Godlike Productions - Discussion Forum
Users Online Now: 1,949 (Who's On?)Visitors Today: 735,663
Pageviews Today: 1,287,311Threads Today: 417Posts Today: 8,630
12:57 PM


Rate this Thread

Absolute BS Crap Reasonable Nice Amazing
 

California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer

 
nightlight7
Offer Upgrade

User ID: 48343469
United States
01/05/2014 10:58 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
From the article by S.D. Harris in American Thinker [link to www.americanthinker.com]

Sam Singer, spokesman for the Children's Hospital Oakland, has taken it upon himself to dictate the limits of hope and prayer.

Singer is one of the players in the gut wrenching saga of Jahi McMath, the 13-year-old Northern California girl who went in for a tonsillectomy and ended up brain dead. [...]

In a jaw-dropping statement, made on behalf of the hospital, Mr. Singer, speaking with greater authority than anyone could have imagined, told the world: "There is, unfortunately, no amount of hope, no amount of prayer that can bring her back." [...]

A hospital spokesperson should deal in facts. Hope and prayer are not facts. No one should dictate to another man what the limits of his hope should be. Greater than that, Mr. Singers' revelation that he personally knows that prayer will not work is an insult to people of all faiths. Unless Mr. Singer is speaking on behalf of God himself and not the Children's Hospital, he is going to have a lot of explaining to do [...]

It seems the sickness industry has concluded that God is a just another clerk in their bureaucracy, subject to their rules and dictates.
IntoTheLight

User ID: 52499059
United States
01/05/2014 12:08 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
It's good to see sanity returning to hospitals.

Prayer has no effect. Prayer is a theological black hole and there's no empirical evidence to prove that it works.

Here's the good news Bible-Tards: Prayer has no effect! That means you can stop mumbling your platitudes and actually do something productive; for example, donating to cancer research or helping families with their medical bills.

Prayer is mental-masturbation from weak-willed people too lazy to do anything useful or meaningful with their lives.

sheeppopesheep
6 months UK then 6 months USA.

I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.
nightlight7  (OP)

User ID: 48343469
United States
01/05/2014 12:27 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
It's good to see sanity returning to hospitals.

Prayer has no effect.
 Quoting: IntoTheLight


It surely seems to have quite an effect on you, at least. Even just mentioning the prayer got your adrenalin pumping. Imagine what the real thing will do to you some day, once you mature a bit from the public school indoctrination.

Although your teachers may have not brought that to your attention, the medical research officially recognizes and appreciates greatly the power of beliefs to beneficially affect healing. For example, any new drug must be tested in placebo controlled manner -- one half of test subjects receives real drug, the other receives placebo. Both groups will improve and the effectiveness of the drug is judged relative to placebo, not to improvement itself.

If the patient's beliefs had no beneficial effect on healing, there would be no reason to more than double the costs and efforts for the drug trials.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 26257191
United States
01/05/2014 01:58 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
I'm not a bible-tard and I believe in the power of prayer.

All prayers are answered, just maybe not the way we want.

It certainly doesn't hurt to pray so why not?
IntoTheLight

User ID: 52509393
United States
01/05/2014 02:54 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
It's good to see sanity returning to hospitals.

Prayer has no effect.
 Quoting: IntoTheLight


It surely seems to have quite an effect on you, at least. Even just mentioning the prayer got your adrenalin pumping. Imagine what the real thing will do to you some day, once you mature a bit from the public school indoctrination.

Although your teachers may have not brought that to your attention, the medical research officially recognizes and appreciates greatly the power of beliefs to beneficially affect healing. For example, any new drug must be tested in placebo controlled manner -- one half of test subjects receives real drug, the other receives placebo. Both groups will improve and the effectiveness of the drug is judged relative to placebo, not to improvement itself.

If the patient's beliefs had no beneficial effect on healing, there would be no reason to more than double the costs and efforts for the drug trials.
 Quoting: nightlight7


Ha!

You felt the need to post and bewail the good sense of a hospital.It seems to have got your adrenalin pumping. I hope one day, once you mature a bit from your Bible school indoctrination, you will educate yourself and discover the truth.

