Opus Dei: Corporal Mortification | |
Old-fashioned Catholic User ID: 27789 United States 10/11/2005 04:12 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Opus Dei is composed of two parts which are quite different. One part, for married people, is more or less like a suped-up Knights of Columbus or PromiseKeepers. The other part, for celibate people, is essentially a strict religious order in every way except the legal documents. This is the primary deception that Opus Dei practices: It tells unmarried people that the organization is merely a secular institute, which it technically is under Church law; but for all practical purposes, it functions as a strict religious order, as ordinary Catholics use the term. Unmarried people should know what they are buying into when they join. As the OP described, corporal mortification in general can take many forms. Some, like the occasional forgoing of sugars and fats, are probably a good idea for most of us! Others, like the cilice and discipline, were common in medieval times as a form of voluntary suffering; but today, sensible people see these as potentially morally harmful, because they unnecessarily focus the user´s attention on his own physical body rather than on God´s glory or the needs of his fellow human. To be fair, athletes and soldiers often engage in strenuous, self-punishing activities also; but they generally do so with the specific goal of strengthening and toughening the body for specific purposes, not simply the goal of causing oneself suffering. In the Catholic Church, engaging in an activity necessary for Godīs glory or the common good, but which punishes the body as a side-effect, may be very praiseworthy; but directly punishing the body without engaging in any useful work can be an occasion of sin--at the very least, a form of sloth (laziness). Ironically, perhaps the greatest danger of Opus Dei is that it is hierarchical rather than democratic. Ancient saintly monks realized that in a religious community, the best way to prevent self-sacrifice from getting out of hand was to elect the abbot or abbess democratically. Once these communities became international networks, they again representationally elected higher levels of superiors; and this practice continues to this day in the well-known religious orders like the Franciscans, Dominicans, and Jesuits. In contrast, Opus Dei is headed autocratically by a bishop appointed by the Pope (as far as I know). This strict hierarchy, together with the traditional monastic vow of obedience, makes it too easy for an aberrant leader to hijack Opus Dei for personal agendas that are not in its official charter. |
JayRodney User ID: 409 United States 10/11/2005 04:19 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
Anonymous Coward (OP) User ID: 3492 United States 10/11/2005 04:20 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | I donīt get it. I always viewed this life as a gift from God -- and our bodies as a gift. I understand self-denial in some respects -- but why go so far as to totally trash this gift God gave? |
Anonymous Coward User ID: 2380 United States 10/11/2005 04:20 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
JayRodney User ID: 409 United States 10/11/2005 04:25 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | |
Biff User ID: 28519 United States 10/11/2005 04:26 PM Report Abusive Post Report Copyright Violation | Circle left You always hurt the one you love The one you shouldnīt hurt at all Now the men star right one time around tonight Allemande left that corner, weave the ring Yes, you always hurt the one you love Swing your lady, promenade the ring Darlinī if I broke your heart last night Itīs because I love you most of all FIGURE Well the heads promenade your lady halfway around the ring Down the middle do a right & left thru, take her home Flutter wheel and then sweep 1/4 more Pass thru and do a right & left thru Touch 1/4 now, walk & dodge and partner trade Reverse the flutter, boys keep this girl and promenade Yes, you always hurt the one you love The one you shouldnīt hurt at all *Wtfīs wrong with these people?? No wonder you have mickies doing all these strange sex things and murders. |