Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? | |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 48897578 United States 08/15/2016 08:40 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? Verse? Good enough? How good? Says who? Verse? How good do you have to be to get to heaven? How bad can you be to get to heaven? Verse? you would want to help the ones you love to avoid hell. Saints, while they are alive and after they die, have this wish for all of humanity. That is what they want most, -even more than enjoying Heaven. Quoting: TGus 14496115 Because this is their greatest wish, God allows them to help humanity in the most important things. Like a Father, God lets His children learn how do do the things their Father could do for humanity, just as fathers and their children do here on Earth. Quoting: TGus 14496115 Please tell all of us why you think dead people can hear prayers and have powers to do stuff for you? Verse? Wouldn't you like to be helped by someone you've known and trusted, someone human who is special to you? Asking help from your deceased mother is not worshiping her. Quoting: TGus 14496115 After death, God allow us to help those we care about, because not being able to help would be the same as being in Hell. Quoting: TGus 14496115 VERSE? |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 48897578 United States 08/15/2016 08:42 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 72796700 Ireland 08/15/2016 08:42 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 48897578 United States 08/15/2016 08:43 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 72422075 United States 08/15/2016 08:43 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 72796700 Ireland 08/15/2016 08:45 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 72796700 Ireland 08/15/2016 08:45 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? |
Judethz User ID: 69883546 United Kingdom 08/15/2016 08:49 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? Verse? Good enough? How good? Says who? Verse? How good do you have to be to get to heaven? How bad can you be to get to heaven? Verse? you would want to help the ones you love to avoid hell. Saints, while they are alive and after they die, have this wish for all of humanity. That is what they want most, -even more than enjoying Heaven. Quoting: TGus 14496115 Because this is their greatest wish, God allows them to help humanity in the most important things. Like a Father, God lets His children learn how do do the things their Father could do for humanity, just as fathers and their children do here on Earth. Quoting: TGus 14496115 Please tell all of us why you think dead people can hear prayers and have powers to do stuff for you? Verse? Wouldn't you like to be helped by someone you've known and trusted, someone human who is special to you? Asking help from your deceased mother is not worshiping her. Quoting: TGus 14496115 After death, God allow us to help those we care about, because not being able to help would be the same as being in Hell. Quoting: TGus 14496115 VERSE? Oh dear, are you trying to confuse the OP with truth? |
TGus User ID: 14496115 United States 08/15/2016 08:58 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? Why do Catholics pray to Mary? What other people do Catholics pray to? Why do Catholics pray to other men? If you died and went to heaven, (or purgatory), what would be your dearest wish? If you were good enough to get there, you would want to help the ones you love to avoid hell. Saints, while they are alive and after they die, have this wish for all of humanity. That is what they want most, -even more than enjoying Heaven. Because this is their greatest wish, God allows them to help humanity in the most important things. Like a Father, God lets His children learn how do do the things their Father could do for humanity, just as fathers and their children do here on Earth. This is why Catholics pray to saints and family members. Wouldn't you like to be helped by someone you've known and trusted, someone human who is special to you? Asking help from your deceased mother is not worshiping her. After death, God allow us to help those we care about, because not being able to help would be the same as being in Hell. What are "Saints"? Do you know? The saints are those who have a true love for all of humanity. |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 70997125 United States 08/15/2016 09:31 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? Why do Catholics pray to Mary? What other people do Catholics pray to? Why do Catholics pray to other men? If you died and went to heaven, (or purgatory), what would be your dearest wish? If you were good enough to get there, you would want to help the ones you love to avoid hell. Saints, while they are alive and after they die, have this wish for all of humanity. That is what they want most, -even more than enjoying Heaven. Because this is their greatest wish, God allows them to help humanity in the most important things. Like a Father, God lets His children learn how do do the things their Father could do for humanity, just as fathers and their children do here on Earth. This is why Catholics pray to saints and family members. Wouldn't you like to be helped by someone you've known and