bills |
|
Anonymous Coward User ID: 338225 12/27/2007 12:24 AM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote | Too tipped to look into it, but those ceramic heaters have a nasty reek to them! |
|
floydian slip User ID: 1338 12/27/2007 12:24 AM
 | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote | I have 5 econo-heaters
[link to www.econo-heat.com]
4 are on now, one is in the guest bedroom
64* and no furnace, the weather in the 20's at night and 30's during the day.
Electric bill is around $80.
Gas bill $30 dryer/hot water heater
Gas bill before econo heaters = $150 |
|
Anonymous Coward User ID: 344850 (OP) 12/27/2007 12:30 AM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote | go to the url for their list
#1 on their list is:
DeLonghi SafeHeat Micathermic HHP1500
(*est. $95)
Best space heater.
Convection space heaters are best at heating a whole room consistently, quietly and safely. The new DeLonghi SafeHeat Micathermic electric heater uses the mineral mica as a heating element. This slender unit comes with feet, but it can also be wall mounted -- keeping it out of reach of children and pets. The DeLonghi space heater earns praise from reviewers for its light weight, performance, reliability and silent operation. The DeLonghi heater has two heat settings. If the unit becomes too warm, it automatically shuts off (it also shuts off if tipped over). |
|
Anonymous Coward User ID: 325080 12/27/2007 12:31 AM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote |
My favorite is Comfort Zone. I paid $8.95 for it. Two settings: 500/1000 watts. I find little need for a 1500 Watt space heater. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 325080
I keep the house thermostat down at 57 and heat a bedroom with it on the 500 watt setting. Bedroom stays a toasty 67-70. I pretty much live in the bedroom in the winter. |
|
Anonymous Coward User ID: 344850 (OP) 12/27/2007 12:32 AM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote | #2 on their list:
• Holmes Quartz Tower HQH319
(*est. $75)
Best radiant space heater.
Reviews say radiant heaters are the best choice if you want to heat one small area of a room. That's because radiant heaters warm objects in front of them rather than a whole room. The Holmes Quartz Tower HQH319 uses quartz tube elements to produce heat, and comes with 750- and 1,500-watt settings. Reviewers praise this model for its design, quiet fan and one-touch thermostat. Safety features include a heavy-duty power cord, tip-over switch and overheat protection (which shuts off the space heater when a sensor is tripped) |
|
Anonymous Coward User ID: 344850 (OP) 12/27/2007 12:33 AM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote | #3 on their list:
Honeywell Mini Tower 360 Surround HZ-2200
(*est. $30)
Budget space heater.
Although larger convection heaters are better at heating a whole room, reviewers say the Honeywell Mini Tower fan heater is a good choice for small spaces like an office or under a desk. The compact and adjustable Honeywell space heater is easy to use with an extra-long cord. Owners say the Honeywell is a reliable little space heater, though it’s just not powerful enough to make a dent in larger cold rooms. |
|
Space Heater Review User ID: 531194 10/20/2008 5:56 PM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote | I personally like the honeywell HZ 365 Ceramic Heater with remote control. My review of ceramic heaters vs radiator heaters is a as follows:
I tend to stick with my alma mater's policies and research of:
"... For new or replacement room heaters, ceramic heaters and electric panel heaters are preferred. Oil filled column heaters may be suitable, but are less energy efficient than ceramic and panel heaters..."
[link to www.usyd.edu.au]
Further I find Oil Filled Column heaters or radiator heaters filled with other substances to be "relatively energy inefficient and they tend to draw a lot of current, which can trip electrical circuits if too many other appliances are operating on the same circuit simultaneously"...
[link to www.usyd.edu.au] |
|
Anonymous Coward User ID: 531194 10/20/2008 5:57 PM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote | Why use a ceramic space heater?
[link to www.usyd.edu.au]
..."
1. CERAMIC HEATERS
Ceramic heaters, sometimes known as ceramic furnace heaters, are a modern type of room heater. Most models incorporate a fan, which can make them effective for larger spaces, areas with high ceilings and areas where draughts cannot readily be eliminated. The features of these heaters include:
* greater energy efficiency than many other types of electric heaters
* rapidly reach the temperature set point
* safety features such as thermostat, safety cut-off switches
* compact size
* some models incorporate a temperature sensor, which enables the heater to maintain a set temperature in the room.
