Godlike Productions - Discussion Forum
Users Online Now: 934 (Who's On?)Visitors Today: 296,066
Pageviews Today: 449,828Threads Today: 173Posts Today: 2,299
05:12 AM


Rate this Thread

Absolute BS Crap Reasonable Nice Amazing
 

Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max

 
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 76686199
United States
09/13/2019 08:38 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
This guy practically lives at the airport.

He told me about all the safety procedures. Theres a log book. Like a plane diary for each and every aircraft. All the repairs and previous repairs and mechanic notes and speculations go in this diary.

Every aircraft mechanic has someone watching them as they make repairs to certify that all procedures and protocols were followed by the mechanic. Once repairs are done they test EVERYTHING. Then the plane gets an ok to fly.

Then the pilots come in. THEY test everything. He said "they dont take the mechanics word for it". If one little thing, doesnt matter what it is, if the system reports a malfunction of any kind, the plane cant leave. People are kicked off the plane or switched to a different gate with another aircraft on its way.

He said his airport had the 737 Max that is currently grounded. He tested the MCAS which caused the crashes. He showed me a picture from inside the cockpit with the pilot's screen reporting a STALL. He didnt say if this test was either before or after the last crash.. so i dont know if all the machanics saw this planes demise coming.

But... heres the kicker! He said the MCAS was made a standard feature by boeing in all the 737max. But only slightly better models with a little more bells and whistles for a higher price was equipped with a back up software that would kick in and take over if the MCAS failed or malfunctioned in anyway. He said kind of like a Honda LX vs Honda EX. LX is standard. But EX has the sunroof and extra electronics (as an example).

He said Boeing fucked up by being cheap with the engine mounting instead redesigning the craft's wings and height.

He says he knows the MCAS update was approved and fixed but from his mechanical perspective the problem is still there. The design flaw with the engines. He believes the 737 MAX will not go back into service until they rebuild and mount the engines safely on the wings of all the 737max. He said this whole mess was very far from over.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 75467007
United States
09/13/2019 08:53 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 72985280
United States
09/13/2019 09:06 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
is this coming from the CEO Dennis A. Muilenburg who took over in 2015? Faster, Better, Cheaper, he picked the wrong two?
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 77201407
United States
09/13/2019 10:16 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
I vote for increasing the length of the landing gear struts by 36 inches.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 77201407
United States
09/13/2019 10:17 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
I vote for increasing the length of the landing gear struts by 36 inches.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 77201407


And lower the engines by that much.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 74993099
United Kingdom
09/14/2019 04:23 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max

 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 75467007


you beat me too it...

everyone should watch this video - a software fix will not fix the planes hardware / physical body which has massive design flaws.

The real reason Boeing's new plane crashed twice

[link to www.youtube.com (secure)]

first reported here in the below glp thread...

Thread: Boeing 737 Max 8 Design Flaw. Warning: This Will Piss You Off.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 74993099
United Kingdom
09/14/2019 04:24 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
This guy practically lives at the airport.

He told me about all the safety procedures. Theres a log book. Like a plane diary for each and every aircraft. All the repairs and previous repairs and mechanic notes and speculations go in this diary.

Every aircraft mechanic has someone watching them as they make repairs to certify that all procedures and protocols were followed by the mechanic. Once repairs are done they test EVERYTHING. Then the plane gets an ok to fly.

Then the pilots come in. THEY test everything. He said "they dont take the mechanics word for it". If one little thing, doesnt matter what it is, if the system reports a malfunction of any kind, the plane cant leave. People are kicked off the plane or switched to a different gate with another aircraft on its way.

He said his airport had the 737 Max that is currently grounded. He tested the MCAS which caused the crashes. He showed me a picture from inside the cockpit with the pilot's screen reporting a STALL. He didnt say if this test was either before or after the last crash.. so i dont know if all the machanics saw this planes demise coming.

