Now they're stealing your Pre-K years even w/o a TV. | |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 744446 United States 08/14/2009 04:41 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
TurnOffYourTV (OP) User ID: 727691 United States 08/14/2009 04:49 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | reading helps to develop an imagination, as well as other valuable skills. i can't imagine why anyone in their right mind would want to believe that learning to read at a young age could be bad. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 744446I guess you haven't seen what kids books are saying these days. It's more about the content than the reading. And sorry, reading shapes thinking...it doesn't necessarily help you to develop an imagination. Playing helps develop an imagination though...so does making art and music...anything requiring creativity develops imagination. Reading does no such thing. KILL YOUR TV NOW! IT IS HYPNOTIZING AND BRAINWASHING YOU! TURN IT OFF FOR GOOD! |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 745002 Canada 08/14/2009 04:55 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Wait so reading is bad but looking at art and listening to music is good? What if the art contains words? Is the music without lyrics? Do you just compose the song in a sound-proof room? I don't see what you're getting at. Reading causes you to use your imagination - if you're reading Treasure Island, say, you're forced to imagine the ship, the characters, you have to imagine up a whole world for all this to take place in, everything that isn't shown to you completely. If a character is described as a young woman in a ball gown, with long blonde hair, you have to fill in the details with your imagination: what kind of gown, what style of hair, what does she look like. |
TurnOffYourTV (OP) User ID: 727691 United States 08/14/2009 05:01 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Wait so reading is bad but looking at art and listening to music is good? Quoting: Anonymous Coward 745002What if the art contains words? Is the music without lyrics? Do you just compose the song in a sound-proof room? I don't see what you're getting at. Reading causes you to use your imagination - if you're reading Treasure Island, say, you're forced to imagine the ship, the characters, you have to imagine up a whole world for all this to take place in, everything that isn't shown to you completely. If a character is described as a young woman in a ball gown, with long blonde hair, you have to fill in the details with your imagination: what kind of gown, what style of hair, what does she look like. I didn't say "listening" or "looking at." I said "making"...or at least I certainly implied that. you're forced to imagine the ship. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 745002How exactly is that using your imagination? You said it for me, thanks... Last Edited by TurnOffYourTV on 08/14/2009 05:02 PM KILL YOUR TV NOW! IT IS HYPNOTIZING AND BRAINWASHING YOU! TURN IT OFF FOR GOOD! |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 744446 United States 08/14/2009 05:03 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
TurnOffYourTV (OP) User ID: 727691 United States 08/14/2009 05:08 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | you're forced to imagine the ship. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 744446How exactly is that using your imagination? You said it for me thanks... umm...how is it not using your imagination? If you have to ask that...you don't get it. I already showed you. If I "forced" you to think of a ship...then you didn't think of the ship...I did. imagination: noun the faculty or action of forming new ideas. Last Edited by TurnOffYourTV on 08/14/2009 05:09 PM KILL YOUR TV NOW! IT IS HYPNOTIZING AND BRAINWASHING YOU! TURN IT OFF FOR GOOD! |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 744446 United States 08/14/2009 05:13 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | you're forced to imagine the ship. Quoting: TurnOffYourTVHow exactly is that using your imagination? You said it for me thanks... umm...how is it not using your imagination? If you have to ask that...you don't get it. I already showed you. If I "forced" you to think of a ship...then you didn't think of the ship...I did. imagination: noun the faculty or action of forming new ideas. first of all, you aren't forced to use your imagination when reading a book. it's an incredibly boring way to read, but it's possible, no one has a gun to your head. secondly, even if you were being forced to use your imagination, you are still using your imagination. you tell me to think of a ship, sure i'll think of a ship, but who's to say what kind of ship it is? i could be thinking, and likely am thinking, of a completely different ship from the one you've thought of. yes, books often have a lot of detail, but the very fact that you can put those details together in your imagination strengthens your imagination. |