"...
Lastly because they work well! |
|
anonymous User ID: 530774 10/20/2008 6:30 PM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote |
[ link to www.consumersearch.com]
Space Heaters Reviews
Consumer Reports magazine has the best review of electric space heaters. Editors test 16 different models from eleven different manufacturers. The magazine also keeps readers updated on space heater recalls. Alongside Consumer Reports, owner-written reviews at Amazon.com and other sites are valuable for gauging long-term reliability and durability. We also relied on space heater reviews and information at Good Housekeeping magazine and Popular Mechanics, and a much longer buyer's guide from James Dulley, a syndicated columnist and environmental engineer. Dulley's website is one of the best sources of information on home heating and cooling, including portable electric heaters, but side-by-side comparison testing isn't included.
We found a large number of evaluations for the EdenPURE Quartz Infrared Heater (*est. $400), which is heavily advertised in newspaper circulars and on television. The manufacturer behind the EdenPURE, Bio-Tech Research, claims that his space heater can "cut your heating bill up to 50% while keeping you toasty warm." However, we read dozens of reviews at Amazon.com and InformercialRatings.com from owners who say the EdenPURE did not live up to its end of the bargain. Professional comparison tests also place this electric heater near the bottom. Many owners say their unit failed within a few weeks or simply did not heat a very large area. While some reported a small dip in their utility bills, it would still take several years of use to recoup the high purchase price for the EdenPURE space heater. We found better reviews for units costing far less.
We found some conflicting reviews for Vornado Vortex portable heaters. The Vornado VH2 (*est. $95) and Vornado EH1-0028-06 (also known as the DVH or DVTH) (*est. $115) are very similar. The main difference is that the DVH space heater has push-button controls and temperature readout, while the cheaper VH2 has knob controls. Both have a fan that circulates heated air (this type of heater is called forced convection). The Vornado DVH is a favorite at Good Housekeeping magazine, where editors say it heats a room quickly. However, owners posting comments to Amazon.com say the Vornado space heaters can be fragile. Some report breaking handles and knobs; others indicate that the fan stopped working. Reviews for the more expensive Vornado space heater are better overall.
Convection heaters represent most of the electric heaters available right now. This type of space heater uses either natural air circulation (natural convection) or a fan (forced convection) to raise the air temperature in a room. We found good reviews overall for oil-filled space heaters. Many of these heaters look like an old-fashioned radiator, using oil in a sealed compartment to produce heat. The oil never needs to be refilled. We found excellent reviews for DeLonghi oil-filled space heaters. The Soleus NDY-15 oil-filled radiator (*est. $60) is moderately priced, but gets some mixed reviews from owners, who say it doesn't last very long or simply doesn't put out enough heat.
Be aware that each year there are several electric-heater recalls. This year has so far seen at least seven recalls, including an April recall for Holmes oil-filled space heaters, models HOH2505 and HOH2520 (*est. $50) . There doesn't appear to be any pattern to the recalls -- different brands and types of portable heaters are affected each time. However, the high number of recalls doesn't help improve these appliances' reputations as fire hazards. In fact, the Consumer Products Safety Commission reports that each year about 28,000 house fires are attributed to space heaters, resulting in 300 related deaths. That doesn't mean that space heaters are inherently dangerous, but they should be used wisely. The U.S. Department of Energy, among other sources, outlines some good common-sense safety practices for using space heaters.
Reviews say electric heaters are a great way to help you reduce heating costs, letting you turn the thermostat down so you are not heating rooms no one is using. Space heaters are also very efficient, converting every ounce of electricity into heat.
Most electric heaters provide up to 1500 watts or 5120 BTUs (British Thermal Units) of heat. This is the maximum amount of wattage that can be used safely in a standard household electrical outlet. Many space heaters offer two settings. The low setting of 500 to 750 watts will warm a typical room. For larger rooms of up to 1000 square feet, the higher heat setting of 1500 watts is necessary.