But... heres the kicker! He said the MCAS was made a standard feature by boeing in all the 737max. But only slightly better models with a little more bells and whistles for a higher price was equipped with a back up software that would kick in and take over if the MCAS failed or malfunctioned in anyway. He said kind of like a Honda LX vs Honda EX. LX is standard. But EX has the sunroof and extra electronics (as an example).

He said Boeing fucked up by being cheap with the engine mounting instead redesigning the craft's wings and height.

He says he knows the MCAS update was approved and fixed but from his mechanical perspective the problem is still there. The design flaw with the engines. He believes the 737 MAX will not go back into service until they rebuild and mount the engines safely on the wings of all the 737max. He said this whole mess was very far from over.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 76686199


this.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 16152409
United States
09/14/2019 04:26 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
Keep your flying sex dungeons in your own dimension or I will redesign them.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 74019301
United States
09/14/2019 04:46 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
When the fuel runs out,the planes quit flying.from an investers point of view,fuel cost will be too high in twenty years.
I would rather milk out my old planes than a major payment.

if boeing doesnt run its plane through ai software,its crazy.ai could lay out the perfect design overall.I suspect a manufacturing drop off soon and any new sales are a blessing.
Are they ready to run straight soybean oil or ethanol?
Better get the bugs worked out now rather than being in denial about crude oil industry future death.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 78002311
United States
09/14/2019 10:57 PM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
When the fuel runs out,the planes quit flying.from an investers point of view,fuel cost will be too high in twenty years.
I would rather milk out my old planes than a major payment.

if boeing doesnt run its plane through ai software,its crazy.ai could lay out the perfect design overall.I suspect a manufacturing drop off soon and any new sales are a blessing.
Are they ready to run straight soybean oil or ethanol?
Better get the bugs worked out now rather than being in denial about crude oil industry future death.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 74019301


Better get fracking!
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 77993861
Australia
09/17/2019 03:33 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
I vote for increasing the length of the landing gear struts by 36 inches.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 77201407


And lower the engines by that much.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 77201407


my uncle told me that you cant do that. the leg length is one of the main "things". if you increase it you basically have to do a redisign of the wings and fuselage ect ect ect.

which is what they should do, a proper redesign with longer legs and engines mounted normally. and the full proper paperwork checks. and full training for the new model plane.

but it seems like they won't do that.

abomb
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 36223405
Australia
09/17/2019 03:43 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
I vote for increasing the length of the landing gear struts by 36 inches.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 77201407


then they wont fit in the wheelwells so redesign the wing .
then the centre fuel tank is in the way so new fuel system is required .
boeing should have built a mini 757 .
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 77993861
Australia
09/17/2019 03:55 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
boeing should have built a mini 757 .
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 36223405


you dont understand. they build a giant "737" because then they didnt need to do a bunch of paperwork and new training. that means they shaved monkeys. with yore plan they would have to do a whole bunch of new certification and training for the new model. which means the monkeys dont get shaved! nobody likes hairy monkeys! now do you get it?
Pilgrim001

User ID: 77021014
United States
09/17/2019 03:58 AM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
I vote for increasing the length of the landing gear struts by 36 inches.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 77201407


They said they didn't have room underbody to do that because of the way they designed it 40 years ago. Can't be changed??
I don't have the time or the crayons to explain this to you.



Slake Blake
Pilgrim001

User ID: 77021014
United States
09/17/2019 04:02 AM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
I vote for increasing the length of the landing gear struts by 36 inches.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 77201407


They said they didn't have room underbody to do that because of the way they designed it 40 years ago. Can't be changed??
 Quoting: Pilgrim001


Maybe they can get some Mexican lowriders from Southern california to show them how to raise and lower the 737 with hydraulics.
I don't have the time or the crayons to explain this to you.



