Debunker Talk LIVE Chat 24/7 - A debunker's paradise!!

Yes, I do.

But open mindedness doesn't mean absolutely everything is accepted at face value. Nancy's PX ideas are provably false, and her idea has failed every experiment put to it.

She claimed a halted Earth. All evidence points to it moving as predicted around the Sun.

She claimed Earth's pole makes a figure eight motion in the sky. It doesn't.

She claimed the Solstices and Equinoxes don't line up as predicted. They do.

She claimed other unpredictable motions of the heavens. Yet GOTO telescopes continue to track, demonstrating her claim as false.

She claimed the Venus Transit wouldn't happen. It did.

She claimed Java is 80 feet underwater. It's not.

She claimed the aliens in her head predict things with 100 percent accuracy. They don't.

I was more open minded about her ideas years ago. However, further analysis of the data, and her subsequent appalling performance, has shown she's simply wrong. Her continued promotion of the PX idea in the light of such concrete evidence to the contrary seems to fit nicely into the 'delusional' category, such as it is.

In your version of 'open mindedness,' do you really accept all ideas put to you equally, or as equally likely?

Not yet

I don't understand why everything turns out opposite of my intentions?

Just like Nancy. Eternally wrong. I wonder if they get a kick out of always being wrong.

I fail

Rolls the dice...

I fail

<tooting horns>

<falling confetti>

<screams of joy>

<sigh>

Upon further thinking, it would have been apropos if you would have ushered in the one thousandenth page. Poster boy and all that....

i tried ... and ****FAILED****

I think ZM's punishment should be to put away the Role-Playing character for ten pages, and post as himself -- and be perfectly honest and forthright about exactly what he believes and what he doesn't. He should have to stop playing the contrarian. He should articulate his true positions, rather than just attemt to stir things up.

Of course, he might be attempting to do just that -- but I have *serious* doubts that is the case.

Or, perhaps he should be forced to play the debunker role DIRECTLY to Nancy, over on her Ning for a month -- or at least until all his possible accounts are banned from the Ning, whichever comes first.

OK - I will agree to this. For the next ten pages I will answer ALL questions as honestly as I can - with one exception. I will not and will continue to not, share any information publicly that will reveal my real identity. In all honesty, the majority of my posts have been for "fun" - to blow off steam, and allow for an outlet of my daily frustrations with the world.

I'm now taking suggestions as to what Max's punishment should be.