trusted, someone human who is special to you? Asking help from your deceased mother is not worshiping her. After death, God allow us to help those we care about, because not being able to help would be the same as being in Hell. What are "Saints"? Do you know? The concept really isn't hard to understand. People pray for those they love to get to Heaven. We ask the saints, living members of the body of Christ who are in sinless perfection and closest to God, to pray for us. Anyone in Heaven is a saint. We don't worship them or deify them. |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 70997125 United States 08/15/2016 09:32 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? Why do Catholics pray to Mary? What other people do Catholics pray to? Why do Catholics pray to other men? If you died and went to heaven, (or purgatory), what would be your dearest wish? If you were good enough to get there, you would want to help the ones you love to avoid hell. Saints, while they are alive and after they die, have this wish for all of humanity. That is what they want most, -even more than enjoying Heaven. Because this is their greatest wish, God allows them to help humanity in the most important things. Like a Father, God lets His children learn how do do the things their Father could do for humanity, just as fathers and their children do here on Earth. This is why Catholics pray to saints and family members. Wouldn't you like to be helped by someone you've known and trusted, someone human who is special to you? Asking help from your deceased mother is not worshiping her. After death, God allow us to help those we care about, because not being able to help would be the same as being in Hell. What are "Saints"? Do you know? The concept really isn't hard to understand. People pray for those they love to get to Heaven. We ask the saints, living members of the body of Christ who are in sinless perfection and closest to God, to pray for us. Anyone in Heaven is a saint. We don't worship them or deify them. |
TGus User ID: 14496115 United States 08/15/2016 09:35 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? Quoting: Anonymous Coward 72796700 What makes you think he should ever answer any challenges? Because his argument has been challenged. And it's up to him to defend it. I'm back. Give me some time to read the responses. |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 70997125 United States 08/15/2016 09:35 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? ... Quoting: Anonymous Coward 37428371 Saying that Jesus is not God doesn't go against Scripture?!?! You have just shown how drastically unqualified you are to discuss this subject. Emmanuel, the name for Jesus announced to the shepherds by the Angels, means "God with us." Thomas called Jesus "My Lord and my God." Jesus said "The Father and I are one." The first verse of John is "In the beginning was the Word. And the Word was with God. And the Word was God." Paul said "Jesus Christ is Lord." I could go on for a very long time. O yeah, Jesus also said "Before God was, I Am." I Am, or Yahweh, was the name God identified himself as to Moses in the burning bush. When Jesus said this, He and his apostles had to flee the town because they were going to be stoned. Excuse me, the correct quote is "Before Abraham was, I Am." Which is not the Name. [link to m.youtube.com (secure)] You won't stop will you? You know everything man. |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 70997125 United States 08/15/2016 09:43 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? ... Quoting: Anonymous Coward 37428371 O yeah, Jesus also said "Before God was, I Am." I Am, or Yahweh, was the name God identified himself as to Moses in the burning bush. When Jesus said this, He and his apostles had to flee the town because they were going to be stoned. Excuse me, the correct quote is "Before Abraham was, I Am." Which is not the Name. [link to m.youtube.com (secure)] You won't stop will you? You know everything man. I mean I could post a link to a video about how Obama is from Jupiter but that doesn't make it true. |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 14496115 United States 08/15/2016 09:46 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? Verse? Good enough? How good? Says who? Verse? How good do you have to be to get to heaven? How bad can you be to get to heaven? Verse? you would want to help the ones you love to avoid hell. Saints, while they are alive and after they die, have this wish for all of humanity. That is what they want most, -even more than enjoying Heaven. Quoting: TGus 14496115 Because this is their greatest wish, God allows them to help humanity in the most important things. Like a Father, God lets His children learn how do do the things their Father could do for humanity, just as fathers and their children do here on Earth. Quoting: TGus 14496115 Please tell all of us why you think dead people can hear prayers and have powers to do stuff for you? Verse? Wouldn't you like to be helped by someone you've known and trusted, someone human who is special to you? Asking help from your deceased mother is not worshiping her. Quoting: TGus 14496115 After death, God allow us to help those we care about, because not being able to help would be the same as being in