Slake Blake
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 74976764
United States
09/17/2019 04:10 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
boeing should have built a mini 757 .
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 36223405


you dont understand. they build a giant "737" because then they didnt need to do a bunch of paperwork and new training. that means they shaved monkeys. with yore plan they would have to do a whole bunch of new certification and training for the new model. which means the monkeys dont get shaved! nobody likes hairy monkeys! now do you get it?
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 77993861


Also, Southwest only buys and flies 737s.

Boeing killed the fabulous 757 because other airlines would have bought it instead of the 737.
The ring of truth

User ID: 77951552
Netherlands
09/17/2019 04:24 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
This is a damn shame,almost sounds like sabotage to me...

How do you so badly screw up with all super computers doing the math and designs for you....

I think someone is behind this....No Way,this was done ,without knowing what it was going to do....

Trying to bring boeing to its knees ...i would be looking at the ones that designed this plane very closely
TRUMP MAGA KAG 2020~AND BEYOND!

Plus KILL THE UN,put a stake through its BLACK HEART OF DEATH!

Then after that,GET RID OF THE IRS,CIA,FBI,NSA,AND SO ON...

ALL WE NEED IS SHERIFFS!
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 77993861
Australia
09/17/2019 04:29 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
This is a damn shame,almost sounds like sabotage to me...

How do you so badly screw up with all super computers doing the math and designs for you....

I think someone is behind this....No Way,this was done ,without knowing what it was going to do....

Trying to bring boeing to its knees ...i would be looking at the ones that designed this plane very closely
 Quoting: The ring of truth


the plane design really isnt that bad. they could make it fly properly if they had good software and sensors. instead they put crap sensors which gave crap readings. then the crap software decided to crash the plane because of crap sensor readings. that is completely unacceptable. that software is terribly wrong.

the reason why the design is a bit crap is so they can pretend its a 737. for paperwork and monkey reasons. if they werent doing that it would be a new model and it would be a lot better.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 77331063
United States
09/17/2019 04:32 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
They wanted new engines but the same flight characteristics of the old. So they used software to accomplish this. The software had a bug, that software bug killed those people.

In the rush to have automated systems like self driving cars, I suspect more people are going to be killed by software.

Think about how unreliable software is. Nearly everyone has experienced computer crashes, do you really want to rely on a microsoft program to keep you physically safe?
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 77993861
Australia
09/17/2019 04:36 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
They wanted new engines but the same flight characteristics of the old. So they used software to accomplish this. The software had a bug, that software bug killed those people.

In the rush to have automated systems like self driving cars, I suspect more people are going to be killed by software.

Think about how unreliable software is. Nearly everyone has experienced computer crashes, do you really want to rely on a microsoft program to keep you physically safe?
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 77331063


its worse than that. already they are collecting as much data as they can about people. if the data gets out people can get hurt.

how much can you trust the computers that store all the data? you can't!

famous computer guy said:

The moral is obvious. You can't trust code that you did not totally create yourself. (Especially code from companies that employ people like me.) No amount of source-level verification or scrutiny will protect you from using untrusted code. In demonstrating the possibility of this kind of attack, I picked on the C compiler. I could have picked on any program-handling program such as an assembler, a loader, or even hardware microcode. As the level of program gets lower, these bugs will be harder and harder to detect. A well installed microcode bug will be almost impossible to detect.

[link to www.win.tue.nl (secure)]


find out his name and which company employs him...

ahhh
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 41002181
United States
09/17/2019 04:37 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
is this coming from the CEO Dennis A. Muilenburg who took over in 2015? Faster, Better, Cheaper, he picked the wrong two?
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 72985280


Jewish CEO's tend to destroy American companies. Like with FORD.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 1897079
United States
09/17/2019 04:43 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
On news radio this past weekend, I heard a (propaganda)"report" that ALL the Boeing 737 Max planes have been "fixed" and are going back into service shortly. Are they SURE? I don't fly anymore so it doesn't affect me (I've flown on almost every jet imaginable since 1964). I worry for those who have to get on this flawed jet craft and crash into smithereens because nothing was actually done about the flaws in the design, the engines, etc.

