See this is where you lose me. Elenin hasn't proven to be very significant. There are ZERO photographs of it in the month of September being very large or bright. Even amateur astronomers have said it's all but gone. And if something IS following it, why haven't any credible amateur astronomers seen it yet? Especially if it's that big that it can eclipse the Sun? I have genuine questions, I am just trying to think logically about this.