I composed a new Imperial March score for a Star Wars' fan film. Is it good?

Anymore comments?

What instrument do you play?

I don't play any instrument. I only know how to compose using musescore. Nowadays, with the help of computer software you don't really need to learn how to play instrument. As long as you know how to use a score writing software, you can compose.

I swear this same garbage was posted here like 6 years ago. Fuck off op, go collect your 3.50, yeah its a hard world i know, but unless you find honest work youll keep suffering this karmic loop

Might need to take off those life rings

you're inability at musical instruments shows. this is crap. sorry, just being honest. it sounds like you tried to copy the original, and did a bad job at that.

this is dunning-kruger in full display--in other words, you think you are good at something but lack the knowledge to know that you're actually terrible.

look it up, and then start learning about musical theory, and learn how to play an instrument, and come back in 10 years and try again.

P U

Being completely honest, this sounds like something out of the videogame Banjo Kazooie. It's got it's own charm. That said, shooting for John Williams level with almost no understanding of music theory is quite ambitious. It falls very short. But I encourage you to keep composing. We all start from nothing, and I hear potential in this.

To me it sounds like something out of Warcraft 1 or 2.
But I agree to the above.

Now that's honest. Because I know Im good. And do realize all I have is computer simulated sound. I don't have money to hire a real orchestra. So my brass horns sound like keyboard sound. And also remember the Imperial March is John Williams' best work and the most notorious master piece in his life. Everywhere he goes people asked him to play the Imperial March. He played this in all of his birthday parties. If you ask me to reproduce another one of his scores, tell you the truth I don't even have the energy to do it. I just want to reproduce his Imperial March just to show you my potential.

the tones are slightly offensive.

Sounds like shit.

Stick to your 7/11 job.

I am a Star Wars lifer (well up until Disney versions)

This is a very good sound alike impression of the Imperial March imo.

Very good quality. Yes I can tell it's synths but this could easily be used as a legitimate soundtrack in a broadcast quality episode that tributes or is a parody of the franchise.

Good job.

Don't listen to the haters

Thank you.

Your curly tiny dog oke...never mind the rest at new gift view ?

Our died but oke thats life bet my parents where tyerd about em

Funny sheep dog different then biting elsewhere dogs near fy neighbour im smarter ? Fucking tree

No problem

I know more about Non Disney Star Wars than anybody else in this thread.

Anybody gonna say anything now?

What are you saying? Can't understand you.

Not bad.

sounds to similar
if you had not ever heard the real one yours would not sound like this because its similar

That's right. Without John Williams there is no copy cat like this.

Oh beer and just type something...

Not good.

I find your lack of musicality disturbing.

Impressive comment. Most impressive.

Sounds good to me. Seems like the original. AI Created?

When you order the Imperial March from Wish.