amateur historian User ID: 127416 United States 08/11/2006 12:39 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | The Talmud reads like grafitti by 14 year-olds. The Bar-Mitzvah ceremony is a rite of passage in the Jewish religion, where a boy becomes a man in the community at the age of 13, the age of Bar-Mitzvah.
Much of the scandalous passages in the Babylonian Talmud (and probably some of the other Talmuds) read like they were written by juveniles, with the insider jokes, scatalogical (fixation on shit), all kinds of perversions, and plain old tall tales. This is the way Junior-high and middle school kids write. Then they grow up and usually grow out of it.
There was a lot of peer-bonding in the schools that wrote the Talmuds, and the pupils there, being legal adults at 13, must have had a heap of fun putting the junk they wrote into the Talmud, and seeing their works in print. Then, there was the rivalry factor, and some of them probably blackmailed other classmates into leaving it in the book.
Rather than a conspiracy back in the 100s BC, I think it was a lack of adult supervision. |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 125023 United States 08/11/2006 01:07 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: The Talmud reads like grafitti by 14 year-olds. i don't doubt it gilgamesh i got the same feeling they were harsh on the woman
the sumerian stuff recounts someone coming in the lettuce to force another to eat his semen... hilarious |
yanni User ID: 129584 United States 08/11/2006 01:34 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: The Talmud reads like grafitti by 14 year-olds. OP is more amatuer than he realizes. everything he says about the talmud is incorrect. here read it for yourself: [ link to www.sacred-texts.com] |