Hell. Quoting: TGus 14496115 VERSE? If you are a believer, do you not get it? God loves us beyond our capacity to comprehend. If it is something a loving parent would grant their beloved child on Earth, don't you see that God would do a thousand times more. Do you actually love someone enough to go to Hell in their place? Do you understand what it is like to be a loving parent who will give anything for their child, -even their salvation? What is Heaven without Love, -all our love? If you are not a believer in God and an afterlife, or don't understand love yet, I really can't argue with you. |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 48897578 United States 08/15/2016 10:07 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 48897578 United States 08/15/2016 10:08 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? Verse? Good enough? How good? Says who? Verse? How good do you have to be to get to heaven? How bad can you be to get to heaven? Verse? you would want to help the ones you love to avoid hell. Saints, while they are alive and after they die, have this wish for all of humanity. That is what they want most, -even more than enjoying Heaven. Quoting: TGus 14496115 Because this is their greatest wish, God allows them to help humanity in the most important things. Like a Father, God lets His children learn how do do the things their Father could do for humanity, just as fathers and their children do here on Earth. Quoting: TGus 14496115 Please tell all of us why you think dead people can hear prayers and have powers to do stuff for you? Verse? Wouldn't you like to be helped by someone you've known and trusted, someone human who is special to you? Asking help from your deceased mother is not worshiping her. Quoting: TGus 14496115 After death, God allow us to help those we care about, because not being able to help would be the same as being in Hell. Quoting: TGus 14496115 VERSE? If you are a believer, do you not get it? God loves us beyond our capacity to comprehend. If it is something a loving parent would grant their beloved child on Earth, don't you see that God would do a thousand times more. Do you actually love someone enough to go to Hell in their place? Do you understand what it is like to be a loving parent who will give anything for their child, -even their salvation? What is Heaven without Love, -all our love? If you are not a believer in God and an afterlife, or don't understand love yet, I really can't argue with you. Verse? |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 48897578 United States 08/15/2016 10:09 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 48897578 United States 08/15/2016 10:11 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
TGus User ID: 14496115 United States 08/15/2016 10:16 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? Verse? Good enough? How good? Says who? Verse? How good do you have to be to get to heaven? How bad can you be to get to heaven? Verse? you would want to help the ones you love to avoid hell. Saints, while they are alive and after they die, have this wish for all of humanity. That is what they want most, -even more than enjoying Heaven. Quoting: TGus 14496115 Because this is their greatest wish, God allows them to help humanity in the most important things. Like a Father, God lets His children learn how do do the things their Father could do for humanity, just as fathers and their children do here on Earth. Quoting: TGus 14496115 Please tell all of us why you think dead people can hear prayers and have powers to do stuff for you? Verse? Wouldn't you like to be helped by someone you've known and trusted, someone human who is special to you? Asking help from your deceased mother is not worshiping her. Quoting: TGus 14496115 After death, God allow us to help those we care about, because not being able to help would be the same as being in Hell. Quoting: TGus 14496115 VERSE? If you are a believer, do you not get it? God loves us beyond our capacity to comprehend. If it is something a loving parent would grant their beloved child on Earth, don't you see that God would do a thousand times more. Do you actually love someone enough to go to Hell in their place? Do you understand what it is like to be a loving parent who will give anything for their child, -even their salvation? What is Heaven without Love, -all our love? If you are not a believer in God and an afterlife, or don't understand love yet, I really can't argue with you. Verse? I'll give you a verse: 1 Corinthians 13:1. Try that on for a few years, then get back to me. |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 72797261 United States 08/15/2016 10:22 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 70997125 United States 08/16/2016 10:18 AM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? I mean I could post a link to a video about how Obama is from Jupiter but that doesn't make it true. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 70997125 I call bullshit. That video might not exist, but my point is the OP sent me a link to a YouTube video in response to five scripture passages and a dozen quotes from early Christians proving his point wrong. |