TurnOffYourTV (OP) User ID: 727691 United States 08/14/2009 05:18 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | you're forced to imagine the ship. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 744446How exactly is that using your imagination? You said it for me thanks... umm...how is it not using your imagination? If you have to ask that...you don't get it. I already showed you. If I "forced" you to think of a ship...then you didn't think of the ship...I did. imagination: noun the faculty or action of forming new ideas. first of all, you aren't forced to use your imagination when reading a book. it's an incredibly boring way to read, but it's possible, no one has a gun to your head. secondly, even if you were being forced to use your imagination, you are still using your imagination. you tell me to think of a ship, sure i'll think of a ship, but who's to say what kind of ship it is? i could be thinking, and likely am thinking, of a completely different ship from the one you've thought of. yes, books often have a lot of detail, but the very fact that you can put those details together in your imagination strengthens your imagination. You said forced...not me. And you make some valid points. But you seem to be missing my point...and you're not showing me that you are willing to see it. So don't worry about it. Believe what you want. This thread was obviously not for you. Last Edited by TurnOffYourTV on 08/14/2009 05:19 PM KILL YOUR TV NOW! IT IS HYPNOTIZING AND BRAINWASHING YOU! TURN IT OFF FOR GOOD! |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 744446 United States 08/14/2009 05:24 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | You said forced...not me. And you make some valid points. But you seem to be missing my point...and you're not showing me that you are willing to. Quoting: TurnOffYourTVSo don't worry about it. that was a different AC. i see your point, i just disagree with it. if you want to teach children to think for themselves you've got to first give them the ability and strength to think, and being able to read and interpret words plays a major part in that. it's almost like you're throwing the baby out with the bathwater here. |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 744446 United States 08/14/2009 05:26 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 748834 United States 08/14/2009 05:26 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 720114 United States 08/14/2009 06:23 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | good goin op....best way to create sheep is to tell them they dont have to learn how to read are you gunna read everything for them? i know many adults that cant read and let me tell you....they arent very creative....kinda hard to research something if you cant read just be creative jimmy....we'll run the world for you idiot |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 722924 United States 08/14/2009 06:26 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | reading helps to develop an imagination, as well as other valuable skills. i can't imagine why anyone in their right mind would want to believe that learning to read at a young age could be bad. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 744446Couldn't have said it better myself. My mother taught me to read before I was in kindergarten, and I have a lifelong love of books and reading as a result. It has helped my life immeasurably. |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 722924 United States 08/14/2009 06:28 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | And sorry, reading shapes thinking...it doesn't necessarily help you to develop an imagination. Playing helps develop an imagination though...so does making art and music...anything requiring creativity develops imagination. Reading does no such thing. Quoting: TurnOffYourTVWho says reading is mutually exclusive to playing and making music and art? How absurd. |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 747699 United States 08/14/2009 06:41 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
TurnOffYourTV (OP) User ID: 727691 United States 08/14/2009 07:57 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | if you want to teach children to think for themselves you've got to first give them the ability and strength to think, and being able to read and interpret words plays a major part in that. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 744446I agree. But where did I ever say that a person or a child should not learn to read. Nowhere. So are you saying that in order to be able to think you have to learn to read by the age of 3? Thinking is not reading. good goin op....best way to create sheep is to tell them they dont have to learn how to read Quoting: Anonymous Coward 720114Again, When did I ever say someone should not learn how to read? I never said that. So, thanks for playing. Do you have a point?" Maybe you should people should have "read" the title of this thread and the content of the OP. Did you actually read it? How ironic that you are arguing about thinking and reading, and yet, not doing them both at the same time. How many times do I need to say "Pre-K," and "first five years" in a paragraph for you to "read" it? lol, good point. Everything in moderation. There is definitely a learning age range where it needs to happen. They do associate higher IQ with an early ability to learn. IQ has nothing to do with common sense but engaging the children causes the brain to build connections. They do need lots of attention and training. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 747699See, I don't think a lot of these people realise how brainwashed we are. It's not just the TV...it's movies, books (yes, I attacked your precious books), internet, the music industry, etc... Books brainwash! So they want you to start reading by the time your 2...when you are most formative. Didn't anyone else understand my point here? They will find any way to indoctrinate you as soon as possible. Anyone else want to pretend I'm advocating illiteracy? And you call me an idiot... KILL YOUR TV NOW! IT IS HYPNOTIZING AND BRAINWASHING YOU! TURN IT OFF FOR GOOD! |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 744446 United States 08/14/2009 08:11 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 744446 United States 08/14/2009 08:12 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
Art Deco User ID: 473495 United States 08/14/2009 08:18 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | reading helps to develop an imagination, as well as other valuable skills. i can't imagine why anyone in their right mind would want to believe that learning to read at a young age could be bad. Quoting: TurnOffYourTVI guess you haven't seen what kids books are saying these days. It's more about the content than the reading. And sorry, reading shapes thinking...it doesn't necessarily help you to develop an imagination. Playing helps develop an imagination though...so does making art and music...anything requiring creativity develops imagination. Reading does no such thing. My God, you're an idiot In ten years we'll look back on this moment, laugh nervously, and quickly change the subject. |
TurnOffYourTV (OP) User ID: 727691 United States 08/14/2009 08:24 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | and if you're so paranoid to believe that They will indoctrinate you with anything they have, then you may as well teach the kid how to read at an early age, because s/he's fucking doomed to be indoctrinated anyway, right? Quoting: Anonymous Coward 744446No, I'm advocating exactly the opposite of stunting growth. I'm advocating creative thought in the formative years (that's the first five), instead of indoctrinated thought. That gives a person the best chance of thinking for themselves later. Yes, we are doomed to be indoctrinated. That is fact. I just think the ability to engage in creative thought is key to ultimate mental freedom. Alright, you don't agree. That's cool. I'm just trying to share some info, and make a point. Thanks for the debate. KILL YOUR TV NOW! IT IS HYPNOTIZING AND BRAINWASHING YOU! TURN IT OFF FOR GOOD! |
TurnOffYourTV (OP) User ID: 727691 United States 08/14/2009 08:26 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
Art Deco User ID: 473495 United States 08/14/2009 08:29 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | My God, you're an idiot Quoting: TurnOffYourTVI am not your G-d. Did you have a point? Or did you just want to call me names? My point is, you're an idiot. The name calling was a bonus In ten years we'll look back on this moment, laugh nervously, and quickly change the subject. |
TurnOffYourTV (OP) User ID: 727691 United States 08/14/2009 08:37 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | My God, you're an idiot Quoting: Art DecoI am not your G-d. Did you have a point? Or did you just want to call me names? My point is, you're an idiot. The name calling was a bonus Good for you...I hope you feel better. KILL YOUR TV NOW! IT IS HYPNOTIZING AND BRAINWASHING YOU! TURN IT OFF FOR GOOD! |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 720114 United States 08/14/2009 08:42 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | i read the title btw...who is they? your parents are the ones who have to buy the program and teach you so your basically saying everyones parents are gunna steal thier own kids imaginations by teaching them to read i assume you support hooked on phonics so "they" can steal your imagination at an acceptable age.....unless you learned it in school....then i guess the school stole it the only problem i see is parents are gunna have to either learn sign language or make one up cuz the whole spelling something so the kids dont know what were talkin about isnt gunna work anymore ok so dont teach your kid anything before the age of 5 total idiot |
TurnOffYourTV (OP) User ID: 727691 United States 08/14/2009 09:26 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | btw...who is they? Quoting: Anonymous Coward 720114I think you mean who 'are' they? That statement leads me to believe that you have no idea what's going on. I'm not getting into that now. There are probably thousands of threads on GLP for you to investigate to find that out. So do that...then come back and debate. Last Edited by TurnOffYourTV on 08/14/2009 11:48 PM KILL YOUR TV NOW! IT IS HYPNOTIZING AND BRAINWASHING YOU! TURN IT OFF FOR GOOD! |