Your poor grasp of double-blind and pharmacological testing is,quick frankly, astounding. A placebo does not require faith in a deity to work, and your poor attempt to link the two,is most probably due to your lack of ability to apply critical thinking skills.

I believe this is fairly common amongst Bible-Tards.

Please, in future, try to construct a more coherent and logical, argument. It is what your mythical GAWD would want.

cruise
6 months UK then 6 months USA.

I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.
nightlight7  (OP)

User ID: 48343469
United States
01/05/2014 08:46 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
Ha!

You felt the need to post and bewail the good sense of a hospital.It seems to have got your adrenalin pumping. I hope one day, once you mature a bit from your Bible school indoctrination, you will educate yourself and discover the truth.
 Quoting: IntoTheLight


I am actually a scientist (theoretical physicist, working as chief scientist in industry, presently on optimization of large Data Center switching networks, which is math related to some physics problems) and have never read, let alone studied, Bible.

Your poor grasp of double-blind and pharmacological testing is,quick frankly, astounding. A placebo does not require faith in a deity to work, and your poor attempt to link the two,is most probably due to your lack of ability to apply critical thinking skills.
 Quoting: IntoTheLight


You need to read more carefully before responding since I never said anything about "belief in deity" but only wrote about general "belief" (in healing).
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 52521036
Brazil
01/05/2014 09:03 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
It's good to see sanity returning to hospitals.

Prayer has no effect. Prayer is a theological black hole and there's no empirical evidence to prove that it works.

Here's the good news Bible-Tards: Prayer has no effect! That means you can stop mumbling your platitudes and actually do something productive; for example, donating to cancer research or helping families with their medical bills.

Prayer is mental-masturbation from weak-willed people too lazy to do anything useful or meaningful with their lives.

sheeppopesheep
 Quoting: IntoTheLight


ASStheist. The true ill calling a prophetical book bad.
IntoTheLight

User ID: 52509393
United States
01/05/2014 09:06 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
Ha!

You felt the need to post and bewail the good sense of a hospital.It seems to have got your adrenalin pumping. I hope one day, once you mature a bit from your Bible school indoctrination, you will educate yourself and discover the truth.
 Quoting: IntoTheLight


I am actually a scientist (theoretical physicist, working as chief scientist in industry, presently on optimization of large Data Center switching networks, which is math related to some physics problems) and have never read, let alone studied, Bible.

Your poor grasp of double-blind and pharmacological testing is,quick frankly, astounding. A placebo does not require faith in a deity to work, and your poor attempt to link the two,is most probably due to your lack of ability to apply critical thinking skills.
 Quoting: IntoTheLight


You need to read more carefully before responding since I never said anything about "belief in deity" but only wrote about general "belief" (in healing).
 Quoting: nightlight7


Unlike yourself, I do not feel the need to list my professional qualifications. Your need to self-aggrandize already tells me more than I need to know about you.

You also need to re-read your post(s).For a scientist, your syntax, sentence structure and above all,your comprehension skills, are sadly lacking.

As to you post and your desperate attempt to try and emote an emotional response,I respond thusly:

God does not exist.Just a sad and desperate need, from emotionally immature people, to abdicate responsibility for their life, to an invisible 'cloud-faerie.'

I hope this clarifies my position on this matter.

sheep

Last Edited by IntoTheLight on 01/05/2014 09:18 PM
6 months UK then 6 months USA.

I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 52513247
Canada
01/05/2014 09:08 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
Op, I started a thread on Jahi last night.

Thread: Weigh in on Jahi McMath story

I don't think he was intending to over ride God's opinion.
He is just reiterating the opinions of three separate doctors who have reached the same conclusion. I hope and pray she can live through this move too.
nightlight7  (OP)

User ID: 48343469
United States
01/05/2014 09:20 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
Unlike yourself, I do not feel the need to list my professional qualifications. Your need to self-aggrandize already tells me more than I need to know about you.
 Quoting: IntoTheLight


That wasn't about self-aggrandizement, but merely to correct your wrong guess about it. You didn't need to provide anything about your background since I wasn't arguing ad hominem and making guesses about (lack of) your qualifications.