Monotheism (OP) User ID: 72674588 Sweden 08/16/2016 10:23 AM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? I mean I could post a link to a video about how Obama is from Jupiter but that doesn't make it true. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 70997125 I call bullshit. That video might not exist, but my point is the OP sent me a link to a YouTube video in response to five scripture passages and a dozen quotes from early Christians proving his point wrong. And my point is that "ego eimi" does not align with God's name in Exodus 3:14, "EGO EIMI HO ON", with HO ON being the subject of emphasis. But chosing ignorance is more convenient I guess. |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 37428371 United States 08/16/2016 12:55 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? I mean I could post a link to a video about how Obama is from Jupiter but that doesn't make it true. Quoting: Anonymous Coward 70997125 I call bullshit. That video might not exist, but my point is the OP sent me a link to a YouTube video in response to five scripture passages and a dozen quotes from early Christians proving his point wrong. And my point is that "ego eimi" does not align with God's name in Exodus 3:14, "EGO EIMI HO ON", with HO ON being the subject of emphasis. But chosing ignorance is more convenient I guess. So why did Jesus say "Before Abraham was, I am?" What do you think he meant by that? Why did Jesus say "The Father and I are one?" Why does Jesus' name, Emmanuel, literally mean "God with us?" Why did John say "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" in the first sentence of his Gospel? Why did Thomas call Jesus "My Lord and my God" and why did Paul say " Jesus is Lord." These are just Bible verses. There are thousands of quotes from great Christians throughout the past 2,000 years about how Jesus is God. You ignore all this and argue that Jesus isn't God because Jesus might have used a different term than the God the Father did to identify himself once. Yet somehow I'm the ignorant one. |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 37428371 United States 08/16/2016 01:01 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? That video might not exist, but my point is the OP sent me a link to a YouTube video in response to five scripture passages and a dozen quotes from early Christians proving his point wrong. And my point is that "ego eimi" does not align with God's name in Exodus 3:14, "EGO EIMI HO ON", with HO ON being the subject of emphasis. But chosing ignorance is more convenient I guess. So why did Jesus say "Before Abraham was, I am?" What do you think he meant by that? Why did Jesus say "The Father and I are one?" Why does Jesus' name, Emmanuel, literally mean "God with us?" Why did John say "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" in the first sentence of his Gospel? Why did Thomas call Jesus "My Lord and my God" and why did Paul say " Jesus is Lord." These are just Bible verses. There are thousands of quotes from great Christians throughout the past 2,000 years about how Jesus is God. You ignore all this and argue that Jesus isn't God because Jesus might have used a different term than the God the Father did to identify himself once. Yet somehow I'm the ignorant one. Also, you're wrong, when Jesus said "I am" the Jews listening understood that he was claiming to be God. |
Monotheism (OP) User ID: 72674588 Sweden 08/16/2016 03:01 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? ... Quoting: Anonymous Coward 70997125 That video might not exist, but my point is the OP sent me a link to a YouTube video in response to five scripture passages and a dozen quotes from early Christians proving his point wrong. And my point is that "ego eimi" does not align with God's name in Exodus 3:14, "EGO EIMI HO ON", with HO ON being the subject of emphasis. But chosing ignorance is more convenient I guess. So why did Jesus say "Before Abraham was, I am?" What do you think he meant by that? Why did Jesus say "The Father and I are one?" Why does Jesus' name, Emmanuel, literally mean "God with us?" Why did John say "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" in the first sentence of his Gospel? Why did Thomas call Jesus "My Lord and my God" and why did Paul say " Jesus is Lord." These are just Bible verses. There are thousands of quotes from great Christians throughout the past 2,000 years about how Jesus is God. You ignore all this and argue that Jesus isn't God because Jesus might have used a different term than the God the Father did to identify himself once. Yet somehow I'm the ignorant one. Also, you're wrong, when Jesus said "I am" the Jews listening understood that he was claiming to be God. No, he used phrase ego eimi, and it's used all over the NT. Or maybe you think the healed blind man was claiming to be God too? Some said, “It is he.” Others said, “No, but he is like him.” He kept saying, “EGO EIMI” John 9:9 Who cares what you have to say about it anyway, when we have Jesus own words denying what you're trying to claim. Thread: Jesus denied being God 43 He said to them, “How is it then that David, in the Spirit, calls him Lord, saying, 44 “‘The Lord said to my Lord, “Sit at my right hand, Matthew 22:43-45 The psalm quoted here is Psalm 110:1. The first LORD, usually capitalized, is not a translation of the text, but God's name, the tetragrammaton, being substituted. A Psalm of David. YHWH says to my Lord: “Sit at my right hand, until I make your enemies your footstool.” Here we have YHWH, the Most High God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, adressing someone else, a second person referred to as lord, adoni. Or maybe Catholics prefers Peter's testimony? The God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob, the God of our fathers, glorified his servant Jesus, whom you delivered over and denied in the presence of Pilate, when he had decided to release him. Acts 3:13 Thread: Peter, the only man commended for recognizing Jesus as Messiah... |
