Looking over this thread the last couple of days, all I see is the debunkers bringing forth one reference and fact after another and Clare only dancing around everything with ridiculous new age mumbo-jumbo. PX either exists and manifests itself in observable and testable ways or it is purely imaginary. Thus far, not a single shred of evidene for its existance has been give except the laughable schtick of Clare claiming that maybe we can't ever "know" anything. What a crock of shit!
Clare, you've made an admirable attempt...at least better than any other bunker to date. But the fact remains that you have brought forth not the first scintilla of evidence for any reasonable person to even entertain the thought that px may exist as claimed by Nancy.
Case closed.
Quoting: Anonymous Coward 974869I responded with items which have not been answered fully yet, and answered more honestly than the debunkers on things like hoax claims not being bedrock of logical proof of hoaxes.
Only the German fellow is taking me up on the bigger questions.
However, the SPT images seem in fact to be hoaxed, if the SPT images must look like the image linked to by someone (I forget who now).
And no-one has handled the holes of repulsion in the magnetosphere at the wrong time (when the Sun attracts) either.
Any takers?
And I have been absolutely consistent in acknowledging all points and pointing out when they do and when they don't add up.
For instance, the SOHO images have no corollary "flares" on any of Menow's pages.
So, how does that add up to "the debunkers have given ideas" and I "just haven't acknowledged they were superior at all of it"?
Hm?
Not true.
This discussion is not closed, at all, or you will have fallen into error. Not so much about PX itself necessarily: it may turn out all the points I raised are debunkable, but not all have been yet.
Have a great day though. Thanks for the partial personal compliment, however. It is decent of you and you deserve one back. Now keep checking ... it's not proven one way or another yet.