You also need to re-read your post(s).For a scientist, your syntax, sentence structure and above all,your comprehension skills, are sadly lacking.
 Quoting: IntoTheLight


Try writing something in your fifth language learned at age 20, as I am doing when writing in English, and see how the native speakers evaluate it.
duFontaine.

User ID: 29412599
United States
01/05/2014 09:25 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
It's good to see sanity returning to hospitals.

Prayer has no effect. Prayer is a theological black hole and there's no empirical evidence to prove that it works.

Here's the good news Bible-Tards: Prayer has no effect! That means you can stop mumbling your platitudes and actually do something productive; for example, donating to cancer research or helping families with their medical bills.

Prayer is mental-masturbation from weak-willed people too lazy to do anything useful or meaningful with their lives.

sheeppopesheep
 Quoting: IntoTheLight


The law of attraction is real. Thought does manifest. Group focused intent does have power. It has nothing to do with religion. Its natural law in this co-created observer centric reality.
"Accept now that all you have seen from the day of your birth on the surface of the earth, to the present, are wonderful only because the finite mind of man is confused with fragments of evidence, that, from whatever direction we meet them, spring from an unreachable infinity."

"There was a man who could create what could not be imagined. A temple so great you questioned if it was built with human hands. A man who built an idea into the greatest force the world has ever known. A world built from a single word. I care not for the folly of man but for the end of human contention."
IntoTheLight

User ID: 52509393
United States
01/05/2014 09:34 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
Unlike yourself, I do not feel the need to list my professional qualifications. Your need to self-aggrandize already tells me more than I need to know about you.
 Quoting: IntoTheLight


That wasn't about self-aggrandizement, but merely to correct your wrong guess about it. You didn't need to provide anything about your background since I wasn't arguing ad hominem and making guesses about (lack of) your qualifications.

You also need to re-read your post(s).For a scientist, your syntax, sentence structure and above all,your comprehension skills, are sadly lacking.
 Quoting: IntoTheLight


Try writing something in your fifth language learned at age 20, as I am doing when writing in English, and see how the native speakers evaluate it.
 Quoting: nightlight7



Thank-you for proving my point, my petulant little friend.

Your 'ad-hominem' attack is quite obvious as is your continuing attempt to elicit an emotional response.

I'm glad you can speak 'five' languages. I do not feel the need to self-aggrandize myself as to my capabilities or skills.

Maybe I'm speaking in my 'seventh' language?

Please try to focus and discuss the matter at hand, which was the 'power' of prayer, and less on your desire to prove how intelligent, or not, you are.

Thanks!

cruise

Last Edited by IntoTheLight on 01/05/2014 09:35 PM
6 months UK then 6 months USA.

I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 41479959
United States
01/05/2014 10:36 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
I'm not sure "hope" is covered under obamacare unless you pay for the platinum plan.


But seriously...that guy keeps calling her a "body" in press conferences and that is just mean.
nightlight7  (OP)

User ID: 48343469
United States
01/05/2014 10:44 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
I'm not sure "hope" is covered under obamacare unless you pay for the platinum plan.


But seriously...that guy keeps calling her a "body" in press conferences and that is just mean.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 41479959


Mr. Singer ought at least to apologize to the family.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 2179361
United States
01/05/2014 10:52 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
It's good to see sanity returning to hospitals.

Prayer has no effect. Prayer is a theological black hole and there's no empirical evidence to prove that it works.

Here's the good news Bible-Tards: Prayer has no effect! That means you can stop mumbling your platitudes and actually do something productive; for example, donating to cancer research or helping families with their medical bills.

Prayer is mental-masturbation from weak-willed people too lazy to do anything useful or meaningful with their lives.

sheeppopesheep
 Quoting: IntoTheLight


Thanks OBAMA for your input ...

I feel complete now!!!
christian
Suited up and Armored in Christ!

User ID: 44720951
United States
01/05/2014 10:59 PM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
It's good to see sanity returning to hospitals.

Prayer has no effect. Prayer is a theological black hole and there's no empirical evidence to prove that it works.

Here's the good news Bible-Tards: Prayer has no effect! That means you can stop mumbling your platitudes and actually do something productive; for example, donating to cancer research or helping families with their medical bills.