For the best results, you should place an electric heater on a flat surface under a window so the unit can warm the cold air as it enters the room, whether this air is from drafts or the cold glass. If this is not possible, place the space heater in a safe location at least three feet away from all objects. The Consumer Products Safety Commission (CPSC) says space heaters should be plugged directly into a wall outlet. If you must use an extension cord, use a heavy duty cord or a good surge protector.
Experts say a bathroom is the wrong place for an electric space heater, because water and electrical devices are usually a bad combination. However, a few models have special shock-resistant features that make them suitable for use in a bathroom.
Only electric heaters should be used inside your home. Unvented heaters -- such as those that use kerosene or propane fuel -- shouldn't be used in interior spaces. That's because these units use a flame to produce heat. The flame consumes oxygen in the room, reducing air quality and introducing flammable elements into the air. They can also be a carbon monoxide risk. Kerosene and propane heaters do produce more heat than electric space heaters, and they are a good choice for heating large areas like a garage or outdoor patio. Kerosene and propane heaters are covered in our Alternative Considerations section below. ... Continued
>> Full story continued... Quoting: Anonymous Coward 344850
products from china continue to have a short life so there is no saving ..rebuying products over and over is just dumb....Huge 10 gallon pot ofhot boiling water heats up a kitchen fast.try it..on your kitchen stove..after desired temp if reached turn burner to med low ..cover with lid .room stAys warm..OR MED HEAT IF YOU LIKE A WARMER ROOM...KEEP WATER LEVEL HIGH AS POSSIBLE ..CHECK WATER LEVELS AND SET TIMER TO CHECK WATER LEVEL. .THIS HEATS KICHEN AS WELL AS SPACE HEATER WOULD.. |
|
Lester User ID: 530990 10/20/2008 6:44 PM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote | A "ten gallon pot of water on the stove"???
Ten gallons is about half the size of most hotwater heaters. Where would you find one and how much ceiling clearance would you need? You are talking about something the size of a stock watering container, a galvanized tub almost big enough to bathe in.
Maybe a tea kettle producing steam would be better? Even a lobster kettle is going to be maybe 4 gals at the maximum.
Will have to give a ceramic heater a try this year, OP; thanks for the info... |
|
Rota User ID: 528208 10/20/2008 6:56 PM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote |
Reviews say electric heaters are a great way to help you reduce heating costs, letting you turn the thermostat down so you are not heating rooms no one is using. Space heaters are also very efficient, converting every ounce of electricity into heat. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 344850
I don't like them. They are direct heat and dry out the sinuses. I use the portable oil heaters. it has oil and the element heats the oil which gives off a nice heat. The oil is in tubes that circulate through the little pipes. No problems and the heat is nice. costs about 39-50 dollars a unit at WalMart or home depot. They also have thermostates where you can set them to go off when the room reaches a certain temperture. |
|
entropy User ID: 527385 10/20/2008 7:04 PM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote | I was just looking this info up last night. Thanks for the post. I was close to getting one of those EdenPure's but after educating myself and ignoring A.P. Harvey's paid endorsement of their brand I think I'd be better off buying a book of matches and a fan. my re-imaging(cover)
of "Piggies" (The Beatles)
and "Lights in the Sky" (Nine Inch Nails)
is available to listen to now. Won't cost you a dime. Click below to hear it.
[link to www.myspace.com]
Over 1 Million plays, Most popular NIN Remix / Re imaging artist on myspace. I keep it separate:
[link to www.myspace.com]
archive:
[link to www.vampirefreaks.com]
Thanks.