I've had one, two and three degrees of separation of MANY plane disasters in the last 20 years, INCLUDING 9/11, TWA 8000, & the famous Dallas DC-10 crash in 1978. I choose to not fly anymore.

On 9/11, after getting out of the gridlocked city, I made my way to a friend's house and we watched the unfolding of events in NYC, live, as they happened. Within 2 hours and before noon time, the phone rang, it was "D," another friend who was stressed out and reporting that his niece, his sister's daughter's 3rd grade school teacher's husband was on flight 175 heading to L.A. from Boston and was killed during the crash of World Trade Center Tower II.
MissCleo

User ID: 77082640
United States
09/17/2019 04:48 AM

Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
On news radio this past weekend, I heard a (propaganda)"report" that ALL the Boeing 737 Max planes have been "fixed" and are going back into service shortly. Are they SURE? I don't fly anymore so it doesn't affect me (I've flown on almost every jet imaginable since 1964). I worry for those who have to get on this flawed jet craft and crash into smithereens because nothing was actually done about the flaws in the design, the engines, etc.

I've had one, two and three degrees of separation of MANY plane disasters in the last 20 years, INCLUDING 9/11, TWA 8000, & the famous Dallas DC-10 crash in 1978. I choose to not fly anymore.

On 9/11, after getting out of the gridlocked city, I made my way to a friend's house and we watched the unfolding of events in NYC, live, as they happened. Within 2 hours and before noon time, the phone rang, it was "D," another friend who was stressed out and reporting that his niece, his sister's daughter's 3rd grade school teacher's husband was on flight 175 heading to L.A. from Boston and was killed during the crash of World Trade Center Tower II.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1897079


I choose not to fly anymore, too.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 77993861
Australia
09/17/2019 05:11 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
On news radio this past weekend, I heard a (propaganda)"report" that ALL the Boeing 737 Max planes have been "fixed" and are going back into service shortly. Are they SURE? I don't fly anymore so it doesn't affect me (I've flown on almost every jet imaginable since 1964). I worry for those who have to get on this flawed jet craft and crash into smithereens because nothing was actually done about the flaws in the design, the engines, etc.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1897079


probly only one more will crash. then the rest will all immediately land and never fly again
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 77987112
Kosovo
09/17/2019 05:16 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
This is a damn shame,almost sounds like sabotage to me...

How do you so badly screw up with all super computers doing the math and designs for you....

I think someone is behind this....No Way,this was done ,without knowing what it was going to do....

Trying to bring boeing to its knees ...i would be looking at the ones that designed this plane very closely
 Quoting: The ring of truth


I have to agree. The engineers couldn't have been that shortsighted.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 78009923
09/17/2019 05:19 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
I choose not to fly anymore, too.
 Quoting: MissCleo


Great, we need more isolationists just like you!
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 76809044
United States
09/17/2019 05:57 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
This guy practically lives at the airport.

He told me about all the safety procedures. Theres a log book. Like a plane diary for each and every aircraft. All the repairs and previous repairs and mechanic notes and speculations go in this diary.

Every aircraft mechanic has someone watching them as they make repairs to certify that all procedures and protocols were followed by the mechanic. Once repairs are done they test EVERYTHING. Then the plane gets an ok to fly.

Then the pilots come in. THEY test everything. He said "they dont take the mechanics word for it". If one little thing, doesnt matter what it is, if the system reports a malfunction of any kind, the plane cant leave. People are kicked off the plane or switched to a different gate with another aircraft on its way.

He said his airport had the 737 Max that is currently grounded. He tested the MCAS which caused the crashes. He showed me a picture from inside the cockpit with the pilot's screen reporting a STALL. He didnt say if this test was either before or after the last crash.. so i dont know if all the machanics saw this planes demise coming.