Monotheism (OP) User ID: 72674588 Sweden 08/16/2016 03:12 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? That video might not exist, but my point is the OP sent me a link to a YouTube video in response to five scripture passages and a dozen quotes from early Christians proving his point wrong. And my point is that "ego eimi" does not align with God's name in Exodus 3:14, "EGO EIMI HO ON", with HO ON being the subject of emphasis. But chosing ignorance is more convenient I guess. So why did Jesus say "Before Abraham was, I am?" What do you think he meant by that? Why did Jesus say "The Father and I are one?" Why does Jesus' name, Emmanuel, literally mean "God with us?" Why did John say "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" in the first sentence of his Gospel? Why did Thomas call Jesus "My Lord and my God" and why did Paul say " Jesus is Lord." These are just Bible verses. There are thousands of quotes from great Christians throughout the past 2,000 years about how Jesus is God. You ignore all this and argue that Jesus isn't God because Jesus might have used a different term than the God the Father did to identify himself once. Yet somehow I'm the ignorant one. Immanuel is a name, a proper, personal name, and not some kind of description of attributes. It's theophoric, meaning it's a compound name containing the generic word for God, -el. Many, if not most, Hebrew names in the Bible are theophoric, containing either -el, orn God's name in contracted form, -iah; Ezekiel, Hezekiah, Joel, Jeremiah, Daniel, Samuel, etc. All those names has a theophoric meaning. That prophecy is about a human being. A human born in the days of Ahaz, during the Syro-Ephraimite War 8th century BC. This already fulfilled prophecy is then rehashed in Matthew. It's about a human being, not some kind of incarnate man-God. You literally only need to add one verse of context to see it's a prophecy about a human child. He shall eat curds and honey when he knows how to refuse the evil and choose the good. Isaiah 7:15. Literally. |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 37428371 United States 08/16/2016 03:29 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? ... Quoting: Anonymous Coward 70997125 That video might not exist, but my point is the OP sent me a link to a YouTube video in response to five scripture passages and a dozen quotes from early Christians proving his point wrong. And my point is that "ego eimi" does not align with God's name in Exodus 3:14, "EGO EIMI HO ON", with HO ON being the subject of emphasis. But chosing ignorance is more convenient I guess. So why did Jesus say "Before Abraham was, I am?" What do you think he meant by that? Why did Jesus say "The Father and I are one?" Why does Jesus' name, Emmanuel, literally mean "God with us?" Why did John say "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" in the first sentence of his Gospel? Why did Thomas call Jesus "My Lord and my God" and why did Paul say " Jesus is Lord." These are just Bible verses. There are thousands of quotes from great Christians throughout the past 2,000 years about how Jesus is God. You ignore all this and argue that Jesus isn't God because Jesus might have used a different term than the God the Father did to identify himself once. Yet somehow I'm the ignorant one. Immanuel is a name, a proper, personal name, and not some kind of description of attributes. It's theophoric, meaning it's a compound name containing the generic word for God, -el. Many, if not most, Hebrew names in the Bible are theophoric, containing either -el, orn God's name in contracted form, -iah; Ezekiel, Hezekiah, Joel, Jeremiah, Daniel, Samuel, etc. All those names has a theophoric meaning. That prophecy is about a human being. A human born in the days of Ahaz, during the Syro-Ephraimite War 8th century BC. This already fulfilled prophecy is then rehashed in Matthew. It's about a human being, not some kind of incarnate man-God. You literally only need to add one verse of context to see it's a prophecy about a human child. He shall eat curds and honey when he knows how to refuse the evil and choose the good. Isaiah 7:15. Literally. Yes, Christians believe that Jesus is God incarnate. Fully God and fully human. Your argument that most Hebrew names have "el" in them is ridiculous. The angel said "He will be called Emmanuel, which means God with us." The name absolutely bears significance regarding the attributes of Jesus, specifically that he is God. Again, these are the words of an angel of God recorded in the Bible. You did use the word theophoric though, so you must be right. |
