You obviously came off as too nice and effeminate. Many guys struggle with being themselves around women (acting like a man) because of radical feminism and it's war on "toxic" masculinity. For this reason, many guys fear that women will see them as brutish beasts if they express their masculinity, so, they start acting overly nicey nice, make no advances, etc, which makes them come off as weak or gay. Naturally, this is an attraction killer, and she will just move on to another guy from her endless Tinder list.

Get your fundamentals in the can or prepare to fail.