Debunker Talk LIVE Chat 24/7 - A debunker's paradise!!

Remember, Nancy has stated on numerous occasions that 2012 is "too far out"...that the "pole shift" will occur BEFORE 2012.

Of course, nothing will happen and you'll have to buy Hap his steak.

I heard from the Dr. and yes, he is taking it with dignity and philosophy. I am sorry to see him go, and I am also sorry that my friends here are going, as will I.

Max, I think that last post is the most truthful and sincere thing you have ever posted. I will miss sparring with you too.

This thread is really the only reason I came here, and with my friends dropping like flies, I too bow out.

Take care, everyone! It has been fun!

I'll still check in once and awhile and "keep the light on". Of course if this REALLY does become a "ghost" thread, it won't be any fun for me either.

True that! Cheers Max.

Your approach to life isn't the healthiest, but I have my flaws as well.

Take care KIR!

Reason has left the building...

How much detailed information came out of the one brain of Isaac Asimov? Or Arthur C. Clarke? Or J. R. R. Tolkien?

And all of it much more cohesive and original than all of ZetaTalk.

Anyway, ditto what everyone else is saying.

This place won't be any fun without Dr. Postman.

Are you placing Nancy in the same league as Asimov and Clarke????????????????

Only in terms of "quantity".

In terms of quantity . . . I still think one elder woman would have a real problem with years and years of crap without some type of significant assistance and/or interference . . . and the interference having resources. I realize she has gaffs, etc. yet the volume of stuff keeps pouring out seemingly without limit.

The scenario you speak of is certainly a possibility. I think it is also possible that she has created the entirety that is ZetaTalk all on her own. This would take much time and commitment…. but let’s be honest, it’s not like Nancy spends her days walking her dog or her nights clubbing.

<laughing>

Yes, I realize that many of you will be tempted to post a humorous response about “clubbing” and “dogs”, but try to resist………………………………………………………………Nevermind, go ahead if you want.

There are always new dog recipes to try, after all she has to keep her two followers happy.

I give her ability to create the whole thing, sustain it for years, as well as being able to maintain a loyal following of accomplices as quite difficult . . . I say only one in three.

Last Edited by George B on 02/09/2011 04:44 PM

For the last year we have been giving the ning grief about their rules and banning policies…with good reason.

It will be interesting to see how consistent we are with our scorn.

take care after the shit thats gone down ive decided not to stay.

Take care fun conversing maybe see ya on other boards somewhere in cyberspace

I'm going silent too.

I have better things to do with my time right now - got a couple good sideline writing projects that pay a decent rate.

Need the extra money to finish up the house I bought - needs cabinets, appliances, air conditioning, etc...typical Florida foreclosure.

As for zetasquawk, it's still there...just not going to get updated for a while...unless Nancy or her sheep make a really good gaffe.

Take care Bob.

What a shame...I wish you all the best.

I was on leave by the coast so I missed what happened, can someone update me?

Dr. Postman was banned and of course removed as a Mod etc. Many of us are don't understand the actions . . . Some are leaving in protest. . .

I don't know, there are a lot of internal contradictions in the Zetatalk canon, a lot of which have been pointed out in this thread. And the Zetas' messages sometimes have the kind of passive-aggressive personal sniping that you'd expect if the whole thing was just a vehicle for Nancy's frustration with herself, others, and the world at large. I wouldn't expect to see that kind of thing if it was any kind of well-thought-out, large-scale operation.

I see the same behavior in major academic departments of universities world wide. . . You think they are being influenced by the same forces! LoL!!!!!!!

Last Edited by George B on 02/10/2011 09:54 AM

Disinformation doesn't have to be "perfect". The point is that Nancy assembles a LOT of information which has an impressive internal consistency (if not "external") - which by ordinary human standards is a LOT OF WORK. I've been to her house - it is NOT a research library by ANY stretch. I personnally witnessed one of her "chats" as she was doing it - and she really was just typing away at like 150 words a minute answering questions just as they came in from the questioners. Her ability to answer all these diverse questions live and in real time was impressive, if indeed lacking in precision. Now, I wasn't looking over her shoulder, and it could be that she was copying from another screen where the answers were being fed to her by an offsite "team" - but that is purely speculation. Nancy would certainly be allowed to put such info in her "own words" - sniping away as you put it.

But if she really was "channelling" this information, then she was also putting her "gloss" on it too, but putting that "spin" on detailed information she was getting either auditorially, or visually or in some way that is not the "norm".

Ordinary people cannot just "make up" stuff that consistently, and that rapidly. Something "ELSE" is definitly going on.

I think you underestimate the extent to which people can come up with things like this, as well as the number of contradictions within Zetatalk. Nancy's been doing this for many, many years now and has an established base of first principles to build upon. Enough practice results in fluency, especially when you don't need to check for internal consistency. She doesn't need a research library because 99% of what she says is either made-up or simply available on the Internet. In fact, a lot of what the "Zetas" have been saying in the last few months has been berating people for stressing Nancy out when she has to spend time learning about plate tectonics and things like that.

Beyond that, a lot of her chat sessions, these days at least, are simply repetitions of earlier Zetatalk or "what's going to happen in this particular region?" Not exactly the hardest thing to pull off. You could make a case that she has a talent for writing on the fly, but there's nothing superhuman about it.

Besides Max, you of all people should know that it's not too difficult to adopt a "persona" and answer questions as if you're that person...!

Max, I find your experience very interesting. Would you say she was in some type of trance, or altered state of awareness? I too believe what she does is too exhausting for someone of her age year after year. While her information is available elsewhere to keep it logical at all is a major undertaking. I easily believe she is getting help and/or is being influenced by techniques she is not aware of . . . in both case she is a victim as much as a villain.

I haven't talked to Jamie about this, but for me, it is over the line. From what I can gather, there is a lot of subterfuge in volved and I don't care to support it in any way. Too bad there isn't another place where we could regroup, is there?

I will reiterate, one more time, my take on what Nancy is doing. I say that Nancy is "channelling"(whatever that truly is) and has become possessed by the "channelled" entity(s) in some way. She denies that is what she is doing, but I have seen it from a close, personal perspective many times over many years and this is exactly what it looks like.

The 'consistency' is that it is routinely false, intentionally misrepresentative of facts and manipulative of certain people.

Yes, they can. Just look at this site for starters. There are people making up material on the spot all the time.

As I said before there are writers generating many pages a day of imaginary information.

And ZetaTalk is NOT especially consistent or original. Large portions of it are obviously copped straight from the internet and other sources of paranormal theories.

I will take your word for it . . . seems like Nancy is susceptible to such a possession. It would explain much of her behavior . . .in your experience what is/are the motives behind the possessions?

Liar LIEDer is not an ordinary person, she is a senile, delusional, mentally ill, hate filled old woman. Hardly ordinary if by ordinary you mean "healthy" or "sane."