Monotheism (OP) User ID: 72674588 Sweden 08/16/2016 03:47 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? ... Quoting: Monotheism And my point is that "ego eimi" does not align with God's name in Exodus 3:14, "EGO EIMI HO ON", with HO ON being the subject of emphasis. But chosing ignorance is more convenient I guess. So why did Jesus say "Before Abraham was, I am?" What do you think he meant by that? Why did Jesus say "The Father and I are one?" Why does Jesus' name, Emmanuel, literally mean "God with us?" Why did John say "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" in the first sentence of his Gospel? Why did Thomas call Jesus "My Lord and my God" and why did Paul say " Jesus is Lord." These are just Bible verses. There are thousands of quotes from great Christians throughout the past 2,000 years about how Jesus is God. You ignore all this and argue that Jesus isn't God because Jesus might have used a different term than the God the Father did to identify himself once. Yet somehow I'm the ignorant one. Immanuel is a name, a proper, personal name, and not some kind of description of attributes. It's theophoric, meaning it's a compound name containing the generic word for God, -el. Many, if not most, Hebrew names in the Bible are theophoric, containing either -el, orn God's name in contracted form, -iah; Ezekiel, Hezekiah, Joel, Jeremiah, Daniel, Samuel, etc. All those names has a theophoric meaning. That prophecy is about a human being. A human born in the days of Ahaz, during the Syro-Ephraimite War 8th century BC. This already fulfilled prophecy is then rehashed in Matthew. It's about a human being, not some kind of incarnate man-God. You literally only need to add one verse of context to see it's a prophecy about a human child. He shall eat curds and honey when he knows how to refuse the evil and choose the good. Isaiah 7:15. Literally. Yes, Christians believe that Jesus is God incarnate. Fully God and fully human. Your argument that most Hebrew names have "el" in them is ridiculous. The angel said "He will be called Emmanuel, which means God with us." The name absolutely bears significance regarding the attributes of Jesus, specifically that he is God. Again, these are the words of an angel of God recorded in the Bible. You did use the word theophoric though, so you must be right. Fully God and fully human is an ontological impossibility. The prophecy is not even about Jesus, it was rehashed by Matthew or whomever edited it. At most you can call it a dual prophecyu, but that's stretching. And it's not the angel speaking those words. And Immanuel is still a human child. |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 37428371 United States 08/16/2016 07:49 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Re: Mary, mother of God/theotokos? What are the Christian objections to Catholic and Orthodox Mariology? ... Quoting: Anonymous Coward 37428371 So why did Jesus say "Before Abraham was, I am?" What do you think he meant by that? Why did Jesus say "The Father and I are one?" Why does Jesus' name, Emmanuel, literally mean "God with us?" Why did John say "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" in the first sentence of his Gospel? Why did Thomas call Jesus "My Lord and my God" and why did Paul say " Jesus is Lord." These are just Bible verses. There are thousands of quotes from great Christians throughout the past 2,000 years about how Jesus is God. You ignore all this and argue that Jesus isn't God because Jesus might have used a different term than the God the Father did to identify himself once. Yet somehow I'm the ignorant one. Immanuel is a name, a proper, personal name, and not some kind of description of attributes. It's theophoric, meaning it's a compound name containing the generic word for God, -el. Many, if not most, Hebrew names in the Bible are theophoric, containing either -el, orn God's name in contracted form, -iah; Ezekiel, Hezekiah, Joel, Jeremiah, Daniel, Samuel, etc. All those names has a theophoric meaning. That prophecy is about a human being. A human born in the days of Ahaz, during the Syro-Ephraimite War 8th century BC. This already fulfilled prophecy is then rehashed in Matthew. It's about a human being, not some kind of incarnate man-God. You literally only need to add one verse of context to see it's a prophecy about a human child. He shall eat curds and honey when he knows how to refuse the evil and choose the good. Isaiah 7:15. Literally. Yes, Christians believe that Jesus is God incarnate. Fully God and fully human. Your argument that most Hebrew names have "el" in them is ridiculous. The angel said "He will be called Emmanuel, which means God with us." The name absolutely bears significance regarding the attributes of Jesus, specifically that he is God. Again, these are the words of an angel of God recorded in the Bible. You did use the word theophoric though, so you must be right. Fully God and fully human is an ontological impossibility. The prophecy is not even about Jesus, it was rehashed by Matthew or whomever edited it. At most you can call it a dual prophecyu, but that's stretching. And it's not the angel speaking those words. And Immanuel is still a human child. You can go ahead and start your own religion then, I'm just telling you what Catholics and 99.9% of all Christians throughout history believed. [link to biblestudyforcatholics.com] |