[link to www.facebook.com]
aSBhbSB5b3VyIHNhdmlvcg0KaSBhbSBjb3JydXB0aW9uDQppIGFtIHRoZSBhbmdlbA0Kb2YgeW91ciBkZXN0cnVjdGlvbg0KaSBhbSBwZXJ2ZXJzaW9uDQpzZWNyZXQgZGVzaXJlDQppIGFtIHlvdXIgZnV0dXJlDQpzd2FsbG93ZWQgdXAgaW4gZmlyZQ== |
|
Anonymous Coward User ID: 531250 10/20/2008 7:07 PM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote |
I use the portable oil heaters. it has oil and the element heats the oil which gives off a nice heat. The oil is in tubes that circulate through the little pipes. No problems and the heat is nice. costs about 39-50 dollars a unit at WalMart or home depot. They also have thermostates where you can set them to go off when the room reaches a certain temperture. Quoting: Rota
I like these to. |
|
Anonymous Coward User ID: 531213 10/20/2008 7:21 PM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote |
I use the portable oil heaters. it has oil and the element heats the oil which gives off a nice heat. The oil is in tubes that circulate through the little pipes. No problems and the heat is nice. costs about 39-50 dollars a unit at WalMart or home depot. They also have thermostates where you can set them to go off when the room reaches a certain temperture.
I like these to. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 531250
I heat my whole house with 4 of these. |
|
merrymar User ID: 538551 10/30/2008 2:49 AM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote |
I have 5 econo-heaters
[ link to www.econo-heat.com]
4 are on now, one is in the guest bedroom
64* and no furnace, the weather in the 20's at night and 30's during the day.
Electric bill is around $80.
Gas bill $30 dryer/hot water heater
Gas bill before econo heaters = $150 Quoting: floydian slip
Hello Floydian slip:
I live in a Mobile Home in a cold part of Canada. Winter temps range from low -25 degrees Celsius to high -5 degrees Celsius. For a 70 x 14 foot MH, it sound like I would have to buy "7" heaters? Do you think my winters are too cold for econo heaters to do the job? |
|
Raena User ID: 624018 2/26/2009 10:44 PM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote | Comfort Zone heater SUCKS. I bought one of these heaters and am thoroughly disappointed. It will not turn on until it is really cold, like around 40-45 degrees or so. As a result i ended up using my old heater instead.
When it does turn on (which has been about five times this winter) it won't turn off automatically so the room just got hotter and hotter until i turned it off. I can't program it to turn on/off at certain times because that part doesn't work.
I called customer service (which is lousy-you can't get them half the time after waiting a long time) and they told me to do this and that which i did, but nothing worked. I bought it in the summer when it became available so by the time i tried using it in the winter the money back guarantee was over.
So i'm stuck with a $400 piece of garbage. |
|
Sorb User ID: 642029 3/24/2009 7:50 PM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote | I read several reviews online and talked to someone I know who bought a CZInfrared (ComfortZone) infrared heater. It was a much better build then their competitors and came recommended by said friend. She said she saw a fair dip in her utility bill by zone heating which is what these are all about. I decided to buy one and saved almost $40 my first month. Basically I use it in my computer room and roll it to my bed room before bed if I'm being a wuss that night. The reviews said I should turn my furnace down several degrees which leaves the house tolerable but not uncomfortable and I stay toasty in the room where I spend the bulk of my time.
I was hesitant to buy a heater since I have a furnace that heats my house and moneys kinda tight. But lucky for me my friend pointed out that this is a way to save money. Once the unit pays for itself I will be making more money off smart heating then off my interest in my savings...
I have a 1500 $40 heater from Walmart that I have tried to warm my room at night with instead of the CZInfrared and it failed miserably at warming my room in a short time before going to bed. Funny that it consumes the same amount of my electricity and puts out the same BTU's but doesn't heat as well. |
|
Over9000 User ID: 674925 5/8/2009 3:51 PM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote | I tried a few conventional electric space heaters, even a propane one, and I was not happy with them. The kids would brush up against them and singe their clothes. I bought a heater at www.czinfraredheaters.com and I couldn't be happier with it. |
|
Solar Comfort Heating User ID: 806230 10/30/2009 1:15 AM | | Re: Space Heaters Reviews | Quote | Although I can sell any of the brands of Infrared Heaters, I choose only Solar Comfort for safety, simplicity, ease of use, quality, no digitals that will fail, no plastic but rather double walled metal as well as the fact that the manufacturer has been selling since 1980's.
To learn more about Infrared Heaters as well as Solar Comfort visit [link to www.solarcomfortheating.com] |
|
|