Prayer is mental-masturbation from weak-willed people too lazy to do anything useful or meaningful with their lives.

sheeppopesheep
 Quoting: IntoTheLight


A GIFT FROM GOD’: WOMAN AND HER DOCTOR SAY PRAYER MIRACULOUSLY HEALED HER MALIGNANT CANCEROUS TUMOR


Therese Daoud recounted her experience to Israel’s Channel 2 on Friday night after she was diagnosed with a malignant tumor in her leg. After the surgery to amputate her limb was canceled three times for bureaucratic reasons, the devout Christian woman believed it was a sign that she should forego medical intervention and instead pray.

Miraculously when she arrived at her next screening five months after her initial diagnosis, doctors discovered her tumor had completely disappeared..

[link to www.theblaze.com]


Annapolis woman healed of cancer through intercession of Bl. Seelos..


[link to www.catholicnewsagency.com]


DOCTOR ADMITS GOD HEALED WOMAN OF BRAIN CANCER
Mark Ellis : Aug 16, 2013


"The Holy Spirit moved in like the fourth man in the fire. He was in the room and I felt His arms around me and this peace flooded me from my head to my toes. It swam all over me." –Bobie Barsky


[link to www.breakingchristiannews.com]


YOU WITH SUCH LITTLE FAITH....
Susie

For where your treasure is, there your heart will be also.....Matthew 6:21
There is a time for everything, and a season for every activity under the heavens: Ecclesiastes 3:1
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 41479959
United States
01/05/2014 11:55 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
They are still calling her a body. Probably afraid of getting sued:

@nbcbayarea: #BREAKING: Children's Hospital Oakland says body of #JahiMcMath released to coroner who released it to her mother.”
IntoTheLight

User ID: 46074761
United States
01/06/2014 02:21 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: California Hospital Dictates Limits to Hope and Prayer
It's good to see sanity returning to hospitals.

Prayer has no effect. Prayer is a theological black hole and there's no empirical evidence to prove that it works.
Here's the good news Bible-Tards: Prayer has no effect! That means you can stop mumbling your platitudes and actually do something productive; for example, donating to cancer research or helping families with their medical bills.
Prayer is mental-masturbation from weak-willed people too lazy to do anything useful or meaningful with their lives.
sheeppopesheep
 Quoting: IntoTheLight


A GIFT FROM GOD’: WOMAN AND HER DOCTOR SAY PRAYER MIRACULOUSLY HEALED HER MALIGNANT CANCEROUS TUMOR

Therese Daoud recounted her experience to Israel’s Channel 2 on Friday night after she was diagnosed with a malignant tumor in her leg. After the surgery to amputate her limb was canceled three times for bureaucratic reasons, the devout Christian woman believed it was a sign that she should forego medical intervention and instead pray.
Miraculously when she arrived at her next screening five months after her initial diagnosis, doctors discovered her tumor had completely disappeared..
[link to www.theblaze.com]


Annapolis woman healed of cancer through intercession of Bl. Seelos..


[link to www.catholicnewsagency.com]


DOCTOR ADMITS GOD HEALED WOMAN OF BRAIN CANCER
Mark Ellis : Aug 16, 2013


"The Holy Spirit moved in like the fourth man in the fire. He was in the room and I felt His arms around me and this peace flooded me from my head to my toes. It swam all over me." –Bobie Barsky


[link to www.breakingchristiannews.com]


YOU WITH SUCH LITTLE FAITH....
 Quoting: christian



DOCTOR ADMITS GOD HEALED WOMAN OF BRAIN CANCER
Mark Ellis : Aug 16, 2013

Rabbli 'DR' Barsky is NOT a Medical Doctor. This headline is both disingenuous and misleading, it also comes from a biased 'Christian' website.

You must try harder to find some proof; but I suppose your desire to find proof,any proof, no matter how false,overrides your desire for the real truth.

It's a shame you have to use biased and misleading articles to try and 'prop-up' your dying religion.

I wonder what Jebus would think, as yet again, the Bible-Tards lies are exposed?

cruise

Last Edited by IntoTheLight on 01/06/2014 02:24 PM
6 months UK then 6 months USA.

I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.





GLP