But... heres the kicker! He said the MCAS was made a standard feature by boeing in all the 737max. But only slightly better models with a little more bells and whistles for a higher price was equipped with a back up software that would kick in and take over if the MCAS failed or malfunctioned in anyway. He said kind of like a Honda LX vs Honda EX. LX is standard. But EX has the sunroof and extra electronics (as an example).

He said Boeing fucked up by being cheap with the engine mounting instead redesigning the craft's wings and height.

He says he knows the MCAS update was approved and fixed but from his mechanical perspective the problem is still there. The design flaw with the engines. He believes the 737 MAX will not go back into service until they rebuild and mount the engines safely on the wings of all the 737max. He said this whole mess was very far from over.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 76686199


so, all along, the engines have been in danger of falling off.

Holy Shit.

bert-facepalm
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 77898480
United States
09/17/2019 06:01 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
This is a damn shame,almost sounds like sabotage to me...

How do you so badly screw up with all super computers doing the math and designs for you....

I think someone is behind this....No Way,this was done ,without knowing what it was going to do....

Trying to bring boeing to its knees ...i would be looking at the ones that designed this plane very closely
 Quoting: The ring of truth


I have to agree. The engineers couldn't have been that shortsighted.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 77987112


Hire dumb foreign engineers, but hey, they work cheap.
Redcat1
Redcat

User ID: 77579655
United States
09/17/2019 06:02 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
According to a pilot that flies (or rather flew) the MAX - he would fly it today and and would fly with the 'flaws'. With everyone of his family on-board. So long as the crew was comprised of US-qualified pilots.

The crashes were due to pilot error by 3rd world, undertrained and almost untrained pilots.

Had they followed procedure the crashes would not have happened.

If the MCAS fails - you simply turn it off. AMD LEAVE IT OFF. One crew with a co-pilot with less than 200 hours kept turning it back on!

The airline industry had enough issues without grounding these aircraft.
Redcat1
Redcat

User ID: 77579655
United States
09/17/2019 06:07 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
boeing should have built a mini 757 .
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 36223405


you dont understand. they build a giant "737" because then they didnt need to do a bunch of paperwork and new training. that means they shaved monkeys. with yore plan they would have to do a whole bunch of new certification and training for the new model. which means the monkeys dont get shaved! nobody likes hairy monkeys! now do you get it?
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 77993861



This is true. The real cost to the airlines (the customers of the 737Max) was the retraining and requalification of pilots had they procured 757s instead of 737s.

Of course these same airlines - at least the 3rd world airlines - also bought/lease the planes without the redundancy features of the MCAS.
Anonymous Coward
User ID: 78010612
Canada
09/17/2019 06:08 AM
Report Abusive Post
Report Copyright Violation
Re: Spoke With An Aircraft Mechanic About Boeing 737 Max
On news radio this past weekend, I heard a (propaganda)"report" that ALL the Boeing 737 Max planes have been "fixed" and are going back into service shortly. Are they SURE? I don't fly anymore so it doesn't affect me (I've flown on almost every jet imaginable since 1964). I worry for those who have to get on this flawed jet craft and crash into smithereens because nothing was actually done about the flaws in the design, the engines, etc.

I've had one, two and three degrees of separation of MANY plane disasters in the last 20 years, INCLUDING 9/11, TWA 8000, & the famous Dallas DC-10 crash in 1978. I choose to not fly anymore.

On 9/11, after getting out of the gridlocked city, I made my way to a friend's house and we watched the unfolding of events in NYC, live, as they happened. Within 2 hours and before noon time, the phone rang, it was "D," another friend who was stressed out and reporting that his niece, his sister's daughter's 3rd grade school teacher's husband was on flight 175 heading to L.A. from Boston and was killed during the crash of World Trade Center Tower II.
 Quoting: Anonymous Coward 1897079


I choose not to fly anymore, too.
 Quoting: MissCleo


24/7

365 days a year.





GLP