Anonymous Coward (OP) User ID: 727691 United States 08/15/2009 12:42 AM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Reading over this thread again has led me to a troubling realization. It seems that a lot of people are believing that the ability to read, or reading per se, is the same as, or leads to intelligence, or the ability to think more critically. How does this make any sense? Reading is merely a means of taking in information. It's a means of taking in information to generate thought...usually, a certain type of thought, depending on what it is your reading. Doesn't the 'quality' of that information, not the reading (per se), have a direct correlation to the quality of the thought it provokes? So, 'just reading,' doesn't really mean that you are provoking the creative or critical thinking associated with intelligence, does it? You can read meaningless dribble right? In fact, I'll bet we all do that from time to time. That doesn't mean you're getting smarter, or more creative, but rather...entertained in those cases. I'll bet (and this is just a hunch...no facts here), that if you took 2 illiterate three-year-old children of equal IQ's, had one play (create) on the piano for an hour a day, and the other read fiction for an hour a day until they were five-years-old...after which, both children went on to develop normally (work with me here on "normally"), the piano playing child would be more intelligent, more creative, and stronger in critical thinking skills than the fiction reading child. And before you go off half cocked and say that I am torturing this piano playing child for forbidding him/her to read...that child begins reading at age 5. And the other child begins piano lessons at age 5. |
ShadowDancer User ID: 287857 United States 08/15/2009 05:24 AM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | From my studies unless the child desires to learn it early it is best to wait until 5 or 6 It has to do with childrens' eye muscles...this is why many do not recommend a night light also-both can cause eye damage-making the muscles perform at a higher level than they are ready for,leading to the need for corrective lenses... research this-it is out there ************************************ fortitudo et spes ************************************ When Japan happened I responded: "The Excrement Has Impacted the Rotary Oscillator." and clearly it has. Thread: The Excrement Is Striking the Rotary Oscillator +++++++++++++++ "Ego et Dominus sumus amici" +++++++++++++++ Ego et mea umbra +++++++++++++++ 'Man does not have the right to develop his own mind. This kind of liberal orientation has great appeal. We must electrically control the brain. Some day armies and generals will be controlled by electric stimulation of the brain.’ - U.S. government mind manipulator, Dr. Jose Delgado, Congressional Record, No. 262E, Vol. 118, 1974 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ Realeyesrealizereallies. C. Thread: GIRD uP as GRID Collapses Thread: Eugenics 101 (Page 27) Thread: Frankenfoods for YOU (Page 2) Thread: I Do Not Consent Thread: FOOD Thread: Cern Power___Colder than Space Thread: Hempilation Compilation Contemplation Thread: Harmonics and Healing (Page 35) Thread: Sarah's Nightmare (Page 10) Thread: Destination Maccabees Thread: Let's Play a GAME Thread: Throat Singing |
ShadowDancer User ID: 287857 United States 08/15/2009 05:28 AM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | all my kids love to read-the eldest has decreased it due to eye issues and attention lol reading is good but the child is the one driving their learning...the more the 'gov' czars act as experts the more offensive it becomes-I know my child, they know nothing the more they try to fix things, the greater the mess imho ************************************ fortitudo et spes ************************************ When Japan happened I responded: "The Excrement Has Impacted the Rotary Oscillator." and clearly it has. Thread: The Excrement Is Striking the Rotary Oscillator +++++++++++++++ "Ego et Dominus sumus amici" +++++++++++++++ Ego et mea umbra +++++++++++++++ 'Man does not have the right to develop his own mind. This kind of liberal orientation has great appeal. We must electrically control the brain. Some day armies and generals will be controlled by electric stimulation of the brain.’ - U.S. government mind manipulator, Dr. Jose Delgado, Congressional Record, No. 262E, Vol. 118, 1974 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ Realeyesrealizereallies. C. Thread: GIRD uP as GRID Collapses Thread: Eugenics 101 (Page 27) Thread: Frankenfoods for YOU (Page 2) Thread: I Do Not Consent Thread: FOOD Thread: Cern Power___Colder than Space Thread: Hempilation Compilation Contemplation Thread: Harmonics and Healing (Page 35) Thread: Sarah's Nightmare (Page 10) Thread: Destination Maccabees Thread: Let's Play a GAME Thread: Throat Singing |